Return of the Model 19

Joined
Mar 14, 2012
Messages
2,997
Reaction score
2,952
Location
Fairbanks, Alaska
My first Smith & Wesson was a brand-new 6" Model 19 that I bought in 1979. I liked it so much, I bought a 2 ½" M-19, in nickel, a few months later. I couldn't hit anything with the 2 inch, and didn't like it at all. I thought the sights were defective, or the barrel was bent or something. I sold it to a fellow officer without mentioning the poor accuracy. He later told me that it was one of the best shooters he ever had. In fact, he routinely scored 100's with it on qualifying day. Reality checks can be hard on your ego.
I sold the 6" when my kids were old enough to explore the house, and have friends over. I didn't want any handguns in my house during that time.
For the past dozen years, I've been buying, shooting, and, tinkering with used, inexpensive K frame Smith & Wessons. It's become a not-too-costly hobby, and I've put together a fairly nice representation of older K frame revolvers. Noticeably missing from the bunch was a Model 19. Until now.
The first thing I noticed when I picked up my (circa 1984) Model 19-5 from the FFL was its heft. The wide ribbed heavy barrel and shrouded ejector rod made it seem a LOT heavier than my other K frames. Then I noticed the long hammer spur. It just seemed easier to reach than my other guns. The action was super smooth, and this is the only gun that I have that doesn't have a trigger shoe attached. The .4" target trigger is just right. It came to me with Pachmayr grips, which I replaced with my favorite kind of grips, and it now fits in quite well with the rest of my rag-tag collection of shooters, beaters, and misfits.
I'm on record as saying that the M&P .38 from the mid '50s is the ultimate Smith & Wesson revolver. This new gun has me thinking that that honor should rightfully go to the Model 19.
 
Register to hide this ad
My '68 6" M19 is awesome. Relatively light, accurate and the action is 'it'. I love shooting SWC's through it in something like PPC competitions.

Great hobby you have!
 
I like the M19 a lot. But I have a NIB (S/N'd box), unfired, tools, paperwork, the whole deal, 19-4 from 1979-1980. I have only "checked" (tried, dry fired) the trigger a few times. Maybe it needs to be "used" a bit more, but it has a god-awful trigger pull! DA or SA. Maybe the older ones had better triggers, out of the box.
It's ok though, I don't really know when, if ever, it will be fired, by me at least. It was one of four S&W revolvers that I bought at an estate sale. All unfired, with box, paperwork, tools, etc...

I have shot the 1955 Target, M25-2 though. It's SWEET!
 
Love to have seen the nickle 19.

My first Smith & Wesson was a brand-new 6" Model 19 that I bought in 1979. I liked it so much, I bought a 2 ½" M-19, in nickel, a few months later. ]
Mike...I've never seen a nickel 2.5" 19. I bet it was a beauty. I have a Model 19, 2.5" that I purchased in October 1971 for $135.00 new. It is a real shooter. That's it in my avatar in a Tucker pancake. I just qualified w/ it under LEOSA.

That's nice 6" you have.

If I had my pick of the litter of 19s, it would have to be the 4", M19 Combat Masterpiece. - 'ole joe.
 
That's nice 6" you have.

If I had my pick of the litter of 19s, it would have to be the 4", M19 Combat Masterpiece. - 'ole joe.

Sure is!
Mine is the 4", it too is a beauty. But I really like that 6" M19
 
I'm not surprised at the accuracy of the Model 19 snubby. I have a Model 19-3 nickel 2 1/2" that is startlingly accurate. I think it's mostly the shooter but this particular revolver came with a set of aftermarket wood stocks that fit me great.
 
19's

I bought my first centerfire revolver in 1972....it was a four inch 19, advertised in a newspaper ad, still have it.....I also have 2.5's and 66's....a large portion of my professional career revolved around K frame Smith's, 2.5 & 4" 66's & 19's....either as a duty gun, guns that I instructed and qualified recruits and recertified line officers with, or an armory full of them that I was responsible for over a period of years as an supervisory instructor / armorer....the 19 was the one " that brung me to the dance" and who could have forsaw the path that would lead down....classic gun, regardless of bl length...congrat's on ur "new" 19.
 
I have a nickel 2.5" and a 4" Tx ranger Comm. 19 and have yet to get either to the range. The Tx ranger has a beautiful deep bluing that if I didn't know better I would think it has a python as a brother. Not a scratch anywhere. The 2.5" is hard to come by especially in great condition. I can brag on that one too. They are great revolvers and are becoming very desirable.
 
Dang....sounds like the snubby you sold is the one I have. ....shipped in 1979



1377136343_zps2a7ec4dd.jpg
 
I liked it so much, I bought a 2 ½" M-19, in nickel, a few months later. I couldn't hit anything with the 2 inch, and didn't like it at all. I thought the sights were defective, or the barrel was bent or something. I sold it to a fellow officer without mentioning the poor accuracy. He later told me that it was one of the best shooters he ever had. In fact, he routinely scored 100's with it on qualifying day. Reality checks can be hard on your ego.

I had a fine k frame with a two inch barrel that was a wonderful piece of work to hold and behold. I had to admit though that my shooting with it was very poor. I hate it when people can shoot short barrels, Like Hickok45.
 
model 19 vs model 10....both are great!

One gun I have kicked myself about letting go was a blue 6 inch 19 I had years ago....that was the most accurate 38/357 I had had up to that time...Model 10s/15s were "the" Cop gun of the 50's with 19s/66s taking over that crown later.

I realize S&W discontinued the 19s/66s due to them not being able to withstand thousands of full power rounds that some police departments required....so they came out with the L frame. Hey! Most folks never fire enough hi powered rounds to wear out a K frame 357 and should they do so it normally can be rebuilt. I have never cared for the L frame guns since the smaller K frame did the job just fine with less weight and bulk.
My fave K frame is the 2.5 inch 66, with second place a 2 inch model 15 (just got one NIB)....
 
The model 19 Combat Magnum is everything you need in a revolver and nothing you don't.

Regards 18DAI
 
Early Model 19-3

Here's an early Model 19-3, K900XXX range (about 1969-1970) I purchased from forum member Wordsmith (David Carroll) a while back. It was/is NIB with TH, TT, and smooth Rosewood service grips.
 
I have a four inch 19-5. I actually found I shot better with it than I did with a six inch Python I also had. Letting the Python go was not a major emotional moment, but I have entertained no ideas letting the 19 slip away.
 
Back
Top