The BMW vs. Kia analogy only goes so far: neither will last a lifetime. My wife is still relying on the same S&W M67 I bought for her 30 years ago. It goes BANG every time and will still be protecting her when I am long in the ground. When my grandmother passed on years ago I took a 1920s era .32 HE out of a cigar box in her nightstand. It, too goes BANG (more like POP) every time. This is not a piece of sporting goods. It is not even a tool. It is survival gear. Anything mechanical can fail, but the odds are better with S&W or Ruger.
I have intentionally left Colt out because all of their DA revolvers now have over 10 years on the clock and I have no idea what kind or service they offer on them, if any. When they made them, like S&W I staked my life on their reliability.