Hey folks, I just recently picked up this 4506 from a guy after having been searching for one for a very long time. It's in great shape, and the serial places it's date of birth at January 1990 according to S&W.
Anyways, I like having a pancake holster for all of my guns. I was very annoyed with not being able to find one for the non -1 4506, so I decided to do some research. I learned that the holsters for the Beretta 92 series pistols will fit the 4506 near-perfectly, so I figured I would try out my Galco Fletch for the 92FS. It fit almost as if it was made for the gun...except for the thumb-break. It would not make it around the hammer on the 4506, yet if I squeezed it between the hammer and the grip it would allow me to snap it closed. So I measured the approximate space I would need to cut out for it to simply work without issue, and made this cut. It's a U-shaped cut a little more than an inch wide, about 1/4" away from the plastic backing of the thumb snap. I used one of those exacto knives while resting the thumb break on a block of wood.
Pictures for your viewing pleasure (clicking them makes them full sized):
It turned out quite nicely, and the holster will still work for my 92FS and CZ75B as it always has, while allowing me to carry the 4506 in my favorite manner! You can't use the tumb break with the safety on though, but on a double action that's a moot point anyways. I found that my H&K USP40 pancake holster fit as well, but the slide would stick out about 1/2" from the end. It didn't hinder the drawing effort, but I didn't like the fact that it stuck out. This mod was quick and easy, while not rendering it unusable for the other pistols it works for.
Anyways, I like having a pancake holster for all of my guns. I was very annoyed with not being able to find one for the non -1 4506, so I decided to do some research. I learned that the holsters for the Beretta 92 series pistols will fit the 4506 near-perfectly, so I figured I would try out my Galco Fletch for the 92FS. It fit almost as if it was made for the gun...except for the thumb-break. It would not make it around the hammer on the 4506, yet if I squeezed it between the hammer and the grip it would allow me to snap it closed. So I measured the approximate space I would need to cut out for it to simply work without issue, and made this cut. It's a U-shaped cut a little more than an inch wide, about 1/4" away from the plastic backing of the thumb snap. I used one of those exacto knives while resting the thumb break on a block of wood.
Pictures for your viewing pleasure (clicking them makes them full sized):







It turned out quite nicely, and the holster will still work for my 92FS and CZ75B as it always has, while allowing me to carry the 4506 in my favorite manner! You can't use the tumb break with the safety on though, but on a double action that's a moot point anyways. I found that my H&K USP40 pancake holster fit as well, but the slide would stick out about 1/2" from the end. It didn't hinder the drawing effort, but I didn't like the fact that it stuck out. This mod was quick and easy, while not rendering it unusable for the other pistols it works for.
Last edited: