Well used Model 586

bgrafsr

Absent Comrade
Joined
Feb 26, 2003
Messages
5,459
Reaction score
9,859
City & State/Province
Homerville, Ohio
Bought a well used Model 586 earlier in the year that had seen extensive firing and some Bubba 'smithing. The price was right so I took it home.
Corrected the internals and then sent it off to S&W for a re-blue. They did a fantastic job.

Took it to the range and it shot good, but I would get misfires once in a while and attributed it to Mag-Tec primers.

Yesterday I again took it to the range for another shooting session and was getting misfires again, but this time with CCI 550 primers.

Came home and did some measuring on the gun. Headspace, from rear of cylinder to recoil shield was .075":eek:. It is supposed to be .060".
B/C gap was .012":mad:.

Okay, now for some work. I removed the extractor, chucked it up in a 1/4" 5C collet, stuck it in the lathe, and removed .015" from the rear of the extractor/ratchets. Re-installed the extractor and with the cylinder pushed back towards the rear I got my headspace of .060". I then had to correct the generous end shake, which I did with the stainless washers.

Now of course, I had a very generous B/C gap to contend with, so I removed the barrel, chucked it up in the lathe, cut the shoulder back, cut the rear of the barrel back, re-installed it, got it clocked correctly, and ended up with a B/C gap of .004":D.

Checked the forcing cone, figuring I would have to re-cut it, but it was within tolerances, so it must have been oversize to begin with.

I was going to go to the range today for some more shooting, but it's raining and damp, so it will have to wait until sometime next week. I don't think I will have any more misfires, and I'm sure the gun will shoot better now that the specs have been corrected.

One thing I noticed is the extractor is stainless, and not blue, which I'm thinking it should have been on a 586. I wonder if the extractor was changed at the factory when I sent it in for the re-blue. Nothing was mentioned about it on the bill. If they did change it, why would they not make sure the headspace was correct? Anyways, the gun is now correct for tolerances and I enjoyed doing the fixing. I love tinkering with my lathe and tools.
 
I love a 586. Could you post pictures of the reblue? I'm curious how it compares to the look of mine from 1982.
 
IMG_0376.jpg


IMG_0375.jpg


IMG_0374.jpg
 
Bill,

Can't answer your questions but applaud your efforts and will look forward to hearing your range report.

Jerry
 
Good job!

My Dad used to have a lathe but sold it just before he passed away. i did not use it that often but man when I was in need of one it was great to have around. I was thinking of buying one but just can't justify the room it takes up for the few times I would actually use it.

Hope you turned it into a great shooter. I've got one (6" 586) that my wife bought me in the early 80's (when they first came out) as an anniversary present. It's probably the best gift she ever gave me.

Chief38
 
that looks great. looks like an aftermarket sight and the barrel looks a little unusual. is that a 6 inch? looks a bit shorter.
 
Good job!

My Dad used to have a lathe but sold it just before he passed away. i did not use it that often but man when I was in need of one it was great to have around. I was thinking of buying one but just can't justify the room it takes up for the few times I would actually use it.

Hope you turned it into a great shooter. I've got one (6" 586) that my wife bought me in the early 80's (when they first came out) as an anniversary present. It's probably the best gift she ever gave me.

Chief38

Hi Chief:

I'm hoping it shoots much better now too. I have a 686 that really shoots well, so I will be surprised if the 586 doesn't.
 
Back
Top