I see a 257 Roberts rifle for sale occasionally but have always passed due to having nice .223's and .243's. I am going to have to pick up the next nice one I see!
The .257 Bob was a fun round to shoot.
For some reason it dissapeared from the scene.
Great round with no recoil and legal fordeer everywhere.
Unless it's changed, you could only buy RN ammo for .257, so if you want full potential, you need to handload with spitzer bullets of good construction, like the Nosler Partition. I think a .257 so loaded will kill elk in a suitable situation. For smaller game, it's excellent.
What killed off the .257 was low powered RN factory ammo and the appearance of the 6 mms, hyped a lot by Warren Page at, Field & Stream.
Jack O'Connor liked the .257, but he handloaded for the caliber.
I wouldn't buy a .257 as my primary hunting rifle, but as a luxury item for the right circumstances, it's fine.
Personal opinion on why the 257 performs better the the 25 06 on deer. No I have not used premium bullets only factory 120 gr on the 4 25 06 rifles I've owned. I lost at least one deer with the 25 06. I saw the bullet strike just behind the shoulder and this id's dead deer for all other calibers I have used.
I feel the 257 at slightly less velocity pent rates before going to pieces where the 25 05 goes to pieces on ribs.
I've taken well over 100 deer. I've used many calibers, none failed like the 25 06, the fares went from 25 to 300 yards.
For v some I guess it works great, I won lime to try a 257 Roberts and a 257 Weatherby with rifling that will stabilize 120 gr premium bullets.
When I had a Wby collection one was a German MKV in 257. It had the old twist and would only shoot the 117 gr round nose. I did not know until I loaded 120 gr Spitzer that they would tumble at w5 and we're lucky to hit paper at q00 yards.
Needless to say I was heart broken and it was the 1st one I sold when I sold my collection.
Some day I'll find a cheap Rem, Win, fn chambered for a magnum round and will have it rebarreled.
Back to your 257, it is a beautiful gun.
Many years ago, there was a magazine called, Safari. The principal writer was a guy named Wally Taber, who liked Weatherbys.
He told me the .257 Weatherby was his favorite caliber, but don't know the rifling twist on his. Said it killed all out of proportion to the bullet size. I was very young and didn't think to ask about bullets. He probably had Noslers.
He shot some African game with it that I'd want to use a .375 H&H on.
The .257 aside, why did you sell your Weatherbys?
The first rifle I ever bought for myself was a tang safety, red rubber butt-pad M77 in 25-06. I still have it. I always wanted an Ultra Light in .250 Savage.
Your .257 Roberts splits the difference. It is a beaut. Congrats.
Personal opinion on why the 257 performs better the the 25 06 on deer. No I have not used premium bullets only factory 120 gr on the 4 25 06 rifles I've owned. I lost at least one deer with the 25 06. I saw the bullet strike just behind the shoulder and this id's dead deer for all other calibers I have used.
I feel the 257 at slightly less velocity pent rates before going to pieces where the 25 05 goes to pieces on ribs.
I've taken well over 100 deer. I've used many calibers, none failed like the 25 06, the fares went from 25 to 300 yards.
For v some I guess it works great, I won lime to try a 257 Roberts and a 257 Weatherby with rifling that will stabilize 120 gr premium bullets.
When I had a Wby collection one was a German MKV in 257. It had the old twist and would only shoot the 117 gr round nose. I did not know until I loaded 120 gr Spitzer that they would tumble at w5 and we're lucky to hit paper at q00 yards.
Needless to say I was heart broken and it was the 1st one I sold when I sold my collection.
Some day I'll find a cheap Rem, Win, fn chambered for a magnum round and will have it rebarreled.
Back to your 257, it is a beautiful gun.