Speed loaders vs. Moon Clips

[Palmetto Sharpshooter]

I recently cut my Comp IIIs and had the cylinder slightly chamferred. The chamferring made a world of difference. I'm not so sure the cut job on the Comp IIIs helped much. Time will tell.

 

[tomcatt51]

I'm not so sure the cut job on the Comp IIIs helped much. Time will tell.

I have cut down JetLoaders for my K frames. Cutting them down makes a loading block necessary but does help my reloads. Doesn't make much difference if the chambers are perfectly clean and I do everything just right but when the chambers start to get a little dirty or I'm off a bit the cut down versions get the rds all the way into the chambers better. I have the center "trigger"(?) cut back .125" also and the loader will push the rds all the way into chamber vs them needing to "fall" in the last half of the way. Just FWIW.

 

[seabeesbob]

What is the difference between CompIII and Comp II. I am getting ready to try IDPA with a 65 3" barrel and have no purchased any speedloaders yet, so I was just wondering which to buy.

 

[BILL]

Get the CompIII. They're spring loaded and help push the round into the cylinder if it is a little dirty.

The CompII relies on gravity to get the round into the cylinder.

I shot a 3 inch Model 10 in IDPA for several years. Lots of fun.

Bill