Restoration Projects - Successes & Failures

GunarSailors

US Veteran
Joined
Jun 22, 2014
Messages
1,182
Reaction score
3,855
Location
Mechanicsville, Virginia
I always love to see things in really sad shape, being brought back to their former glory, or as close to it as possible. For me with this project it was about this heirloom deserving a better ending than just being a "truck gun". One of my most successful projects was this model 15-2. Ironically a couple of my bigger failures involved this same gun. I would like to see any project that you have taken on that were either a great success or an epic failure.

This story starts in the late 70's when my dad was a police officer in my hometown. The model 15-2 below was given to my dad by some people he knew, after their son (a young man) had committed suicide with it. It did have some pretty good bluing damage from the incident but it had a great trigger and shot wonderfully. I immediately took a liking to the gun and by the early 80's our whole family knew that gun as being my gun. It may sound a little funny but it wasnt uncommon for me to have my model 15-2 in my holster, walking around the house. Probably younger than 10 years old, and my mom & dad didnt have a worry in the world. They knew that I was extremely conscious of the status of any gun in my hands. I remember being real young when my dad would come home in uniform for dinner, it was almost an everyday occurrence for me to ask him if I could look at his model 686 service revolver after dinner. At first he would unload it for me but by the early 1980's both my parents knew that he could just hand me a loaded gun and I would do the exact same thing (unload it) immediately without hesitation.
By my high school years in the late 80's I had put my model 15-2 in and out of a holster quite a few times. So in my infinite wisdom, I decided to reblue my model 15-2 in shop class at school (with the schools permission). What a failure that was, I am glad I didnt take pictures documenting that. It was before Youtube, my teacher was my only guidance and he was a moron. I didnt know the difference between cold bluing and hot bluing, I was 14 years old. The stripping off of the factory bluing was the easy part...
I at least had enough sense to realize I was in over my head and took the model 15-2 to a gunsmith to have him send it off for a professional rebluing. It came back, I paid the bill but was never happy with the bluing job. I remember thinking just that it was better than what I could do, but the barrel had more of a brownish tint and you could almost see buffing mark like tigerstripes going up the barrel. It didnt look very good. I dont have any pictures to document that either. Over the course of the next 25 years I shot the heck out of that model 15-2, and as you can imagine the finish was getting pretty worn again. Once again, in my infinite wisdom, I let a buddy try to Duracoat my model 15-2 (the epic failure part). It looked more like it was dipped in concrete.

THE BEFORE PICTURE :

2015-01-20-17-33-18_zpsy0oxwb0s.png


It didnt take long to realize that I had to do something with the model 15-2. So I called around to different gunsmiths who all were not very enthusiastic about restoring my gun, and I cant say that I blamed them. Not to mention how many hours it would take/how much money it would end up costing. So I opted to try my luck at refinishing it myself again. This time with a little more age and patience under my belt.
2015-01-20-17-32-22_zpsvianyr5v.png

20140425_165927_zpsxscjsrnv.jpeg


I did pay a local gunsmith to media blast the Duracoating off, but it did leave an orange peel texture on the metal, and as you can see uncovered some pitting.
20140608_1349412_zpscmvnvbvn.jpeg

20140608_1349273_zps3vpqitqb.jpeg

20140608_153937_zpsowiqxyap.jpeg


I started sanding and polishing with 600, 800 and 1000 grit sandpaper. Carefully trying to keep the flat spots flat with the help of a small flat sanding block.
20140608_113342_zps2ioz8kyc.jpeg

20140610_173757_zps5qhh1cj0.jpeg

20140610_173424_zpssrnlyp3t.jpeg

20140610_173335_zpstogmg1pd.jpeg


While I was at it I cut a dovetail in the front sight... Like I was going to hurt the value any more than I already had.
20141220_182943_zps6pstxcmn.jpg


Ready for bluing so I found a different local gunsmith than the guys who media blasted it, he was willing to fire up the burners under his bluing tanks and let me dip my model 15-2 (using all of his equipment). That is his hand adding water with the ladle, making sure the temperature was just right. He only charged me $30 but I left a $50 bill just to show my appreciation.
20150118_152317_zpsh5ocyoz5.jpg

20150118_152254_zps2lzpjsb3.jpg


In case anyone is wondering, I did end up completely wiping out the S&W logo on the sideplate during the process of removing the case number engraved (rather poorly) by the police dept evidence room. I hated doing it, but its just the way it is.
20150118_172957_zpsvpgmeiom.jpg

20150118_172909_zpslfhaxbor.jpg


Poured the new front sight insert...
S&W Red Ramp Insert - Tips & Pics | The Outdoors Trader
20150304_085432_zpsanjxls5u.jpg


A new set of factory stocks, a period correct hammer & trigger, and a .126 rear sight blade with a W/O.

THE END RESULT :
20160319_125547_zpsehosnnda.jpg

20160319_125600-1_zpstbuawxwp.jpg


The coolest part for me is that I did all the work. Since the gun has so much history with me, the fact that I basically removed the S&W logo on the sideplate doesnt bother me too much. I would say my model 15-2 project ended up being a success. Lets see your projects!
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
It looks good now,you for sure saved that one. I have restored many Smiths in the past I used to be notorious for buying the roughest looking Smiths and rebluing them, I have many mint Smiths too but I did enjoy buying a rough one and spending hours making them look new again.
Several years ago while cruising on GB I found a decent looking Model 10 for around $125 and it wasn't getting any attention and I won the auction. While completing the payment and FFL I contacted the store that was up North (New York) as I recall and the older store owner informed me that they had several dozen rough old S&Ws that he said he "couldn't give away" I ended up over time purchasing several of them mostly 10s,15s and a few 19s. I didn't give over 200 for any of them and I recall my gun buddies telling me "you bought that??" but when I would finish one they all tried their best to buy them. I miss those days I did have a lot more time and patience then. You did a great job and have a neat story.
 
Reference the side plate emblem: Possibly it could be re-stamped or re-cut ?
I do know that Fords Guns in Florida could have redone the logo on the sideplate. But they wanted the whole gun when I talked to them about it before I moved overseas. I really just ran out of time.
 
Congratulations on the completion of this very successful restoration project. The pictures sure make the verbiage a lot clearer.

An old gun shop owner in South Georgia has mentioned several times - "I'd much rather own an older gun than one of these new ones!" This is certainly what he means. I don't believe that any of the plastics/polymers that are so popular today could look this great or even be restored.

They just don't make them like they used to make them!

Did you take your front sight insert kit to Denmark with you??

Thread Drift, but humorous: I have read a few posts in our forum about the canted barrel issue. Now I find myself looking at the barrel cant for every one that I own or see in a LGS.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top