daniel defence DD5v1 would you spend $3000?

marathonrunner · Mar 9, 2017

I was looking at this rifle at a gun store and it was certainly incredibly well built and very stout. However, I did a google search and found a lot of hits about feeding issues. I have read that many AR10's have issues with reliability is that true?

That said, to spend $3000 on one rifle seems ridiculous. I can get a BCM for probably $1700 . Anyway your thoughts.

Safestuffer · Mar 9, 2017

Gunbroker has several auctions for that gun at about $500 cheaper.
So if I were going to get one, I wouldn't pay full msrp when street price is that much lower.

eb07 · Mar 9, 2017

No way I'd buy a scar 17

paragain · Mar 9, 2017

In a word NO! Lots of fine AR's for much less and unless you are going to battle it is a profound waste of money. Have you considered the S&W?

dusty3030 · Mar 9, 2017

Not unless it alchemy'd the spent brass into gold. I just couldn't spend 3 grand on any kind of semi auto AR.

marathonrunner · Mar 9, 2017

dusty3030 said:
Not unless it alchemy'd the spent brass into gold. I just couldn't spend 3 grand on any kind of semi auto AR.

This is so very true! I would be a fool to waste so much. I am looking at Windham's .308 with the free floated barrel

shottist · Mar 9, 2017

Please remember that its generally accepted that you get what you pay for.

JohnRippert · Mar 9, 2017

Nope. Other than my Colt 6920 all mine are self built mutts that cost $500-600 to put together. Even the 6920 was only $850.

jack the toad · Mar 9, 2017

marathonrunner said:
That said, to spend $3000 on one rifle seems ridiculous. I can get a BCM for probably $1700 . Anyway your thoughts.

Because I can't afford to pay that plus I can build my own (and if I can do it, anyone can) using the parts I prefer, there's no way that I can see paying that much but I'm no expert.
Maybe apples to oranges but I've seen new DPMS AR10's for under $700.

RV4driver · Mar 9, 2017

Ask yourself, "is it twice to three times as good as" (insert name here).

Reminds me of the Tesla. Pathetic customer satisfaction numbers, amazing "would buy again" numbers.

patrickd · Mar 9, 2017

I'd be very disappointed after dropping 3K only to watch my $400 Savage .308 shoot circles around it.

LAA · Mar 9, 2017

My first "put together" (someone in another thread didn't like the term build)

, was in the $1600-$1800 bracket. The last two, around $1400 without optics. I owned a $800 dollar AR which worked just fine. But these three are even better. Just depends on what you want to spend for triggers, barrels, and the rest of components. There's even a lot of difference in free float rails, when it comes to machining, looks & finish.

In reality, sometimes twice is much, really is worth twice as much. As to three times, I don't know, since I haven't handled one.

Arik · Mar 9, 2017

Let's put it this way.

Rossi/Taurus/Windicator - S&W/Colt
DPMS/Windham - DD/BCM/KAC

Both shoot 38spl/357. So thus both are equal! Correct? What does S&W do that a Charter Arms doesn't?

Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk

marathonrunner · Mar 9, 2017

Thanks for all the input guys! Tell me if you agree with this, but someone told me getting a .308 in a 16" barrel in an AR platform makes no sense for close quarters as the kick, and over penatration would make it less than ideal. also been told the best close quarters would be the 16" 5.56 which would be still better than a .45 Was also told if you are going to get a .308 then make sure it is a 20" barrel.

The Daniel Defense DD for $3000 is amazingly cool looking but I still can't justify it's hefty price tag when I can get Windham .308 with a midwest floated handguard for $1250 including tax. No is not as stout as the DD but I can get two Windham's for the price of one DD .308

patrickd · Mar 10, 2017

marathonrunner said:
Thanks for all the input guys! Tell me if you agree with this, but someone told me getting a .308 in a 16" barrel in an AR platform makes no sense for close quarters as the kick, and over penatration would make it less than ideal. also been told the best close quarters would be the 16" 5.56 which would be still better than a .45 Was also told if you are going to get a .308 then make sure it is a 20" barrel.

The Daniel Defense DD for $3000 is amazingly cool looking but I still can't justify it's hefty price tag when I can get Windham .308 with a midwest floated handguard for $1250 including tax. No is not as stout as the DD but I can get two Windham's for the price of one DD .308

Looking for the best "close quarters" defense weapon? Look for a shotgun instead of an AR. Nothing is more effective in close quarters as a large gauge repeating shotgun.

Arik · Mar 10, 2017

patrickd said:
Looking for the best "close quarters" defense weapon? Look for a shotgun instead of an AR. Nothing is more effective in close quarters as a large gauge repeating shotgun.

Which is why all SWAT/SRT members carry shotguns!

No matter how you slice it a SD 556 round has less recoil, more energy and more ammo. Unless youre shooting point blank or slugs
Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk

LAA · Mar 10, 2017

marathonrunner said:
Thanks for all the input guys! Tell me if you agree with this, but someone told me getting a .308 in a 16" barrel in an AR platform makes no sense for close quarters as the kick, and over penatration would make it less than ideal. also been told the best close quarters would be the 16" 5.56 which would be still better than a .45 Was also told if you are going to get a .308 then make sure it is a 20" barrel.

The Daniel Defense DD for $3000 is amazingly cool looking but I still can't justify it's hefty price tag when I can get Windham .308 with a midwest floated handguard for $1250 including tax. No is not as stout as the DD but I can get two Windham's for the price of one DD .308

I haven't spent one cent on AR's with the idea of what's best for close quarters. I've spent a lot of money on them, because I have a lot of fun with them in the desert. I also like the idea of cool looking ARs. To me, they are one of several hobbies, along with reloads of .223 & 300 Blackout.

Unless there is a Zombie attack, with ample warning, I won't have time to dig the ARs out of their cases. I do my my shotgun, 45's, 9mms, etc. , if required.

marathonrunner · Mar 11, 2017

I wasn't so scared before because I knew the chance of me actually buying the DD5V1 was slim and none, but now I am really thinking of possibly just possibly breaking out my credit card. But then again I can get a Windham RS16 with a Midwest Free Float that is not as good, but very reliable. I can pick that up for $1250. It seems crazy to spend $280 on a rifle that is simply overkill

marathonrunner · Mar 11, 2017

look at this video of a DD5V1 fail. The person dropped it on the ground and the 4 bolts that attach the free floated handguard shifted and caused the rail to be out of alignment with reciever. There were other problems as well. Good thing I did not buy this rifle. also this rifle had issues with trigger failing to reset. Think I will stick to Windham's, Colts, and believe it or not I love my Sport ii. I would be definitely be bummed out had I spent 3K on a rifle and then find out it had many issues. I am also thankful I was here kicking this question around and pondering before making a rash decision. I understand the vast majority of DD owners are not going to drop their DD on the ground, but you don't see ven rifles like Bushmaster or DPMS doing this stuff. [ame]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8IJU0zm1glY[/ame]

Arik · Mar 11, 2017

marathonrunner said:
look at this video of a DD5V1 fail. The person dropped it on the ground and the 4 bolts that attach the free floated handguard shifted and caused the rail to be out of alignment with reciever. There were other problems as well. Good thing I did not buy this rifle. also this rifle had issues with trigger failing to reset. Think I will stick to Windham's, Colts, and believe it or not I love my Sport ii. I would be definitely be bummed out had I spent 3K on a rifle and then find out it had many issues. I am also thankful I was here kicking this question around and pondering before making a rash decision. I understand the vast majority of DD owners are not going to drop their DD on the ground, but you don't see ven rifles like Bushmaster or DPMS doing this stuff. Daniel Defense AR15, 2500 Rds Later: Died in my Arms... - YouTube

You don't know Rob do you? He's an ex Polish SF who does AK centric courses. His standard is all rifles have to be AK tough surviving Stalingrad. Some AKs he tests fail, I don't see a Bushmaster surviving he's tests either

Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk

daniel defence DD5v1 would you spend $3000?

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Absent Comrade

Member

Member

US Veteran

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Similar threads