Shield vs shield plus

I have the Shield 1.0 and love it !
I have handled the Plus and feels OK but not enough to buy one yet :)Looking at 1911's :)
For anyone want a better feel grip on the 1.0 or 2.0 try TALON Grip tape , The rubber tape not sandpaper type, Better feel, firmer grip and makes the grip a tiny bit thicker.
As for extra rounds I have a SR9 with 17 +1 so that good enough g=for me right now :O

the 1.0 trigger was gritty and not as light as the 2.0./ The Shield plus with the flat trigger is about as close as you can come to an apex flatty and it's the best trigger of the group. The 2.0 grip is too aggressive and I seldom carry it because it is too abrasice. The shield plus is just right. The plus is definitely worth getting
 
the 1.0 trigger was gritty and not as light as the 2.0./ The Shield plus with the flat trigger is about as close as you can come to an apex flatty and it's the best trigger of the group. The 2.0 grip is too aggressive and I seldom carry it because it is too abrasice. The shield plus is just right. The plus is definitely worth getting

Thanks for the reply and reviews very helpful ! Good to know, I have been lucky with my 1.0 and think the trigger is fine BUT I have not shot a Plus or 2. 0 lol so that may change !
I have 1000+ rounds through my 1.0, But am always thinking of another reason to buy lol
 
Okay, how many folks here have been in an actual gunfight? Show of hands.

Now, how many of you actually anticipate being in an actual, guns-a-blazin' gunfight at some point in your life?

Last but not least, imagine that you're famished right now, like you haven't eaten at all today, (bonus points if you actually are that hungry right now) then tell me what sounds better right now...A single hamburger or a bacon double cheeseburger?

The point is, wanting more ammunition in a gunfight is like wanting more food when you're extremely hungry, you may want it, you might even think that you need it, but factually speaking, how many folks have actually run out of ammo in a gunfight, and if they had it on them, would it have made a difference, would they have been able to make use of it?

FACT: If you're outgunned, then you're at a disadvantage which cannot be overcome simply by carrying more ammunition. In other words, if you are facing multiple assailants, then having a gun that holds more rounds and/or carrying more magazines/speedloaders isn't going to even the odds, not by a longshot.

Don't get me wrong, there's definitely an advantage to carrying firearms which hold more rounds as well as spare ammo, because obviously they enable you to potentially stay in the fight longer, but that doesn't mean that you'll necessarily need that many rounds, much less be capable of effectively making use of all of them.

In cold weather, I myself carry a double-stack SW40VE, but in warmer weather I carry a Shield 1.0 because it's easier to carry, and I have no intention to "upgrade" to a Shield PLUS when the added thickness as well as the added weight of a fully-loaded magazine would make it less comfortable to carry in Summer, yet make no difference in Winter. As previously stated, I'd sooner update my existing Shield with aftermarket magazine extensions than buy a new Shield PLUS.
I would never trust my life to aftermarket extensions or magguts components. That's just me. My life and the lives of my family are well worth the upgrade.
The original Shield is .95w and the Plus is 1.1. You'd never feel that. The original Shield is 20.8oz while the Plus is actually lighter at 20.2oz. How much weight difference do you think there actually is between a fully loaded 1.0/2.0 Shield and a fully loaded Plus?
Smith & Wesson M&P 9 Shield vs M&P 9 Shield Plus size comparison | Handgun Hero
 
Last edited:
My nephew picked one up on Friday and we shot it Saturday. I was impressed. I liked the texture and the trigger was really good. It is a lot of gun for the money. I highly recommend shooting it if you are on the fence. It is it's own best salesperson.
 
Having had the Shield 1.0 when it first came out and recent production 1.0's (2018) the trigger did improve through the years but the Shield 2.0 improved upon that to a noticeable degree - smoother and crisper - The Plus is better still. My Plus has less take up and even crisper break than my 2.0. I'm not sure the added rounds mean much to me (having 10 rounds in the same footprint isn't a bad thing) but the added grip width seems to help as I shoot the Plus better than the others (except maybe my 2.0 performance center 4" with an Apex trigger shoe)IMO. It even fits in all my Shield holsters.
WK
 
I bought my first Shield in 2015.

I bought my Shield Plus a little over a month ago.

The Plus is a better gun. Much improved trigger, increased capacity, and (for me) the slightly wider grip w/ a tiny bit of a palm swell makes it superior. It has definitely been improved.
 
I have a PC Shield 2 , the plus has tempted me bad. I would jump on it if I didn't have a nice to me EDC.

Sent from my SM-P610 using Tapatalk
 
Thanks, I almost went on that S&W Shield plus they had but seeing as how it's hard as all get out to find mags for em I passed in favor of the 45 shield, which, after fondling her now for several hours straight, I like her.


Yeah… hopefully S&W can get their act together and get some mags to market for the Plus. For no, I’m content with the 2 I have. I don’t carry more than that anyway.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Back
Top