Working my palate through taste testing canned and peeled tomatoes.

Joined
Apr 4, 2006
Messages
19,619
Reaction score
31,123
My go-to brand of Italian San Marzano peeled tomatoes are either the Cento or Nina brands. There may be better brands out there but I have not found any yet since I am a relatively newcomer to these tomatoes - "discovered" them only 2 years ago. My best friend for over 68 years is at our house almost daily and last week he brought me 5 cans of different tomatoes, however at a quick glance none are San Marzano - still similar though. Tonight I had a can from Whole Foods but found them watery, harder and did not have the flavor I have come to like. It will be interesting over the next month working our way through these peeled tomatoes.

Bottled sauces contain too many additives and tomato skin which usually gives me heart burn or indigestion of some sort. I am done with having to take an antacid for dessert.

If anyone here is particular to a certain brand please share your opinions.....
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
The best canned tomatoes I've tried, by a wide margin, are Bianco DiNapoli. Not technically San Marzano as they are grown in the US, but very much in the style. They are hard to find and ridiculously expensive, but very tasty. Worth trying once as a treat.



By the way, we grow and can San Marzano style tomatoes every year. Easy to do and better than ANY canned tomato.
 
Long story short: Grew up hating tomatoes in any form other than ketchup or spaghetti sauce. Tomatoes weren't "right" inside. It wasn't until I bought a house in Spokane, WA, eons later that the previous owner had a massive tomato garden that I tried eating them. These were huge beefsteak tomatoes and absolutely wonderful.
I don't can foods, so I'd take grocery bags full of them to work at the AF base for the troops. They'd disappear in minutes with requests for more.
 
I stopped buying San Marzano canned tomatoes a couple years ago. I mostly cook for my wife and me so the larger cans were no longer a good value.

Since then, I've been buying COLAVITA crushed tomatoes in their tetra pak (13.76 oz)(390g). This is a product of Italy that is naturally sweet without added sugar or salt - just crushed tomatoes, tomato puree, and citric acid (acidity regulator).

After adding spices, herbs, and other recipe ingredients and simmering for a bit, I can't tell the difference between the Cento and the Colavita.;)
 
San Marzano Tomatoes explained - from Google

So, what makes the Italian San Marzano tomatoes superior to other varieties that are grown in the US?

San Marzano Tomatoes are grown in Italy. On one particular piece of real estate and on one side of the mountain which give you the best quality in all of Italy and the World. Tomatoes that grow close to this real estate have much of same quality but can not be called San Marzano. Remember, the tomato is a fruit. Italy is also responsible for incredible wines made from it's amazing grapes grown in unique soil in which volcanic ash of Italy's past may play a role in its produce quality. Sometimes tenderness depends on when a tomato is picked or the way they are processed when it comes to American Brands.

***************


Why are imported Italian canned tomatoes more tender than the same American product?


***************


Unfortunately, it's a known problem. Much of the produce in the US has been bred for profit: size, color, amount produced per acre, and ability to survive handling (mechanized pickers, shipping long distances, etc).

It's that last one that tends to be the problem with tenderness -- a tomato that's tender when ripe will get squished when it's being picked in the field and transported to the canning facility:

(summary of the video : vines are cut and stripped, then tomatoes are flung into a large container where tons are collected at once, then they're washed, sorted, stripped of their skins, and possibly diced or crushed, sorted again, then canned and sterilized)

********************

San Marzano is both a type of tomato and a region in Italy. The San Marzano tomato is a type of plum tomato, but it's longer and thinner than the typical plum tomato; it also has a more obvious pointed tip and fewer seeds. Not all canned tomatoes from Italy are San Marzano, and to make things more confusing, San Marzano tomatoes grow outside of Italy, too. In fact, they are now also grown in the United States—and their seeds are widely available, which means you could grow San Marzano tomatoes in your vegetable garden.

Genuine Italian San Marzano will be labeled showing protected region.
DOP. Denominazione d'Origine Protetta | Protected Designation of Origin. The DOP label guarantees that your favorite cheese, prosciutto, olive oil, etc., is produced, processed, and packaged in a specific geographical zone and according to tradition. Each step, from production to packaging, is regulated.

Just like the designation of a specific area for growing onions to be sold as "Vidialia Onions".

bekeart
 
Last edited:
Bottled sauces contain too many additives and tomato skin which usually gives me heart burn or indigestion of some sort. I am done with having to take an antacid for dessert.

If anyone here is particular to a certain brand please share your opinions.....

Tomato varieties have varying amounts of citric acid. That is what causes the heartburn. San Marzano Tomatoes are low acid, some descriptions say sweet, smooth flavor.
Myself, I prefer the "bite" of a higher acid tomato, home grown.
 
It has been determined that the San Marzano tomato is a TYPE of tomato, that can be grown almost anywhere.
But there are few that actually COME from San Marzano, and the must be labeled as such..

The DOP certification for San Marzano tomatoes means that the tomatoes are grown in the Agro Sarnese-Nocerino region, near Mount Vesuvius.
This region is known for its volcanic soil and climate, which contribute to the unique flavor and characteristics of San Marzano tomatoes.
DOP certification ensures that the tomatoes are of the San Marzano variety and are grown, harvested, and processed according to specific regulation



SHAMELESS PLUG... Available at most PUBLIX:D

The cans must be marked as such..

a1983018-ae27-4c1e-86e8-35b4d6b83a27.png


00066086080770_C8N1-2-edited.jpg
 
Last edited:
Since then, I've been buying COLAVITA crushed tomatoes in their tetra pak (13.76 oz)(390g). This is a product of Italy that is naturally sweet without added sugar or salt - just crushed tomatoes, tomato puree, and citric acid (acidity regulator).

After adding spices, herbs, and other recipe ingredients and simmering for a bit, I can't tell the difference between the Cento and the Colavita.;)

Didn't Colavita play for the Cleveland Indians?:D
 
MsNative and I managed a not bad for rookies crop of San Marzano type and twice had 5 lbs. worth suitable for turning into sauce at one time. After the boil, peeling, seeding, mashing thru a sieve with the back of a spoon, food processing the remnants then shoving thru a sieve once more, then reducing with a bit of oil, garlic and basil I will never bark about the price of a can of Cento or other brand.The first batch yielded a bit less than a quart, the second (pictured) about 2 lbs. were oven roasted then packed in oil.
attachment.php
attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • mater.jpg
    mater.jpg
    56.7 KB · Views: 81
  • 5lbs.jpg
    5lbs.jpg
    48.1 KB · Views: 81
My wife will buy nothing but D.O.P. tomatoes, which around this neck of the woods are pretty expensive. She's been using Rega brand but found a few cans of Vantia brand and decided to try them. I can't tell the difference, but she says she can.
 
I can't believe that it took me 70+ years to discover the San Marzano tomatoes. Guess I have been hiding under a rock! I am making up for lost time though as I enjoy them quite often. Whenever I mention them to friends they look at me and say, oh - we have been eating them for many years...... :o
 
Just priced some of the Pastene DOP cans. Yikes! Thrice as expensive as the Contadina crushed that I use along with fresh Roma tomatoes to make my big batches of sauce. I may have to try a few cans just to see if there is 3 times better taste to go along with the cost.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top