My Second S&W Revolver

NinjaMidget

Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2015
Messages
9
Reaction score
6
Location
Milwaukee, WI
686-1 Stainless. It has an "M" before the serial on the yoke signifying that it has been repaired due to a defect in the hammer. Models before 686-2 had this defect and were recalled to repair this defect. Serial is AUY1649. The person I got this gun from knew a little of the history behind it. It used to belong to an officer here in the West Allis police department. It was sold when the department went to the Glock 40 to this guy's brother. He acquired the gun when his brother died.

SW686-1.jpg
 
Register to hide this ad
686-1.....Serial is AUY1649.....
October 1986​

It's kind of a hair spiting thing, but it wasn't really a "defect". The gun worked fine. There was just one certain brand of primers, that were too soft. With really hot loads, the primers would flow back into the firing pin hole and prevent the cylinder from rotating.

That's what the the recall addressed. The hole was actual in a pressed in bushing, so S&W installed a new bushing with a smaller hole. That then necessitated the need for a smaller firing pin - which in those days was on the hammer and held in place with a rivet.

The defect, if you ask me, was with the primer manufacturer. (S&W remained incapable of fault... until the Lock Hole. The lock proves the Protestant theory of "original sin" ;):cool:).

That out of the way...... you got an awesome gun there. The original stocks would of been wood Targets. It looks like a LEO gun. Lots of little scratches that don't effect anything. You can tell that gun use to work for a living.

Did you know it has a trigger over-travel stop? That little off-center flat piece of metal behind the trigger. To adjust it you take the side plate off. You'll see a tiny screw head that can be adjusted to cam the stop in and out.

The stop is not a rare thing. When you look for them you'll see them all the time. A lot of the early L-frames had them. Often, when the gun was in LEO service the stops were removed as a matter of routine by police armorers. It was thought that this would improve reliability.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thanks for the info Kernel! I would agree it was more of a defect on the part of the primer manufacturer. I believe I did see the piece of metal behind the trigger. Now I'm going to have to pull it out of the safe so I can verify :)
 
A few years ago I actually had my stop work loose and kept my 586 hammer from falling. Just a target shooter though. Here is a picture of mine in the full extended position.
 

Attachments

  • DSCN5738.JPG
    DSCN5738.JPG
    188.5 KB · Views: 41
Last edited:
Now that's a really great choice for your second revolver! Congratulations. You will soon learn what fine guns these L frames are.

Regarding the "M" recall. I'm glad yours has already been done. I have two guns without the M. A 686 no dash and a Md 681. I had no intentions of sending either back for the fix, but recently I had the problem described by Kernel happen to my 686. I called S&W and they promptly sent me a prepaid shipping label and I will return the gun tomorrow. I'll write a separate post about this later.
 
Nice find, especially with knowing the LE history.

Two comments - I have seen several 680 series guns that were stamped:

M-686-x

In this case, I don't think the "M" indicates the modification KC so nicely detailed above; it the the abbreviation for "model". If it is stamped:
SN
M
M (or MOD) 686-1

then the work has been done. The M for modified may also be stamped below the model number. Either way, a call to the factory with the SN handy would confirm. Second, how unusual to have 6" 686s as duty guns? It's the first one I have seen or heard of personally. Enjoy!
 
Good to know @murphydog. Thanks for the info. I'll have to watch for that. Thanks for the info @loeman. I'll be calling S&W today to double check about the recall. @kernel, I took the cover off and verified it does, in fact still have the overtravel stop. Thanks for all the feedback on this, guys!
 
I called S&W and the hammer nose and bushing have not been replaced on this gun. Got it all packed up and FedEx is coming to pick it up today. Thanks for letting me know about that @murphydog! :)
 
Now, you are going to need a 586, for your 3rd. My 586 no dash came 1st. a -3 686 followed . Enjoy your 686! Bob
Sorry if offended anyone by posting this again!
 

Attachments

  • 001.jpg
    001.jpg
    198.7 KB · Views: 5
  • 005.jpg
    005.jpg
    195.5 KB · Views: 4
Back
Top