I like most LEOS. Heck I am meeting the guy who was the chief or police in my home town for lunch Monday when I am there. I was on come to my house for supper friendly with the just retired sheriff.
But, you should never have been able to stop and check people without probable cause in the first place. Probable cause is there for a reason. Just because some guy looks suspicious is no reason to stop and search. Why would you just up and stop someone for no cause??? Explain the law on looking suspicious??? How have judges and defense attorneys responded to you when you said I stopped him because he looked suspicious or do you HONESTLY say that in court??
I am driving down the street. Would you stop me and check it I had a drivers license or warrants with no cause???
I am walking down the street and you think I may have a concealed gun, would you stop to see if I had a permit with no cause??
What is really different except no constitutional right to possess a car??
If I look at you and move my eyes away quickly, I am driving the speed limit, I have a clunker in the "good'' neighborhood, my older brother went to prison, are those suspicious????
In any case with no probable cause a judge will release the person in short order. Your Honor, he looked suspicious ain't going to cut it no more permits or not. Anything obtained during such search would be fruit of the poison tree and tossed as evidence. Not revolving door justice, but poor police work. Sorry.
Other states have been doing it without a problem for some time. Vermont for decades. I only needed a permit for carry in town on my person in Montana forever. I could legally have as many guns as I wanted wherever and how ever in my car with no permit for as long as I can remember and our law enforcement had no problems. Arizona has had permit less carry for 10 years no with no disaster like you describe. Why??
Profiling was never the best way to go. Just cause some one is driving a brand new Mercedes late at night in a bad neighborhood does not mean it was stolen. Yes it might be. But what if it was you driving home from work?
Sometimes my hair is a mess and my clothes are dirty, if I drive slow around a few blocks looking for a business, is that a reason to think I don't have a permit or my Lincoln is stolen???? If you did stop me I would call the city manager and complain. The heck with the chief.
A whole bunch of suspicion is based on profiling. While I don't think if a crime was committed by a tall young man, the cops should have to check out 60 year old fat women too, stopping every "suspicious looking" 16-30 year old tall man and patting them down, cuffing some while waiting for information ain't right either. A lot of the reason for some people being up in arms lately is because of having been profiled at one time or the other themselves. Not condoning the looting burning or destruction. But, having been stopped and cuffed for something I never did does mean I can understand some of the outrage. The apology when I was released from the cuffs did not help one little bit. News flash, cops get nervous around very muscular 20-30 some year old 6'3" 240# aggressive guys. Don't mean we committed a crime or started a fight or belong in cuffs.