I just sold mine in similar cosmetic condition but has been fired with serial number matching grip panels. No box or papers for $800. I think I could have gotten more if I went online to sell it but the new owner is a S&W buff and I knew he was in love with it.
I paid $1000 for one with presentation case/paperwork/tools two years ago and it had definitely been fired. I would think your package would sell for $1200-$1500 at auction; probably around $1200 where I shop. I don't think the damaged hinge would make too much difference.