How satisfied are you with Froglube? (2014)
- Thread starter Llando88
- Start date
Stratajema
Member
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2013
- Messages
- 239
- Reaction score
- 87
Before FrogLube there was another dry lube called Militec-1. There were all kinds of posts about how "great" Militec-1 lubricated and protected guns. The posts were on all the gun related message boards. Then the department of defense did an analysis and testing of Militec-1 which showed it to be a garbage lubricant and an even worse rust preventative. ...That still didn't stop amatuers from posting about how "great" it was. Now the message boards are filled with people extolling the virtues of a plant-based wax that is known to grow mold on treated guns kept in a safe.
Last edited:
Rastoff
US Veteran
This did happen. It has been addressed and no longer does that. Thanks to the internet, this false information continues to be propagated.
Apples v. Oranges.
I had no true dissatisfaction with petroleum distillates as far as that goes, too, and indeed had a lot of resistance to trying the FrogLube, but I'm glad I did and have made the switch for all my semi-auto pistols.
In a few words- I use the paste, long-lasting, do not reapply it often. Guns have never been cleaner, safer, smell good. What's not to like about that?
Last edited:
Harrison
US Veteran
I have never tried it and have no reason to. The lubes I use have worked perfectly, for me, for many years. They are inexpensive and available anywhere. Froglube certainly is not available in the small city where I live and I have heard it is not inexpensive.
ocinsomniac
Member
Besides providing lubrication and enabling easier cleaning after the initial application when used as per instructions, FL has been proven to be a leader in corrosion prevention -
Comprehensive Corrosion Test: 46 Products Compared | Day At The Range
What initially impressed me about FL was how easy it enables cleanup after a long day at the range, carbon deposits just wipe right off. To an OC clean freak like myself, this was a plus, and being biodegradable, using nitril gloves are no longer necessary. It was also very impressive seeing its results on anti-corrosion tests like this one.
The key is to use sparingly, and wipe down excess, a little goes a long way. Been using it on all my firearms for the past 1 1/2 years and have never been as pleased as to how they function and how easily they clean up......
Comprehensive Corrosion Test: 46 Products Compared | Day At The Range
What initially impressed me about FL was how easy it enables cleanup after a long day at the range, carbon deposits just wipe right off. To an OC clean freak like myself, this was a plus, and being biodegradable, using nitril gloves are no longer necessary. It was also very impressive seeing its results on anti-corrosion tests like this one.
The key is to use sparingly, and wipe down excess, a little goes a long way. Been using it on all my firearms for the past 1 1/2 years and have never been as pleased as to how they function and how easily they clean up......
Bozz10mm
US Veteran
Been using FL for over a year. Works fine, no problems. I re-apply the paste with the heat treatment method every time I fire and clean them, usually about once a month. I use the liquid for the bore. It's really difficult for me to say that it makes cleaning easier, since I rarely shoot more than 100 rounds through a gun in one session. But, I am satisfied with Frog Lube.
It's expensive, but between my 5 pistols and 2 rifles, I believe I will get two years of cleaning, lubing, and protecting from the 4 oz liquid and 4 oz paste that I purchase on Amazon.
It's expensive, but between my 5 pistols and 2 rifles, I believe I will get two years of cleaning, lubing, and protecting from the 4 oz liquid and 4 oz paste that I purchase on Amazon.
EnticeTheMalice
Member
- Joined
- Aug 21, 2014
- Messages
- 40
- Reaction score
- 9
Best lube I've ever used.
M&Pmeister
Member
- Joined
- Aug 5, 2014
- Messages
- 166
- Reaction score
- 64
The thing I like the most about FL is that, when properly applied, it is essentially a dry lube and surface friction modifier. I used to have to relube my "truck guns" every so often because the wet lube evaporates when left in a hot car for weeks and months. Not exactly a big problem, it is something I have to remeber to do.
That bit about waxy type lube having too much viscosity is misguided. We used to lube racing bike chains with parafin wax. We heat up the wax and immerse a cleaned chain in it overnight. Then the chain is removed and most of the wax wiped off. It works fantastically and stays far cleaner than with oil based lube. It worked whether it was hot or cold. In essence, it works very similarly to FL.
FL is a surface friction modifier. Oil based lube provides thin film lubrication. Different operating principles.
I too have to agree FL is way overpriced. But that's a consequence of having little competition.
That bit about waxy type lube having too much viscosity is misguided. We used to lube racing bike chains with parafin wax. We heat up the wax and immerse a cleaned chain in it overnight. Then the chain is removed and most of the wax wiped off. It works fantastically and stays far cleaner than with oil based lube. It worked whether it was hot or cold. In essence, it works very similarly to FL.
FL is a surface friction modifier. Oil based lube provides thin film lubrication. Different operating principles.
I too have to agree FL is way overpriced. But that's a consequence of having little competition.
tropicheat
Member
- Joined
- Jul 26, 2014
- Messages
- 21
- Reaction score
- 5
I've been using FL for a few years now and since have not had any issues with corrosion or lubrication even in hot humid south florida. I put it on a knife I use for camping which is an unfinished carbon steel and have yet to see any rust spots even form after a year with no cleaning or re applying and I've used that knife gotten it in salt water too.
A more healthy alternative...
Your stated reasons were mine a couple of months ago. I was able to purchase the paste alone from a guy on ebay for about $12.00. I've used it on numerous guns and still have 75% of the jar left.
Despite your finding no justifiable reason for switching from your highly satisfactory cleaners and lubes, just go for it. What the heck?
I know, trying something different or new is extremely difficult when one is already happy.
Just give it a try.
Your stated reasons were mine a couple of months ago. I was able to purchase the paste alone from a guy on ebay for about $12.00. I've used it on numerous guns and still have 75% of the jar left.
Despite your finding no justifiable reason for switching from your highly satisfactory cleaners and lubes, just go for it. What the heck?
I know, trying something different or new is extremely difficult when one is already happy.
Just give it a try.
Last edited:
Look at the poll!
How about your health?
'You can lead a horse to water but not make him drink it.'
'It's difficult to teach an old dog new tricks'.
How about your health?
'You can lead a horse to water but not make him drink it.'
'It's difficult to teach an old dog new tricks'.
Last edited:
N4KVE
Member
No need to try it. Working at a LGS, I'm constantly getting free samples of gun lubes from the various mfr's. I have way more than I could ever use in my lifetime. Since I can't take it with me, maybe I'll try FL in my next lifetime, providing I come back as a human who likes guns & lives in a free country. GARY
78Staff
Member
I got a free sample when I bought a Nickel Boron AR BCG... kind of ironic, getting a sample of lube with a product that advertises (relatively) no lube needed lol.
Anyway, I haven't tried it - my initial interweb searches on FL turned up some unhappy campers, I'll have to go back and see if I can find the complaints... iirc something about getting gummy and sticky over time - admittedly at the time I was searching for AR-related cleaning and lubes, etc.
I've stuck to a standard process of CLP, #9 if needed, and TWB-25 or SLIP2000 depending on application... I do have Rand's verison of CLP on the way and will be testing it against Breakfree's version.
Anyway, I haven't tried it - my initial interweb searches on FL turned up some unhappy campers, I'll have to go back and see if I can find the complaints... iirc something about getting gummy and sticky over time - admittedly at the time I was searching for AR-related cleaning and lubes, etc.
I've stuck to a standard process of CLP, #9 if needed, and TWB-25 or SLIP2000 depending on application... I do have Rand's verison of CLP on the way and will be testing it against Breakfree's version.
hkcavalier
US Veteran
I had problems with Froglube and cold weather.
Mossberg 500 duck hunting gun got gummed up and wouldn't fire last November. Then a Kimber Solo I had got Froglube into the striker channel and caused light strikes.
It seems to have consistency and melting point very similar to butter or coconut oil. I'm not kidding, when cold it is tacky and very thick. Hot, it's nice and smooth.
Competitive shooters seem to love the stuff, but for guns that are carried much and shot little (and MUST work when the trigger is pulled) like hunting guns and EDC pistols, it's off my list. I used it to grease up a trailer hitch...
Mossberg 500 duck hunting gun got gummed up and wouldn't fire last November. Then a Kimber Solo I had got Froglube into the striker channel and caused light strikes.
It seems to have consistency and melting point very similar to butter or coconut oil. I'm not kidding, when cold it is tacky and very thick. Hot, it's nice and smooth.
Competitive shooters seem to love the stuff, but for guns that are carried much and shot little (and MUST work when the trigger is pulled) like hunting guns and EDC pistols, it's off my list. I used it to grease up a trailer hitch...
78Staff
Member
Right, that was one of the other complaints I had read about - but being in FL I didn't focus on that one too much
.
Rastoff
US Veteran
In every instance where the stuff seems to turn waxy or gum up, it has been because too much was used or left on the gun.
The directions are completely averse to how we are used to using lubricant. Since childhood we've been told that more grease/oil was better. With Frog Lube, a little goes a long way.
The proper application is:
Initial Application-
- Warm parts and apply Frog Lube liberally over every aspect of the gun.
- Let sit for at least 20 minutes. 2 hours is better.
- Wiped off the excess. This means everything.
Follow-up Applications-
- Clean gun by wiping down with a rag. Usually this will remove all deposits. Scrubbing is rarely necessary.
- Re-apply Frog Lube at the normal lube points.
- Let sit for a few minutes.
- Wipe off excess. This means everything.
Following this procedure is foreign to most of us. We are used to leaving at least a little product on there. When I tried to use the liquid Frog Lube like a regular lube, I had all the gummy, waxy results everyone else reported. Once I got over my apprehension and wiped it down good, no more trouble. The gun is easier to clean and works smooth as butter.
I admit I still have my reservations. Even so, it has been working so far and I use my gun regularly. I also have guns that spend more time in the safe and no trouble with them either.
1hatchet
Member
FL, personally I hate minty smells.
My Firearm Lube of choice is Gun Butter, oil and grease.
My Firearm Lube of choice is Gun Butter, oil and grease.
I love Frog Lube! Before I started using it, I was so bald that they were calling me Daddy Warbucks. One day while cleaning my Shield, I accidentally rubbed some Frog Lube on my head. The next day I noticed a smudge on my head. I tried washing it off, but I was shocked to see that it was hair! I then slathered the whole tube of Frog Lube on my head and within five minutes I could actually see the hair grow! I bought more Frog Lube that very day, and I am now one hairy son of a gun! And my Shield is clean. 
Similar threads
- Locked
