How Many Have DUMPED their J-Frame for a NEW MINI Semi-Auto?

[Execpro]

Snub nose forever

I have had and shot S&W revolvers for years starting with a model 19 back in the 60’s. I recently (past 4 years) carried a 642 until 2016 when I traded it for a 9mm shield.

The 642 trigger pull was too much,the worst I have ever run across even after a trigger job,but it was an awesome AIWB gun. I carried the Shield until last summer,but I just really missed my J frame.

Went to mlgs looking for another J frame (the Lady Smith model has a great trigger) but all I tried had the same issue. (No Lady Smith Mod 60 -38/357 in stock)

I purchased a Taurus M85 ($210 after rebate). It had the sweetest trigger and on the range it didn’t beat the heck out of my hand with the +P loads I carry like the 642 did.

I really love both guns but carry the snub nose most of the time, switching with the Shield if I feel a need for more firepower. Both shoot 10ring groups offhand at 7 yards.
J frames rule!
Be Safe!

 

[zogger]

I wonder how many people will change back to revolvers with 5 or 6 shot capacity if NJ passed their 5 rounds in a magazine law?

 

[Louchia]

I have a 442J the I put aside for a Sig P938. It's more comfortable for me to carry IWB. So far it's flawless at 1500+ rnds.
However I will not give up my J.

 

[max503]

These are better than an auto, I think.

 

[oldiesradio1560]

I've carried revolvers since the 70's since I've seen way to many autos jam over the years. My current concealed carry is a 640-1 Pro Series that I pocket carry. I also have 3 speedloaders on me so with 20 rounds of Hormany Critical Defense 125gr. .357 mag. I'm covered.

 

[daddy bear]

Five J-frames, one Colt 1908. Daughter Two has the Colt, Daughter One has one of my 60s. I carry a 42 and have two 60s stashed in handy places. Few affrays require even five shots.

If I knew trouble was coming, I would reach for a shotgun loaded with #2s.

Jack

 

[dandyrandy]

If you can find a reliable small and light 9mm auto than its far superior to that of the J frame snub. PM 9, MK 9 and Micro 9 come to mind. Even the 380 autos are superior to the little snub in some respects.

 

[Sal1950]

The 642 trigger pull was too much,the worst I have ever run across even after a trigger job,but it was an awesome AIWB gun.!

I'd find a different gunsmith if he couldn't get you a trigger you loved on that 642. No reason for it.

 

[JWM]

Magazine limits

I wonder how many people will change back to revolvers with 5 or 6 shot capacity if NJ passed their 5 rounds in a magazine law?

This is what will keep the revolver alive in the modern era. As a retired LEO, I'm finding that my Glock 17 is not welcome in many states that I visit. So, I dusted off my 5-6 shot revolvers for USA travel under LEOSA. Glad I did not dump those old fashioned wheel guns.

 

[JayFramer]

I'd trust a J or K frame snub to ANY micro 380. Have had bad luck with a new Ruger LCP II breaking. Don't ever recall my .38s busting.