Where Have All The Accordions Gone?

federali

Absent Comrade
Joined
Mar 24, 2012
Messages
3,082
Reaction score
7,549
Location
Cary, NC
For those of you old enough to remember the 50s, two things caught on like wildfire: rock’n roll and accordions. Rock and roll is still with us but the accordion had its few years of unprecedented popularity, mostly among pre-teens, then, faded from the scene.

Rock and roll relied heavily on electric guitar, base, drums and some sax. Keyboards, synthesized music and electronically altered instruments would come later. Elvis Presley and Bill Haley and the Comets made music a visual, besides an auditory experience as they moved and gyrated to their own music. You couldn’t easily gyrate with a large accordion strapped to your body like a boat anchor.

I can recall scores of young contemporaries, more girls than boys, lugging accordions to and from their weekly lesson. The lessons were most often in mom-and-pop music stores where lessons were given in a back room. You couldn’t mistake the hardshell accordion case: it was large, bulky and usually had a slanted lid or cover. Those music students all walked lopsided trying to counterbalance their accordion.

Perhaps the popular Lawrence Welk Show had a major influence on the accordian’s popularity. Welk himself was an accordionist and he had an accordionist in his band named Myron Floren who would play at least one solo per show. Of course, all those tens of thousands of would-be virtuosos may have thought that the squeezebox would land them a scholarship somewhere, maybe even Juilliard. While the accordion was often seen in small combos at local dances and at Polish, Italian and similar ethnic functions, it never made it to the larger orchestras or gained much acceptance in the recording industry.

I recall that the accordionists’ must-know song of the day was “Lady Of Spain” with the vibrato second chorus. Every accordionist could play it while violinist virtuosos concentrated on “Flight Of The Bumble Bee” and guitarists had to know “Guitar Boogie.” Aside from the Korean War, the Cold War and McCarthyism, the 50s was a great era that’s slowly fading from memory.

As musicians matured, many gave up the accordion and switched over to keyboards such as the electric organ, which was gaining a toehold in contemporary music. Accordions found their way into the attics and garages of America. Just for fun, I checked on ebay and there are several pages of accordions for sale. I suspect that a few million more of them lurk in the American storage bin, waiting to be dusted off and listed on ebay.

I never played the accordion, Instead, I went with the guitar and my heros of the era were Les Paul and Chet Atkins. At the time, I was too young to know about jazz and thus, had never heard of that era’s truly seminal guitar greats like Johnny Smith, Django Reinhardt or Charlie Christian. There were no computers or Youtube upon which you could bring virtually any musician to your desk.

The accordion proved to be a passing fad, the square peg in the round hole. Today, however, the accordion and similar sounding instruments are popular in a genre of music that you can access on Pandora called “French café.” For me, the accordion will always be an integral part of the era that included President Eisenhower, James Dean, the Brooklyn Dodgers, “Rock Around The Clock” and the young Elvis Presley.
I hope you enjoyed this little side-road through the past.
 
Register to hide this ad
I *got to play* and accordion for a minimum of 1 hour a day - EVERY DAY - from sometime between 1st & 2nd grade until I turned 18 and moved out of my parent's home.
My cousin Bobby got a guitar [sniff]

I haven't played a squeeze box in 47 years but do bang on a piano and was fairly competent on an acoustic guitar till a finger on my left hand and a 3/4" router bit wound up in the same place at the same time...

I'd actually like to pick up the accordion again, but have you seen what they cost now?

PS - I came in second in the National Accordion Contest at the Pick Congress Hotel in Chicago in 1968 :)
 
Last edited:
Ye

Yep, I remember the accordion, had a cousin who played one. That's all I remember about the accordion! :rolleyes: I myself went on to play the organ plus various other instruments while in school. No longer play anything but I have a piano sitting in the living room. ;)
 
I *got to play* and accordion for a minimum of 1 hour a day - EVERY DAY - from sometime between 1st & 2nd grade until I turned 18 and moved out of my parent's home.
My cousin Bobby got a guitar [sniff]

I haven't played a squeeze box in 47 years but do bang on a piano and was fairly competent on an acoustic guitar till a finger on my left hand and a 3/4" router bit wound up in the same place at the same time...

I'd actually like to pick up the accordion again, but have you seen what they cost now?

PS - I came in second in the National Accordion Contest at the Pick Congress Hotel in Chicago in 1968 :)


Wow it took you 18 yrs to get out of the 2nd grade.:D
 
Rite of Passage

I grew up in the Slovenian neighborhood of Cleveland OH, land of the polka bands.

My lessons started around 1945 with a 12-bass Hohner. Not too difficult. When I first strapped on a 120-base, all those buttons and keys scared the hell out of me. After a few lessons, I quit, much to the dismay of my parents.

A cousin was a pretty good accordionist. Every time he was asked to perform, he played the "Sharpshooter's March". I sure got tired of that piece.


(This isn't my cousin): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WvBa6I0epuY

Look at all those buttons!
 
Last edited:
I remember and like the accordion very much. Thanks for the heads-up about "French Cafe." I recently heard a "concerto" for accordion on NPR. I wish could recall the composer and/or orchestra and soloist. I know, the idea of a concerto for an accordion seems ridiculous, a twisted joke of some sort, but it was actually a serious piece of music and it was quite entertaining. I had never heard it played like that before.

The accordion in "casual" music has always been more common in Europe than it is here, which I think a shame on us. In the Alpine areas, especially in the smaller towns, you can hardly take a seat for the evening meal without bumping into an accordion, if you hang around long enough. Here in the U.S. in my neck of the woods, the piano always took that place, when I was a young lad. Nowadays we have nothing - or, if there does happen to be "live music," we wish we had nothing! :D

The piano will always be the superior instrument in that setting, but, the stereotypical "um-pah-pah beerhall" music aside, the Europeans do good work with the accordion. I guess you might say it is just their "particular idiom." :D
 
I grew up in the Slovenian neighborhood of Cleveland OH, land of the polka bands.

My lessons started around 1945 with a 12-bass Hohner. Not too difficult. When I first strapped on a 120-base, all those buttons and keys scared the hell out of me. After a few lessons, I quit, much to the dismay of my parents.

A cousin was a pretty good accordionist. Every time he was asked to perform, he played the "Sharpshooter's March". I sure got tired of that piece.
...

I grew up in a mixed neighborhood in Gary, IN.
German, Italian, Polish, and Slovakian families. We were the only Croatians :) And we got along with the Serbians just fine :cool:
I made a fair amount of coin playing wedding receptions in many basements back then.
Ironically (for me) a favorite of the older folks was The Tennessee Waltz.
 
I watch RFD TV every saturday night and there is a one hour program called Millie B's Polka party. They feature bands from all over the Midwest and Canada and even some in Texas and other southwestern states. My personal favorite is the Slovenian/Cleveland/Buttonbox styles. And the Dutch Hop style utilizing the Hammer Dulcimer that are quite popular in Colorado. This program is on each Saturday night at 10 P M eastern.
 
I still hear accordians playing around the Central American parties. I sometimes reminds me of the Bavarian music. I guess they got it from the them back when.

I have a CD from Germany with Bavarian music that I play for Octoberfest. It takes me back to the mountain beer gardens in southern Germany.

Hagstrom from Sweden and others like Hofner from Germany started making guitars as tastes changed. I love my Hagstrom Guitars. I'd like to have a vintage Hofner too.
 
They're all down here. Go to any decent party and someone will pull one out. I have never cared for accordian music and it has not grown on me much after 24 years here.

In fact, whenever a party is a little dull these days, I often comment that "it often gets this way just before you hear the accordian music."
 
Back
Top