Any reason the Sports won't last as long as other AR's?

Wow there are some seriously good posts in this forum. I particularly like this quote:

Some boutique shops depend on the logical fallacy that price and quality are directly proportionate.

I learned this lesson back in the 1970's when Japanese cars were selling for half the price of American cars and they were built better too. That's no longer the case but at the time you could buy a Toyota that would go double the average mileage of an American car and it cost far less. So I learned then that quality is not a function of price. Price is determined by what the market will bear. If a company convinces people that their equipment is far better so it rates a higher price they better be prepared to prove that to me or not only will I not buy their product at that point but I will be suspicious about their integrity from that point on. All it took was driving a Ford product from the early 70's to convince anyone that the quality just wasn't there but they were still charging much higher prices than the imports. It took a long time before Ford earned my trust again but it did happen. Hype can drive the price of a piece of equipment. Don't fall for that age old scam. The idea that "you have to pay for quality" has made a lot of people very rich at the expense of their customers.

Another point I liked was that true knowledge is only truly gathered through personal experience. For the most part that's true but there are some shortcuts I take when it comes to guns. If it's a popular gun I'll go the range and watch the people shooting them. I learned a lot about various AR makers doing that. I shot a bunch of different brands that other people owned too. But when I saw certain brands being worked on more than they were being shot I knew I didn't want anything to do with those rifles. Some of them were made by popular companies in the entry level market but the guns were just not high quality. I will admit I learned much about the M&P Sport 15 on internet forums. I never saw a single person bash them. I'm talking people that actually owned them. You can always find some joker that thinks every rifle except the one he bought is a piece of garbage. i ignore those people.

One more point. I have a 1:9 twist bolt action .223 rifle. It will shoot anything from 50 gr. to 75 gr. bullets and do it well. I have always felt it was a better choice over the 1:7 twist models of the same rifle. Some of my best groups at 500 yards have been shot with very light bullets. That surprised me because of the wind factory but I shot a 1" group at 500 yards using 50 gr. ammo. Of course that rifle was built for accuracy instead of volume shooting but the principle is the same. 1:9 is a good choice for a twist rate. It has been for me anyway. I could have been burned on that because I didn't really know what rifles were what twist when I was trying out all those AR's at the range. I jumped in with both feet and it paid off. It might have gone the other way but I got lucky.

I think it's possible to get good data from the gun forums if the volume of posts are available about a weapon. I don't trust 10 people as much as I trust 10,000 people when it comes to gun reviews.
 
Many thanks for all the solid replies,guys. They only reinforced what I'd already assumed, that the cost-saving measures incorporated into the Sport series have no significant negative effect on longevity or overall quality.
The guy on that other forum does seem to irrationally and unjustifiably have a bug up the wazoo about S&W, but whatcha gonna do? He says he's gonna trade/sell it back to his LGS, who will naturally screw him sideways. Guys on the forum are already making low-ball offers ! Hell, I'd happily take a smokin' deal on a S&W Sport fresh back from rehab !! :D
 
Last edited:
JaPes summed it up pretty well.

Similarly, hard chromed bores are great if you will be doing full auto fire with your AR-15 - but unless you have class 3 receiver, that's just not an issue, and even if you do the difference in barrel life isn't that significant, and give the low cost of non chrome AR-15 barrels, you can afford to replace a non chrome barrel twice as often and still come out ahead.

Ah, no. You can, and we did, burn out non plated barrels in CQB training without full auto fire. The plated barrels just keep going and going and going. Also, the cost difference between plated and non-plated runs about $40 per barrel. Given the price of a quality barrel, the choice of a plated bore is a no brainer if rapid fire sequences are part of your training, work or play.

The uniformity claim is also suspect. That's usually the claim of manufacturers who are too cheap to use quality barrels, plated or plain. FN furnishes their precision/sniper rifles with plated bores and they have no difficulty maintaining extreme precision. Not that most folks buy ARs for bench rest shooting.
 
The uniformity claim is also suspect. That's usually the claim of manufacturers who are too cheap to use quality barrels, plated or plain.

I have to agree with this. I've seen the differences in brands with my fairly limited exposure to the platform. I've seen jam-o-matics that were portrayed on forums as quality entry level AR's. I've seen my Sport do far better and for less money. There will always be some that are better than the rest and some worse. Finding out which is which can be a hard row to hoe. I waited years to find the right entry level AR. It was the Sport and I haven't been disappointed. YMMV
 
There are some really great posts on this subject. I own one of these rifles and have only made a couple of changes. I did put a red/green dot sight on the top and changed the hand guards so I could add a side rail for a light/laser device. I haven't put too many rounds through my Sport yet mainly because I shoot handguns more than my rifles or shotguns. I was an Air Force Small Arms Technician/Supervisor when the Air Force first got their AR 15s. I might mention that they didn't have forward assists and I felt they weren't needed when the Army insisted they be provided. From my past experience, with ARs we put a massave amount of training rounds through, I did purchase a spare firing pin, firing pin retaining pin, extractor, ejector and springs. I may never need them but those are the parts we replaced most back then.
 
Last edited:
Everything I read and heard leading up to buying a Sport 2 was I'd be an idiot if I bought a Colt Expanse or 6920 over the Sport 2 or Ruger due to the price difference. I would love for someone to prove a 6920 will outlast a Sport 2 over an extended time period. I understand the Colt has a better resale value, but are actual build quality between a Colt and S&W that much different? Can the average consumer really tell a difference? I'd love to see a side by side comparison between the quality of both firearms. I think it's laughable to say my Sport 2 won't last a lifetime if I properly take care of it.
 
Last edited:
Ain't nothing wrong with the Colt or Ruger. They're fine rifles. What gets folks riled up are those that turn off rational thought in favor of defensive fan-boy behavior. Colt makes a heck of a nice rifle. Drawback for me is the higher price of the brand image (prancing pony roll mark) commands. Ruger makes fine AR, but the screw down handguard ring + unlined and untreated barrel are a turn off for me.

The criticism for the Sport was the omission of a forward assist and dust cover. That was overcome by the old Melonite treated, 1:8 5r progressive gain twist, Thompson center barrel. Now they added a forward assist & dust cover, the barrel is an Armornite treated 1/9 6-groove twist barrel. Give a little, take a little.

There is always a give and take with factory complete rifles. If you're the type to know every build detail of your ideal rifle, then it's time to obsessively pick every component part and build your own.
 
I'd happily take a smokin' deal on a S&W Sport fresh back from rehab !! :D

Not a bad thought, as a firearm sent back, worked on, and tested has an extra level of QA not afforded the production line.
 
I wouldn't be surprised if AR's aren't rising in price as I type this.......

They certainly are... Academy Sports and Outdoors has pulled their ARs from display. They will still sell them, but you have to ask now. They are also keeping a database of large ammo purchases... Hang on to your hats, I think we are in for a bumpy ride.
 
They certainly are... Academy Sports and Outdoors has pulled their ARs from display. They will still sell them, but you have to ask now. They are also keeping a database of large ammo purchases... Hang on to your hats, I think we are in for a bumpy ride.

Apparently they won't be selling Daniel Defense anymore...
 
They certainly are... Academy Sports and Outdoors has pulled their ARs from display. They will still sell them, but you have to ask now. They are also keeping a database of large ammo purchases... Hang on to your hats, I think we are in for a bumpy ride.
local Academy has pulled ARs and anything resembling an AR - air rifles , air soft etc. from the shelf. "Large" (10 boxes up) ammo purchases are reported to the company. My question is what are they doing with the database?
 
Colt AR's have stood the test of military use for many years. S&W AR's have not. LE use is not the same as military use.
 
Last edited:
In the first post the OP stated the lack of dust cover and foreward assist weren't big u issues to him. Bolts and related small parts aren't lifetime parts on any AR, and most armorers recomend preventive replacement periodically, with numbers of 5-10k rounds frequently mentioned. As always your opinions and millage will vary on preventive part replacement.

Leaves primarily the bbl . If your future includes frequent repetive mag dumps, chrome lined bore will slow down errosion. If you don't frequently make the bbl glow, a 4140 bbl will last a plenty long time. If not as not as long as 4150, but still more rounds that 99% of owners who pay their own money for ammo will ever put through them.
 
GREAT thread as I am starting to look at ARs.. My LGS is around 600$ for the S&W not as good as the link posted but hes sold out :(
To all who repl;ied Thanks this thread has helped me alot
 
GREAT thread as I am starting to look at ARs.. My LGS is around 600$ for the S&W not as good as the link posted but hes sold out :(
To all who repl;ied Thanks this thread has helped me alot

Yea all the decent prices have dried up for now. Have to wait for the bruhaahaa to simmer down. Looks like we missed our "window" by about 20 days


Patiently watching;)
 
Back
Top