Stag grips can be beautiful. They are great for photographing, for displaying, for safe queens, and for looking “purty.” However, I find them less than easy on the hand when actually shooting. So for the young and for those who still enjoy heavy felt recoil, they are fine, for the serious shooter my age, they are just not all that.
I once bought a beautiful Ruger Security Six with a very nice set of Sack Peterson stag grips hand crafted from American Elk. The first thing I did was remove the grips and sell them for $115 and put some nice stock wood grips on the revolver. At that time the same stag grips were selling new for $125, so I was pleased with the auction results I got on the grips.
It effectively reduced the cost I had in the Ruger to a level well below its market value. That was many years ago and I still have the Ruger and I like it so much more with the stock wood grips on it. That was my only experience with stag grips. Soon I may be putting rubber Pachmayr grips on that Ruger to replace the wood grips. Those rubber grips are sure ugly, but they are so nice to shoot with.
If I were still young and recoil tolerant like I once was, I might well love the stag grips, but at my age with arthritis, stag is just not something I want on any of my guns.