you're right-------You never should have opened this thread.
I feel your pain!
I have 8 different bullets (multiple calibers) that either I have extensive work ups or in the middle of or just starting. I've played with several powders, primers, etc. I have all my logs filled out - chrono data, pics of targets.
I was almost done
These guys forced me into trying bayou's 158 grain SWC's.
I haven't loaded or shot them yet - but those gator snots are just sitting there harassing me. I want to put them to the back of the line and let them wait their turn - - but NOOO - this topic won't go away - they'll be a Part 3 and a Part 4, etc
I cast/pc coat over 30 different bullets right now. The only thing that I've found different is the velocities. Same firearm, same bullet, same brass, powder primers, yada/yada/yada. If the firearm likes a load it doesn't matter if that load is the traditional cast/lubed bullet or the cast/pc'd bullets. They both are accurate & in most cases the pc bullet is more accurate (smaller groups) that their traditional counterpart for the same load.
The only real difference I see is the chronograph results, the pc'd bullets have a higher velocity for the same load than their traditional counterparts.
Personally I feel that the coated bullets have a better fit/seal due to the coating process. It anneals the bullets making them soft which it turn allows them to expand/seal the cylinders & bbl's better/easier. I've had the air cooled pc'd bullets up to 1800+fps without any leading & the wd (water dropped) pc'd bullets up to 2700fps without any leading.