8 beats 5 every day of the week.
Just too dang ugly for me. If I want to carry a .357 snub, I'll go with a snub K-Frame. As far as I'm concerned, N-Frames should have at least a three inch barrel for aesthetics.
I like the look but without the horn and the caliber is too small. I'm in the big slow bullet that is controllable camp vs the lightweight speedy bullet with too much flash and recoil camp.
I deer hunt with a Thompson center pro hunter 7mm rem mag with a custom brake from eabcoBoy, howdy. I have seen this hunting. Guys rush that first shot and the guys with the semi autos seem to be the worst about this.
The idea that will have another shot right away is hard to keep out of your head I think.
My brothers and I go by the saying. "One shot, one deer, 2 shots, maybe one deer. 3 or more, nothing" Mostly it runs true.