In the realm of collectible handguns, it
matters, it more than matters, as to collectibility and collectible value, what was available as new and original from the factory are literally precisely where the value lies for something of that nature.
If I'm not being clear, let me say it this way:
If S&W offered a PPC-9 chambered in .38 Super
and it was a very short run but you could, at one time, order it from them exactly as described, a high condition example of that would be worth a silly TON of money in the collectible gun market.
However... they did not. It does not exist. Now if you took a PPC-9 and with skill and patience and tools, you re-chambered it to .38 Super, that would be neat but on the collectible gun market, all you've done is attacked it's value.
In your post there are a couple points to address:
Sevens I dont think it matters. That money for any P/C gun unless the first one or last one is out there. I guess the color scheme makes it rarer for collectors but doesnt mean that much to shooters.
Maybe 15 or 20 years ago,
shooters and competitors drove the market for these guns, but that is no longer relevant here in the year 2022. There exists nearly no shooter that's going to pay market ($4,500 to $8,500) for a 6-inch long slide S&W PC gun, or far beyond $8,500 for the 1-of-14 or 1-of-17 exclusive two-tone blackened 6-inch 952-2.
The only folks who will pay that kind of money (other than one random outlier who goes to bed at 11pm and has his wife stay up until 2am bidding in $25 increments) (yes, specifically that happened) (pay eight grand for a pistol they intend to whack steel with) are folks who are chasing it because it is elite, rare and valuable.
If they are still making 952s couldnt you order one polished up like you want or doesnt S/W do that kind of stuff anymore.
They are so very much not making anything in the hemisphere of 952's anymore. The folks that work there don't even recognize a 952, you'd be lucky to have them shuffle the deck and find one person at work on a given day who knows what a 952 even is (or was) and they certainly have no plans and no skill on staff to produce them ever again.
Pretty sure they will not do tricky finishes to a short-run hand fitted pistol from 12-30 years ago when the real Performance Center existed.
Time and Smith & Wesson has moved on. These guns have a following because they are elite and came from a very short period of absolute greatness.
952's, 845's, 3566 Limited and PPC-9's have as much relationship to S&W today as a Bren Ten. I mean to say... zero.
The only thing a PPC-9 has in common with S&W in the year 2022 is the name emblazoned on it. There is no relationship between these guns and the current company. It's exactly like I said in another recent thread, calling up Springfield and talking to S&W now about a 952 is like stopping at your local Chevrolet dealer to ask them about a 1969 COPO Camaro. You've got just as much chance of success if you ask that car dealership about Eli Whitney's cotton gin. They have no relationship to a COPO Camaro.