Post Your Very First 5-Screw S&W

Joined
Oct 9, 2006
Messages
7,568
Reaction score
50,594
Location
AZ
I was waxing a little nostalgic today so I pulled out my records and was reminded that in March 2007 I purchased my very first 5-screw S&W - what a journey it has been since then.:) This Highway Patrolman was on GunBroker with a no reserve starting price and some terrible photos. In addition, it was filthy and had a set of mismatched grips, one panel was a diamond PC magna (probably from a model 58) and the other a regular non diamond magna. So I put in a max bid for $300, and won it at $270 plus $20 shipping.:D After cleaning it up, I purchased a set of Patrick Grasshorn's finest and sometime later, I found a period correct box. So here she is:





I would love to see some photos of your First 5-screw S&W and a little bit of its story would also be fun.

Thanks for letting me share,
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
1931 K-22 I got off consignment. It had been in the case less than a week.

pAsPd4Fh.jpg
 
It was 2003 and I found a 1907 38 M&P that I just could not pass up for the $175 asking price,and prior to that I concentrated on antique S&Ws. It had two things goning for it. First was the serial number, 100007 and the 6 1/2" long barrel sealed the deal.

I still own it and shoot it from time to time. Richard, your comment on what a journey it has been since then is right on the mark. This was my first "modern" S&W and now my safe is full of 1899 to 1950s S&Ws. Unfortunetly, they have displaced most of my antique S&Ws. A safe is only so large you know.:D
 

Attachments

  • P2140004.jpg
    P2140004.jpg
    67.1 KB · Views: 249
  • P1010004.jpg
    P1010004.jpg
    84.1 KB · Views: 249
I've shared this story before.

I inherited my Grandfather's LEO 38/44 Outdoorsman. It shipped in 1940. He carried it, as a Motor Officer and Patrolman for about 10 years (by my estimation). At some point he replaced the pre-war magnas with some custom targets (with a cut out to show his engraved name on the sideplate). I have found some post-war diamond magnas to serve as stand-ins until I find the period correct stocks. Other than the stocks, everything is his original set-up.

This old gun has quickly become the pride of my array of firearms.

mYE3rr2.jpg

cEjjrYK.jpg

kryxte7.jpg

uBAAiGb.jpg
 
The HFT was my second handgun ever not long after I turned 21 as I wanted a 22LR revolver at the time. The collecting got out of hand as a result of picking up my first 44spl years later in a MS pawn shop.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1605.jpg
    IMG_1605.jpg
    151 KB · Views: 147
  • IMG_4442.JPG
    IMG_4442.JPG
    177.6 KB · Views: 136
My first five screw is this S&W .44 Magnum (Pre Model 29). It was shipped in June of 1956. It has some warts and the "Coke" grips were replaced with diamond targets and the target trigger and target hammer were replaced with standard width trigger and hammer at some time in its past. It obviously wore some type of rubber grips at one time as it has bluing loss that would correspond with that type of grips.

This was the gun that started my S&W sickness. It is a great shooter that locks up like a bank vault. While its not pristine, its not bad for "an early 1970's gun (per the gun store employee) that was bought for $400 OTD.



 
Unfortunately no pictures since I no longer have any of them. Back in 1975 I had a Hi Standard 44 Automag,it was fun while it lasted but a pain chasing the brass. So I traded it one day. I walked out with a 1917 the finish was a brown patina all over but it shot great even with cast bullets. Also a Model 1905 4th change (I believe) target 38 special. Nicks and scratches made it about maybe 90%. But it had one chamber slightly bulged at the cylinder notch,still shot great with but I usually only loaded 5 rounds at a time. Then the last one was a Model 1950 Target 45ACP. Also got 2 boxes of 45ACP and 3 boxes of 38 Special ammo thrown in. If I recall the trade value of the Automag was placed at $500. If I only knew then what I found out years later.
 
This is fun.
Maybe 5-6 years ago I got to wanting one of the early ones. My first was a model of 1905 , built 1909. I never get tired of looking at the grips. The lanyard ring is a nice bonus.
Worn , but tight and good.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1084.jpg
    IMG_1084.jpg
    157.1 KB · Views: 181
Pictures?, If I had any they'd be from an Insta'matic.

S&W HD 38-44 38sp 5" bbl Nickel finish.
Backstrap factory roll marked T.T.P. 46 (Tonawanda Township Police 46)
ser# 266058
Factory letter stated shipped with 9 others to a distributor in Buffalo NY. Can't recall the name, maybe 'Reed's' or something close to that.

Tonawanda is a city north of Buffalo, Tonawanda Township is more commonly known as Kenmore, NY (Village within the Town) also north side of Buffalo.
I've seen 3 or 4 other HD's all nickel 5" marked the same over the years. Different rack #'s.

Bought it in 1967. Cost $45.00 from a small garage dealer in Holley, NY.
Condition near exc.
Went back when I gathered the extra $$ and bought the 5" blued pre-war M&P he had later on. That one was $40.

Both long gone, sold or traded for something much much better.
But I have no idea what.
 
After seeing all these beautiful old guns, I have to admit it; I only have one five screw S&W.

My 1950 Army that a previous owner had evidently stored in its holster, but shows little actual signs of having been fired more than a few times.

IMG-0401.jpg

IMG-0405.jpg

IMG-0408.jpg

IMG-0409.jpg

IMG-0410.jpg

IMG-0412.jpg

IMG-0414.jpg

IMG-0417.jpg

IMG-0418.jpg


When I went to post some photos, I realized the shots I had taken several years ago were too pathetic for posting, so I stopped and snapped the above shots a few minutes ago.
 
A good yarn posted in 2016. Bringing it back up for an excellent thread!

Passing through Northern Minnesota, is usually a bone chilling journey, but summers are sweltering. In this instance, it was mid-July 2012, 100% humidity, 95 degrees, and haying season was coming to an end (we only get one cutting per year). Finished product was being shipped to local barns and equipment greased for next years' service. We had to travel between many small fields scattered around the swampy and heavily wooded Norhtland. A very labor intensive process. As the day cooled off, we were all looking forward to the end of season party! Big get together including whole pig rotisserie, deviled eggs, and crack your teeth cold Premium Grainbelt! When I say "we," I mean two families that have helped each other for many years caring for animals and the community. My family, and pal, Tyrel's family are synonymous in cultivating the crop, but he is much more prominent as a local business owner. His awesome display of persuasion is explained on the last day of harvest.

Finally, our concluding trip with the destination, PARTY! Our three quarter ton pickup hauling a 22 foot goose-neck trailer loaded with round and square bales, and a tired out 1950 tractor lumbered down the road. We were dog tired, not saying much, but a white sign stuck out of the ditch. That is odd in this country. It said MTA Timber Hall Convention. MTA? "Oh," Ty says. "This is the Minnesota Trappers Association Convention." "We should swing in for a quick look. They may have some scents, beaver castor or guns. What are you looking for Dave?" I said, "The only thing I'm looking for right now are a few Smith, in particular, a 5 screw pre-29 4 inch. Don't have one of those yet. And probably won't see one of those on a table for a long time." Holy! I would eat those words!!! We stopped the caravan at the Timber Hall, and it is dead. Dealers are talking to each other and some have relinquished themselves back to their campers. About 6 tables are still rolling, and on the last table out the door, there is a black case, S&W logo, and DO NOT TOUCH sign!

"Um, can I see that?" Craig, the dealer, looked unappreciative down his wide brimmed hat at my deplorable condition. "I suppose," he says. The case opens, and queue angelic music. Five Screw Four Inch Pre-29! Oh, yeah, BTW Jinks letter had to be peeled off the top of the gun. I wanted it!!! Whew! Then Ty says, "Hey! That's what you've been looking for!" Busted. "Yes, Ty, I know." "Excuse me, may I confer with my friend." Craig waffles, "why, by all means. You sound like you know your S&W's"

"Ty! I have to get this revolver! He wants $2250. I do not have the skrilla on me, and 1600 on Saturday, we cannot get it!" Ty smiles, he knows something… He says, "Brenda (Ty's mother) is horseback riding with the bank manager right now. Let me give them a call. You go back and deal on the revolver." Really, the bank manager of the Credit Union! Oh, happy day! "Craig, cash, right now, what is the price?" Craig, "$2000." Me, "One hour, done!" Of course, the how much are you going to put down is thrown out there. And I kid you not, I reached in my pocket to pull out three sweaty $20 bills stuck with hay seeds. But he took them!

The bank was not far away, half mile at most. Caravan parked out front, we sat on the green treated steps. Not far off in the distance, there were two horses bellies swinging back and forth. The riders side by side, laughing and pointing in our direction. When they arrived, it was something that would only occur in a small town. "Come on in," as the bank manager swings open the safe door. "How much do you need?" she inquires. "Uh, $2K." I say. Well, how else do you grovel for money!? "Here! That should do! Pay me back next week." She says. Seriously!

Back to the MTA Show! Cash in hand, caravan, and now a couple of horses. Solo, I walk in and approach Craig, "Well, you got it." Money on the table. "Incredible…" He was disappointed, and I was elated! "Well," he says, "you better take this too." He throws a gorgeous vintage leather holster on the table. "It came with it." I came out of the Timber Hall just glowing. Gun in holster with case in hand. Brenda says, "Hey! Give me that! It is mine for the ride home!" Brenda strapped the holster and 5 screw on her hip, gave a Wahoo! And full gallop off to the party!

Here is the piece with holster - I have a picture with Brenda, holster, horse et al. but she has not given consent to post it here, yet :)

salox-albums-pre-29-s-picture14622-5-screw-4-a.jpg


salox-albums-pre-29-s-picture14635-image7.jpg


salox-albums-pre-29-s-picture14630-image-3-a.jpg


salox-albums-pre-29-s-picture14634-image6.jpg


salox-albums-pre-29-s-picture14629-image-2-a.jpg


salox-albums-pre-29-s-picture14633-image-6-a.jpg


salox-albums-pre-29-s-picture14636-image8.jpg


salox-albums-pre-29-s-picture14627-myres.jpg


salox-albums-pre-29-s-picture14628-myres-8-a.jpg
 
Back
Top