Willcoe,
When our department transitioned from revolvers to semi autos we went with Glock 22 on duty and 27 off duty. The guns were flawless but to this day I have never owned a Glock that fit my hand well. I eventually sold them all and switched to the M&P 9c and Shield. Reliability has been equal to the Glock, they are just as accurate, fit my hand almost perfectly and in my opinion have less felt recoil. You cant go wrong with any of the guns you are considering, shoot them if possible, that will go a long way in helping with your decision. Hope this helps. J L