Nickel 19-4 1978/79, Unfired since factory? What say you?

Joined
Mar 18, 2018
Messages
96
Reaction score
383
Location
Northwestern IA
I recently picked up this 19-4 4 inch nickel at a gun show. It came with box, tools and paperwork and a mystery. I have read that S&W revolvers were test fired at the factory with a round in every other charge hole. This gun has only a burn ring on every other cylinder hole. Now since the serial # puts it at 1978/79 production is it possible that after 47 years it may have never been fired? The cylinder shows a very light turn line with a light wear mark on the hammer possibly from handling over the years ? It had a light yellowish glaze on parts of the nickel that cleaned up with some Flitz. Now the second part of the mystery: the gun has no Mod 19-4 stamp in the frame yoke cut. The serial # is there. The reason I ask is that I own three other 19-4,s , a 2 1/2 in blue from 1977, a 4 in blue from 1980 and a 2 1/2 nickel also from 1980. They all have Mod 19-4 in the yoke cut. Is it possible this one made it out of the factory without a model marking ? The box is labeled 19-4 and serialed to the gun. I will attach some pictures.IMG_4794.JPGIMG_4797.JPGIMG_4800.JPGIMG_4804.JPGIMG_4849.JPGIMG_4851.JPGIMG_4853.JPGIMG_4833.JPG
 
Register to hide this ad
Occasionally you will see one that the fitter forgot to mark. No big deal.

Also, 42K numbers were used in 1978. It could have shipped in '79, but that is a 1978 production number.
 
Maybe, but maybe he shot it cleaned it and fired three. It's all about the condition and I would hate to leave a gun "dirty" on the hopes someone down the round would believe it was unfired from the factory. It isn't a rare gun so I wouldn't feel bad shooting it and cleaning it.
 
Maybe, but maybe he shot it cleaned it and fired three. It's all about the condition and I would hate to leave a gun "dirty" on the hopes someone down the round would believe it was unfired from the factory. It isn't a rare gun so I wouldn't feel bad shooting it and cleaning it.
I fully intend to shoot it. I never buy safe queens but I do try to keep them in good condition.
 
Thanks for the reply but based on the cylinder burn rings do you think it has not been fired since factory?
If it were mine I'd hope it had only been fired at the factory, but those burn rings are pretty prominent and I'm thinking what Vtgw938 mentioned, that three of the charge holes were cleaned to give the impression of it being unfired since the factory. The turn line would tend to support that. If I had (and I do) a nickel gun that I wanted to keep as new as possible, I would not be turning the cylinder much, or at all. I've got a nickel M29-2 commemorative I bought used, and I have not fired it myself but I can't swear the previous owner(s) haven't either. It has the barest of turn lines, and only three burn marks but they too were very faint. The recoil shield, like yours, has no evidence of case heads wearing it either. I've cleaned the gun several times and there are no burn marks at all that can be seen now.

I wouldn't worry about it though, you have a very nice M19, the last P&R series
 
I judge by the recoil shield,
Need good clear pictures of that.
The alternate burn marks on the cylinder are easily faked.
Pics are dark and blurry but the stocks look modified at the football cut,
Did they come with that gun and are they modified?
If yes to both more proof the gun has been fired.
 
The pics are too blurry to be certain but doesn't appear to have the telltale case head imprints on the recoil shield, you will be able to judge having it in hand but looks nice and clean.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top