What would be an adequate calibre for a handgun in bear country???

Ummm ... Caje, they even got bears down there? Or are you plannin' on travel?

One of the conditions was that you'd be havin' it on your hip all the time. Its easy to carry a gun when you're out walkin and stuff. But if its a heavy one, you'll want it off your hip as soon as you can. Which pretty much limits you to one of the ultra light guns. I'm not sure if the caliber makes a whole lot of difference. I think the general consensus will be the 44 mag isn't heavy enough, so the 41 and 357 are even more marginal. So the whole answer depends on how light you're willing to go. If you accept the 357, you really have a little choice because you can carry one of the painful Js, or one of the 386s.

My original thought was .458 and I still think I'd feel OK with one. Even a little wimpy .30-30 would be better than a handgun. And I like the 12ga idea. But they don't fit on your hip. Basically the criteria eliminates any really effective gun. That being the case, hire a body guard. Or live in a tank.

There are actually some "Bear Crossing" signs on the highway
(Hwy 90), in the Morgan City area, just south of where Caj lives -- there are black bears in the lower Atchafalaya Basin.
 
So from readin' this here thread, I'm disposed ta thinkin' they ain't no handgun that'll do the job. Think I'll just be carryin' a knive.....worked for ol' Dan'l, oughta work fer me.......
 
Here abouts (West Tennessee) THEEE preferred method was to grin 'em ta death.
Seems to be pretty effective - There haven't been any bears in WTN for quite a while.

One might also note that back *In The Day* kids as young as 3 were killing bears.
No wonder they're all gone....

AND - To all y'all that pshaw my idea of using a .22 --- You do realize that I was referring to a .22LR - Right?
Not one of the wimpy .22s, like a short or CBI.
 
A black bear has been destroying deer feeders on a sugar cane farm I am involved in. The hunting club members notified the game warden who is supposed to set out a trap soon. If they trap the bear they will relocate it, if it has been trapped for that before it will be "euthanized"

Bears are not common in South Louisiana, but I believe their numbers are increasing. I have only seen one in the 50 years I've been living here it was on the side of the road, dead I believe, near the bear crossing signs, mentioned by Col Jagdog above, near Morgan City, La.

Steve W
 
In this young man's humble opinion i think at minimum a .44 magnum revolver with a 4 inch barrel for easier carry. would do the job but the shooter would have to have a lot of practice with the gun before carrying it in bear country.
 
I have enjoyed reading this thread and smiled a lot. However, my daughter goes hiking in places where bears are and wants to buy something to take with her. It has been suggested that she carry everything between a .40 cal SA to a .45 cal., mostly for the noise factor.

Would a revolver be better?

I have heard of the Judge and the Governor with the buckshot loads, but I think that she would have to be much closer to a bear than anyone would one to be for that to be effective.

She has been going to the local range and shooting various makes and models of SA's trying to find the one that she likes best.
 
Well..............I would proboby reach over and wake-up Leory my "swamper".........cuzz he anit never seen nobody run like im fixin to do
 
I have enjoyed reading this thread and smiled a lot. However, my daughter goes hiking in places where bears are and wants to buy something to take with her. It has been suggested that she carry everything between a .40 cal SA to a .45 cal., mostly for the noise factor.

Would a revolver be better?

I have heard of the Judge and the Governor with the buckshot loads, but I think that she would have to be much closer to a bear than anyone would one to be for that to be effective.

She has been going to the local range and shooting various makes and models of SA's trying to find the one that she likes best.


In my opinion I would carry nothing less than a 44 mag in a double action and bear spray.

John
 
I would dress in a meat suit like Lady Ga Ga so when the bear attacks it may be "filled up" before it gets to the actual you.

I was called one time to fix some cash registers in '68 at the Brookfield Zoo outside Chicago. It rained like never before for two days and one night 3 Kodiac bears swam across the their retention moat which filled to the brim. The damage done around the park was unbelievable. They didn't kill any animals because they broke in the restaurant, and snak shacks. I would opt for a Barrett .50.
 
Well this thread has served its purpose-provolking some thoughtful commentary as well as a few misguided barbs at the poster ;)
St. Mary Parish is about hald a federal bear sanctuary. It seems that here and up in Tensas Parish are the two remaining hotspots for Louisiana Black bear. I remember when I was young, we had a season for them-the first week of October each year and you could shoot one per season. The black bear has stages a remarkable comeback down here to the point of becoming a pest right up there with the feral pigs. They can destroy a sugar cane field over night and they will trash stuff like deer stands. Very shy and will run away from human contact. Big problem is that from a coouple of hundred yards, they look just like the pigs and you got to be careful. If you DO shot one, he'd hetter have your arm in his mouth or you're gonna be in trouble.

Well, it seems this thread has about run its course-I'll start the Pit Bull thread tommorrow. :D
 
I just read in article on one of my outdoor magazines and bear spray had a higher percentage that worked in an attack. Me bear spray an largest handgun I can carry
 
Last edited:
I just read in article on one of my outdoor magazines and beer spray had a higher percentage that worked in an attack. Me bear spray an largest handgun I can carry


Mmmmmm beer spray :D Is that for the bear or for yourself? ;)
 
I get to tell a story

I can't believe some one hasn't said this one yet.

I asked this question to a friend who was a guild in Alaska. He told me that what ever gun I choose, make sure you file the front sight off.

This confused me. Why? For a quicker draw? To force you to point shoot?

His answer "So when the bear takes your gun away from you and sticks it in your rear end, it's much easier to pull it back out."

After I stopped laughing, he told me his bear stopping technique was 12 ga slugs to the front legs and shoulders. He did not say how many times he used it.
 
Back
Top