The Best Tarzan?

Texas Star

US Veteran
Joined
Mar 11, 2005
Messages
20,360
Reaction score
16,164
Location
Texas
I liked the Tarzan books, but the movies were usually lacking in his portrayal.

I think the best was Christopher Lambert in, "Greystoke: the Legend of Tarzan of the Apes." (But the girl who played Jane was a total loss in that role.)

Johnny Weissmuller was an irritant. I didn't like his hoarse voice or his pidgin English or general lack of culture. The Tarzan of the books spoke perfect French, later English. He was, after, Lord Greystoke, a wealthy nobleman! He would have been that man, with the savage nature beneath. Burroughs was very clear about that, and about his physique, wiry and strong, not musclebound like a bodybuilder.

His knife intrigued me, especially after I studied English knives that his marooned father might have had. Based on the books, I settled on a dagger with stag handle and about an eight-inch blade, by I*XL or Joseph Rodgers. Nickle guard. Keep in mind that his parents were marooned in French West Africa or nearby in the 1880's. I once published an article on the probable Tarzan knife, so some good came of my speculation. :)

I think Tarzan (if real) would probably have had that knife of his father's restored by the maker and surely bought others. But none would have resembled those in the movies.

Herman Brix was a pretty good Tarzan in the 1939 film, "The Green Goddess." Lex Barker was okay, but blond and obviously American. The same for Buster Crabbe, who I otherwise liked in the role.

I never saw a Jane that I really liked.
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Howdy Tex

Hi Tex,
I liked them all for different reasons.
Including "Me Tarzan, you Jane" Weissmuller.
Even as a little kid I would laugh as Tarzan would ride the rhino and stab it to death with his rubber knife.
I enjoyed Greystroke and would look forward to a new movie.
I can't remember most of their names. I liked some more than others
On a side note, I saw where Cheetah passed away about a year ago.
I never saw a Jane I would kick out of my tree house.
Girls were hard to come by for Tarzan.
I'll have to check out The Green Goddess. Thanks for the tip.
Thanks
Mike
 
Last edited:
Johnny Weissmuller spoke and acted just dumb enough to be acceptable on screen as a jungle man. It's probably not likely that many people seeing those old movies had read the books,so they got away with it.
 
I will have to admit I never read the boks but I did watch the movies. So I guess I really liked Johnny Weismuller the best. Since I am not a Tarzan reader.
 
The lady in "Greystroke" was Andie McDowall who is from South Carolina. I had heard that she could not overcome her Southern accent so her entire movie dialog was spoken by Glenn Close faking a cultured English accent.

In 1974 I was stationed at MCAS Yuma and living off-base. The older single lady across the street was visiting with us one night and told us about her "date" with Johnny Weismuller at the height of his Hollywood career.

"He was an animal." She said. They went on a double date to a nice restuarant and at the very beginning of being seated he started feeling for her legs and playing "grabby" underneath the table. She excused herself, went to the Lady's room and crawled out the window, abandoning her lady friend to the table and two men. She said he was such an animal she was truly afraid to be around him.

I watched all of the Johnny Weismuller "Tarzans" and my favorite was when he was fighting the Nazis in Africa. He'd call out, "Hey Nazi" and when one came after him he'd ambush them. Now, when I watch them in re-run I realize that my biggest mistake was not realizing how beautiful Maureen O'Sullivan was. As for Ole Johnny...he was lucky for the venue of "Tarzan" and "Jungle Jim". Real lucky.

"Boy" was constantly getting himself in trouble, like the kid in "Shane" he needed a serious thumping.
 
...my favorite was when he was fighting the Nazis in Africa. He'd call out, "Hey Nazi" and when one came after him he'd ambush them. Now, when I watch them in re-run I realize that my biggest mistake was not realizing how beautiful Maureen O'Sullivan was.

I swear Weissmuller says, "Tarzan hate Nazis," in one of his movies, but I've gone through them and counldn't find it.

Maureen O'Sullivan is one of those women who would look beautiful in any era, in any outfit, hair style or make-up.
 
All I know about those old Tarzan movies is that there was always some bad Juju up on the escarpment and once the natives found out from the witch doctor that was where they were going they always panicked, dropped the boxes they were carrying on their heads and ran away.
 
Remember how the hostile natives would have that trick with the crossed trees? Man, I'd like to see that done now with all the computer graphic stuff.
 
Hmmm...
Elmo Lincoln 1918
Gene Pollar 1920
James Pierce 1921
Frank Merrill 1928
Johnny Weissmuller 1932
Buster Crabbe 1933
Herman Brix 1935
Glenn Morris 1938
Lex Barker 1949
Gordon Scott 1955
Denny Miller 1959
Jock Mahoney 1962
Mike Henry 1966
Ron Ely 1967
Miles O'Keefe 1981
Christopher Lambert 1984
John Lara 1989
Wolf Larson 1991
Casper Van Dien 1998
Travis Fimmel 2003

I'll have to go with Buster Crabbe as my favorite!


Crabbe was good, also as Flash Gordon and as Capt. Gallant of the Foreign Legion.


Joe Lara was in the TV series filmed in South Africa after the political changes there, and that PC stuff precluded making Tarzan films as they should be. Now, the natives have to be major characters and hardly the "gomangani" of the Burroughs books. Also, they had too much special effects in that brief series, as with the one starring Gena Lee Nolin as Sheena.

Maureen O' Sulllivan was okay, but if you compare her to, say, Grace Kelly...

Most people seem to forget that Jane was American, from Maryland, I think, in the books. Having Andie McDowell's accent dubbed wasn't needed. Jane wasn't British!

I think a young Rachel Blakely would make a good Jane. I loved her as Marguerite on, "The Lost World." She could probably fake a US accent. (She's half American, although she's never lived here; just visits her US father and sister. She's Australian.) But Rachel is over 40 now. If you liked Maureen O'Sullivan, you'd adore Rachel. She resembles a witty, droll Nancy Kerrigan. And she can really smolder.

I think almost all of the movies and the TV series just assumed that few viewers read the books, and they played to the lowest common denominator. I detested Jai with Ron Ely. Why would this Mexican kid replace Boy? BTW, Boy had a name in the books, and was a fine son of Tarzan. I think his name was Jack. Tarzan's actual name was John Clayton. Greystoke was his estate and part of England. A parallel on, "The Lost World" is that Lord John Roxton, VC, was the Earl of Avebury.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top