My ugly duckling Model 19

Looking at the top of the grips behind the trigger guard, I notice a screw that appears to go completely through the frame and sideplate. I supppose it is to add extra support to retain the grips. Am I seeing this correctly?

I think you might just be a bit thrown by how large the grips are, the upper screw goes under the frame, not through it thankfully.
 
Here's what $320 worth of Model 19 looks like:

4bytoga.jpg


SRmFxF2.jpg


I've never used these kind of rubber grips before, but they feel surprisingly great.

Probably not worth a thread but just a reminder to always be hunting for deals, the po-surp smiths aren't as common as they were (and will be getting less so), but they're still out there.

What year is it? Any known history on it?
 
I bought a new in the box 4 inch blue 19 for a little over $100. And I traded it later for a nickel 2.5 19 which I later traded for a Python. That I sold for about $200.

In 1977......
 
Finally got it out and it shot like a laser, very happy with it, though I'll be swapping out those Davis grips when I get home. They feel great in the hand but they make the revolver sit way higher up which leads the gun to flip up much more than I'd prefer.
 
It's a nice gun, a little worn but still nice. If it were mine I would probably have it hard chromed though and it would no longer be an ugly duckling.

I've had a few worn guns and sent them back to the factory for refurb. Have always wanted one hard chromed.
 
Looks like it was once evidence of a crime and lived part of its life in a police property room.

My thoughts exactly as scratching a case number into the sideplate was a common practice back then or even now. Usually there are more numbers but it could have been from a small town with little crime. Or it could not be anything evidence room related at all. Even still, that's a hot revolver OP! I'd switch the grips to something more traditional but that's just me. Nice score either way!
 
Last edited:
My thoughts exactly as scratching a case number into the sideplate was a common practice back then or even now. Usually there are more numbers but it could have been from a small town with little crime. Or it could not be anything evidence room related at all. Even still, that's a hot revolver OP! I'd switch the grips to something more traditional but that's just me. Nice score either way!

It's some PD specific number, it was part of a batch of issued police trade ins similarly equipped and marked.

It's a nice gun, a little worn but still nice. If it were mine I would probably have it hard chromed though and it would no longer be an ugly duckling.

I've had a few worn guns and sent them back to the factory for refurb. Have always wanted one hard chromed.

I'm generally of the opinion that Smiths produced in numbers as large as the 19 have nice examples cheap enough that it's not really worth refurbing/putting a new finish on this versus just selling it and buying a nicer one if I hated the finish. Luckily I don't mind having one somebody's already put the first scratches in.
 
I swapped out the grips with one of the many in my bin of po-surp takeoffs, and the ugly ducking is doing a great job in the camping gun role.

Sb4N6hd.jpg
 
Back
Top