@Dave686
Do you really believe S&W still makes the best revolvers in the world?
I certainly don't. No offense, but your statement actually sounds laughable to me!
I'm pretty sure most everyone here would agree that Korth and Manurhin build a higher quality revolver than S&W, just as they should for 3-5x the price (or more) of a comparable S&W.
Colt is making some very nice double action revolvers again too. Aside from some minor production problems with early ones, their quality and consistency is a step or two above a modern S&W as well.
Even if you exclude Colt, Korth & Manurhin, I'm not convinced that S&W is still in a league above Ruger and Taurus. It seems that Ruger as a company has figured this out too, considering the MSRP for a basic stainless Ruger GP100 is now $1029 compared to MSRP of $893 for a comparable S&W 686. Gone are the days of Ruger being a lower cost alternative to S&W.
I do believe S&W is still CAPABLE of building quality revolvers, albeit without the fit and finish of their older ones. If you carefully look over enough of them you're bound to find some good ones among many that are subpar. Even when you do find a good one, be prepared for it to have a canted barrel/front sight and some minor finish issues.
As you said, Dave686, the main issues with S&W are their quality control and customer service. It used to be that if you were unlucky enough to get a bad gun at least you knew it would be fixed properly under warranty. Not any more! Many people are having to send guns in multiple times for the same issue. Nothing like adding insult to injury.
Nobody can build a revolver as good as s&w for the price of a S&W.
Colts cost nearly twice as much, with an insanely long trigger reset and a side plate that stops the trigger functioning if you don't tighten it often enough. I sold mine because I hated the trigger. Colt triggers are horrible to me.
The french and german guns go through so much testing and firing that if there were anything wrong, they would get fixed. Send your s&w to a custom shop.
S&W has a few rounds test fired and very basic specification checks. S&W could solve ALL of their problems if they cut multi million dollar salaries by a few percent, tightened tolerances, and did real QC. They don't need to because less than 1% of guns have these problems. Considering that sub 1%, they are still the best in the game, bar none. Best gun I own is a 66-8 with the new lockup
Any company with millions of dollars CAN make a better gun, including S&W. Manhurin and Korth make copies of s&w with upgraded parts, 10x as much labor, for 10% increase in performance. Let me know when any other revolver is recommended by everyone for everyone, and for every task.