Should've Purchased a 637..Hindsight

Joined
Dec 2, 2010
Messages
3,658
Reaction score
3,695
Location
Western Pennsylvania
My wife liked my dad's old Chief's Special but wanted a lighter weight gun for CC in her purse. I have a 642 and let her shoot it several times. She really hates DAO revolvers and, while she shot OK with the 642, she didn't want to carry that gun.

We looked art a few used Smiths including an Airweight Bodyguard, which I suggested she purchase. She wanted a new gun. Almost had her convinced to buy a new 637 but then she spied a Taurus Model 85 Ultra Lite with the gold accents and faux pearl grips. We checked it out. Had a better DA pull than the Smith and she liked the sights much better. (The sights on the Taurus are better). Against the advice of the counter guy who said flat out "Two out of every four Taurus revolvers we sell come back to us with serious problems." She purchased the revolver. I remained neutral, as I had a model 605 for 20 years that was always perfect. Plus the Taurus was $369 with two sets of grips.

The first rip to the range, the 85 UL was perfect. The wife shot about 80 rounds and I fired 30 or so. Hit right on point of aim at 7 and 10 yards. I shot it quite a bit better than my 642!!.

Next time out she only shot about 50 rounds, but everything was OK.

The other day I suggested she get some more practice with her carry gun while we were wringing out a couple other revolvers on the outdoor range. She started shooting single action with some Privi-Partisan 158 gr lead loads and was doing OK. I then reminded her she should really be shooting double action like she would in a real situation. Bang-Bang- Bang--------Bang--Bang. Reload, Bang--------Bang-Bang----Bang--Bang. I said, 'Why are you hesitating with you trigger pull? Just pull straight through." She shoots five more while I watch. Same thing. I shoot five 130 grain Winchester USA's out of it. Same thing. Houston-we have a problem!

The gun is rolling into battery and not locking all the time. When it doesn't lock into the cylinder notch properly, it makes the trigger 'hitch' toward the end of its stroke causing the hammer to hang up, then fall. The cylinder then rotates backwards slightly, causing the next pull of the trigger to not rotate the cylinder completely into battery resulting in a short stroke and a misfire!

The gun will not do this when dry-fired with snap caps or dummy rounds. Taurus says there is nothing wrong with the gun! I popped the side plate, cleaned lubed and inspected everything, finding nothing out of place. I've dry fired it about 1,500 times since. Another trip to the range is in order. Thing is- if it still does its DA stuff, how do I convince the idiots at Taurus that there really is a genuine problem with the revolver??
They serviced an extractor problem with my 738 .380 without a problem, but they want ME to pay the shipping on the revolver because they feel I'm just not shooting it correctly..

Should've purchased a 637...
 
Register to hide this ad
That has never hapened to me, so I can't comment on the
mechanics. However, if it goes back, and you lose trust in it,
it'll be a good reason to get the 637. Put some fancy engraving and
fancy grips on it, and you'll have an heirloom for the next couple generations.
 
J frame prices have come down to bargain levels as of late. It should have been possible to pick one up only a pittance more than the Taurus.

But what really puzzles me... why wouldn't the clerk reduce his fractions....? Why say "two out of four" instead of simply "half" or even "one out of every two"? Unless of course it was a literal figure and they'd sold all of four and two were broken. Ponders.

Anyway, Taurus customer service can be somewhat lackluster. Or so I'm told. I haven't owned one since the Model 85 I had died after about that many rounds were fired. (I gave it away to a friend, he had it fixed, but I'm unsure how long it lasted.) Sometimes it can take several trips and a bit of persistence to get a problem resolved. In a few cases...it would seem that things never get resolved.

HiPoint, Jimenez, KelTec, et al... actually have good customer service and fix things or send parts. Yet Taurus manages to sell guns that cost almost as much as their competition, break more often, and fails to fix them... yet they still sell. Strange world.

Sorry that you got a bad one this time around. Is the dealer you got it from of any help, such as perhaps allowing a trade in or willing to send it back for service again?
 
I know it's not quite the same, but shop around for a new 637 or 638.

I needed a new carry gun due to the fact that the wife commandeered the 65-3.

After a couple of weeks I found a dealer in my area selling new 638's for $359 ! Almost $60 less than anyone else.

I love it. I know it's not a prelock, not my old 49 in nickle that I sold years back, but it functions flawlessly.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20111018_143603.jpg
    IMG_20111018_143603.jpg
    55.4 KB · Views: 17
Back
Top