Secret to buying fresh fish at Costco

Joined
Mar 22, 2010
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
4,758
Location
New England
I thought I'd share some Costco wisdom with fellow fish lovers. Here in Vermont buying store-bought fresh fish is a roll of the dice - sometimes it'll be fresh, other times it'll stink up the kitchen when it cooks. Fresh fish, of course, has nearly no smell to it, and it does not stink up your kitchen when it cooks. Here's the secret for buying fresh fish at Costco: My Costco gets fish 3 times a week. You have to learn which days your Costco gets it. Then you go only on those days for fish, and you look for fish that was packaged *that day*. But by itself, the packaged date still is not enough - they could have gotten it two days ago and packaged it that day, and it'll stink up your kitchen when you cook it. So you look for fish that was packaged *that day* AND has a sell by date that is 7 days down the road. That tells you they got the fish that day. Follow these steps, and you'll get fish that has nearly no smell if you cook it that day, e.g., fresh. It all sounds obvious, but it took me too long to connect all 3 dots to decode the system!
 
Last edited:
No-No-No

Get the tartar sauce!

Make the tarter sauce, it's easy & has Sooo much more flavor when it too is fresh.

Go catch fish yourself to insure freshness (optional, if opportunity arises)

1/4 cup chopped onion
1/4 cup chopped dill pickle
1 to two tablespoons chopped fresh jalapeno (seed & mantle removed)

in a blender or mini food processer, fine chop the first 3 ingredients

1/2 cup mayonnaise
1 tsp real lemon juice

mix all well
 
Fat Tom is correct:

Look for bright, clear eyes. The eyes are the window to a truly fresh fish, for they fade quickly into gray dullness. Dull-eyed fish may be safe to eat, but they are past their prime.
 
I haven't bought much fresh or frozen fish because most of what I see is farmed in China, probably under very unsanitary conditions.

And most salmon in restaurants is farm-raised and full of carcinogens.

Pity. I do like really fresh fish.
 
I haven't bought much fresh or frozen fish because most of what I see is farmed in China, probably under very unsanitary conditions.

And most salmon in restaurants is farm-raised and full of carcinogens.

Pity. I do like really fresh fish.
Here's an interesting anecdote about farm raised fish: I used to give my former cat a shrimp or two whenever I cooked them (peeled & boiled, no seasoning). If the shrimp were wild shrimp, she'd eat the whole thing. If the shrimp was farm raised, she would *never* eat the last part of the shrimp nearest the tail. Clearly she was tasting something in the farm raised shrimp she didn't like, something the wild shrimp don't have. After that connection was clear to me, I stopped buying farm raised fish of any kind - too much we don't know about it.
 
Last edited:
As a guy who spent 10 summers commercial fishing salmon in AK I will say

Friends don't let friends eat farmed fish.

Raised in crowded pens, given lots of tetracycline to keep them from dieing, fed ****. They actually add color make them look better.

Wild fish roam the sea, eating a variety of natural feeds, predators get the week and sick.
 
i saw a video once on farm raised fish its in asia somewhere where there raised in large swiming pools ,not only did they feed them bad food. They had wire chicken pens above the pools you know what that means
 
i saw a video once on farm raised fish its in asia somewhere where there raised in large swiming pools ,not only did they feed them bad food. They had wire chicken pens above the pools you know what that means

It means they were raising the chickens of the sea?
Or that the fish they raised taste like chicken?
Or that they now have aquatic chickens?

I saw a program awhile back where they had pens in the ocean but with the density of fish in the pen the area beneath the pen had been rendered completely lifeless and anoxic as a result of all the fish waste that sank to the bottom.
 
Fresh fish here is no problem, the 2nd largest comm fleet on the east coast is less than 5 min from my house, we have a saying here, if you can smell the fish, buy a steak.:D
 
Costco in HI

My method is to buy from the Costco in Lihue on Kauai:D

They have somewhat taken over the local fish trade, and have fresh caught Mahi, Ono, Opa, Ahi, Swordfish in their case every morning. Every time I go (I'm lucky, it's usually 3-4 times a month) I bring back a cooler of fish on ice.

The family is now addicted to fresh caught Pacific fish. My 4 year old son has become a fish-snob and will not eat fish from the local Safeway, and can spot previously frozen fish from a mile away (I've created a monster)….

To have fresh fish right out of the ocean is a real treat, especially for us folks that live in Phoenix!:roll eyes:

Opa done with smoked Kauai salt seasoning in an iron skillet is the bomb!

If any of you S&W forum denizens ever find yourself on Kauai, go to Verde's in Kapa'a for the best fish tacos you've ever had.
 
I buy fish from the fish market but it's hard to know where it originated

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

Not trying to be a smart alec, but have you asked the vendor? If a vendor can't answer I don't recommend buying the fish.

+1 on not eating farmed fish. When the have to add red die to salmon, run, don't walk, away from the case.
 
What's with this recent Tilapia push. I never heard of it growing up and not you can't get away from it. Near as I can figure it is a bottom dwelling garbage eater. My instincts tell me to stay away from it and I do.

How are the wilde caught shrimp in the gulf since the BP spill, good or not?

This concludes the thread hijack.
 
Back
Top