Pachmayr vs. Hogue

[Navy1969]

For the S&W 642, the Smith & Wesson Company told me I have a square butt, meaning it is 1 1/4" or wider at the base of the stock. I ordered and returned an Ebay Hogue which they said would fit , but didn't fit. I am now looking at Packmayr which DOES make a grip, square butt, for the 642 and appears to have a hardy grip for recoil issues shooting the 38 +P and regular 39 Special. Square butts are rare and can be a frustrating search.

 

[BB57]

For me, it depends on the frame size, and what I am shooting in it.

For example, I like Hogue Monogrips on my J-frame revolvers, particularly the Model 60s that get shot occasionally with .357 Magnum. I like them a bit less on my SP101, mostly because the grip gets a little too skinny down low - but then I like my SP101 less than my S&Ws anyway, so it kinda fits...

However, I've noted than the Hogue Monogrip on a K-frame interferes slightly with my HKS speed loaders. But that's not all bad as I really like the Pachmayr Compact grips on my K-frame sized .357 magnums. It's comfortable to shoot, but still small enough to be easily concealed with an IWB holster. I also like the same grip on my Ruger Speed Six.

When it comes to my 6" Model 19, my 4" Model 15, and my recently acquired 6" Model 66, I despise them both and prefer the S&W wood target stocks. They are perfect for .38 Special target loads, and work fine for the occasional .357 Mag in a 19 or 66, and they look a whole lot better than any rubber grip.

 

[Navy1969]

S&W Model 642; Grip Selection

You have a fine selection of weaponry. Thank you for your advice on the Packmayr. I will most likely go with Packmayr re form and function. The stock grip is way too small for my large hands and can still conceal with out notice. Take care, and watch your back. Pat.