pocket holster for snubnose J-frame

[rockquarry]

I know little about holsters of any kind and have never had much interest in them, but lately have wondered about the "pocket holster" for a J-frame snubnose. It seems such a holster might offer a safety advantage over pure pocket carry, but I don't know this for sure.

My interest would be in something made of thin leather rather than a synthetic material. Any comments on such holsters and their usefulness or lack of the same? I'm not a quick draw maestro or aspiring gunfighting ace, so fast draw is not a big concern.

 

[diyj98]

I'm a big pocket holster fan. Pocket holsters are just like in any other style holster in that everyone has their favorite(s). I like the Desantis Nemesis holsters, but those are synthetic. I have a couple Mika's pocket holsters which many swear by, but I prefer the Nemesis. for my own use. There's lots of options. used to use a cheap Uncle Mike's pocket holster with my LCP when I carried that.

 

[crazyphil]

It seems that there are a lot of gun folks who swear by the DeSantis Nemesis, including me. It doesn't cost much either. I would suggest
you try it, just to see if you like pocket carry.

 

[shell627]

I have custom leather pocket holsters and production nylon and kydex.By far I prefer Mika pocket holsters.And from a safety standpoint a handgun carried in a pocket should be in a holster.

 

[Marshal Tom]

The advantage to using one is that the gun will stay in place if the holster is formed correctly. It will also reduce printing. Not to worry about becoming a quick draw maestro from the pocket, not going to happen! All types work just fine. Some like Mika's have material on the outside to make the holster stick inside the pocket on the draw, others have a lip or hook at the bottom to prevent the holster from coming out on the draw. I have used leather and synthetic but mostly just stick it in my pocket. If carrying without a holster, put nothing else in the pocket that could interfere with the trigger or the draw!

 

[Borderboss]

When I was pocket carrying my Kahr PM-9, I used the FIST kydex pocket holster, and it worked great.

When I moved to pocket carrying my S&W 940 J-frame, I went with a Mika holster. I like it a lot. I would highly recommend the Mika.

 

[THE PILGRIM]

Have several by different makers.
Another DeSantis vote here.

 

[jim0383]

Cheap leather: Don Hume Pocket Holster
Good leather: Milt Sparks Pocket Holster

Both will offer better weapon retention and trigger protection than any "soft" holsters.

Leather I DON'T recommend: Galco pocket holsters (Suede or horsehide)

 

[hyena]

My main carry is a J frame. I have two pocket holsters for it: the Desantis Nemesis and the Mika. I much prefer the Mika.

My other main carry is a BG380. I have two pocket holsters for it: the Nemesis and the Mika. I prefer the Nemesis. Although I do opt for the Mika with a certain pair of jeans.

Weird, huh?

My suggestion - as cheap as they are, buy a Nemesis and a Mika.

 

[Onomea]

For my 640-1, I have a horsehide, boned Kramer and a loose fitting Mika. For looks, the Kramer. In terms of usage, the Mika. The Kramer will come out of my pocket when I draw it unless I work the leather off first, or twist my hand when I draw. The Mika, being a loose fit, slips right out, holster in place, and is easy to drop the gun back in.

For OWB I like Mitch Rosen's holsters. I bought a Rosen pocket holster for my Detective Special but, like the Kramer, it would come out of my pocket when drawing. (High quality stuff though.) Sold it.

My conclusion is Mika. It's lined, synthetic leather of some sort, and no great shakes in the looks department, but it is well made and works well.

As for retention, I don't want retention in a pocket holster. The pocket itself is all the retention I need. I want smooth access.

 

[s&wchad]

I pocket carry a J frame most of the time. I wouldn’t do it without a proper holster that covers the trigger guard and keeps the butt upright.

Here’s a photo of some that I’ve accumulated:

On the left is an old Pachmayr “T.A.C. Tactical” pocket gizmo. It replaces the grips, carries extra ammo and keeps the butt upright. Interesting idea, but it doesn’t cover the trigger guard, is hard on pockets, eliminates grip choices and smacks you on the knuckle when shooting. I’m also not sure how the ATF views these.

Next column has (3) Kramers and an Alessi. The middle Kramer shows the outside. The outside of the Alessi is also flat and looks like a wallet in your pocket. They’re both excellent choices. I picked up the extra Kramers used as spares, but I doubt you could wear one out in a lifetime.

Top of the next column is an old Ahern pocket natural. I used one for about 10 years, but switched to a Kramer. The gun was able to move too much inside the holster, which caused excessive wear on the finish. It also soaked up perspiration and destroyed some pockets.

Below that is a Milt Sparks holding my 342Ti, which is my current favorite. It’s very comfortable and is almost perfect! I bought it second hand and believe it’s sharkskin. Some slacks don’t have pockets wide enough to accommodate it, so in those cases I use a Kramer.

On the far right is a PC 327 (N frame) in a Mika. It makes for great winter coat pocket carry. He makes a quality product at a very reasonable price. You can get them with either a round or square bottom, depending on the type of pocket you have. They’re extremely durable and Bob is great guy to deal with. I had several J frame Mika’s, but gave them to a friend who wanted a pocket holster for himself and his son.

 

[mikerjf]

I have a Azula from ebay that looks like the Ahern above... natural with the rough side out. Love it.

 

[firefighterjohn]

I've had great luck with the inexpensive Uncle Mike's for my 637 which even has a Pachmeyer grip (3 finger grip) and it works great. The 637 "disappears" in my pocket and the draws are easy. The holster stays right in my pocket when I draw...practice draws that is.

 

[dirty & hairy]

Semi-retired(?) artisan Karla Van Horne makes a fine pocket holster. I believe she is still selling them. Check out Purdy Gear Custom leather Goods.

 

[rockquarry]

Thanks very much to all the respondents so far. Lots of good information for me and probably others have also derived some benefit-

 

[KalamazooKid]

Been pocket carrying with a Mika Pocket Holster for 10+ years. Either my 340PD or this model 60.

 

[lawandorder]

You might have noticed in the replies and recommendations above

....that there is a wide variety. What A swears by might not work at all for B. Everyone is different.

The holster selection process is as personal as the choice of firearms.

It becomes a trial and error process and thats why most folks have a box of leather (or a closet full).

You are on the right course. It is best to pocket carry with the weapon in a holster and as been stated one that covers the trigger guard.
Also reccomended don't carry anything in that pocket except the weapon and its holster.

Most folks buy a weapon that costs a considerable sum. Don't skimp on your holster , get a good quality one even if it costs a few $s more.

Also if you do that you won't have to buy a new one every year or so.

The one in my pocket has been there nearly every day since the spring of 2004 still in good functional condition.

And.........

Practice, practice, practice and practice some more.

God bless.

 

[3rdRRU_PhuBai]

Been pocket carrying with a Mika Pocket Holster for 10+ years. Either my 340PD or this model 60.

Another vote for Mika's Pocket Holsters. I have two, one for warm weather J-frame pocket and one for G30 cargo pocket or winter jacket pocket.
Mika's Pocket Holsters

 

[6917sctygrp]

Just a Word of Caution

I know little about holsters of any kind and have never had much interest in them, but lately have wondered about the "pocket holster" for a J-frame snubnose. It seems such a holster might offer a safety advantage over pure pocket carry, but I don't know this for sure.

My interest would be in something made of thin leather rather than a synthetic material. Any comments on such holsters and their usefulness or lack of the same? I'm not a quick draw maestro or aspiring gunfighting ace, so fast draw is not a big concern.

Just a word of caution, I think you want something rigid enough so that if you happen to lean against anything it can't force the holster material into the trigger guard and depress the trigger. Soft feels better but a thicker leather would be safer. I prefer an AIWB holster both for access and safety.

 

[Fortcouragearmory]

The DeSantis Nemesis is the one I carry every day for my 442. The outside of the holster is “sticky” enough to stay behind when you draw the weapon and the shape of the holster breaks up the obvious outline if a 2” revolver in your pocket. My suggestion to to see if you can try out several different ones before making up your mind.