Looking for a good Custer biography.

Smoke

US Veteran
Joined
Aug 11, 2013
Messages
6,140
Reaction score
9,132
Location
Colorado
Can anyone reccomend a good biography of George Custer?

I'm reading The Battle of the Wash- ita by by Stan Hoig and I realized that I've never read a good book that covered Custer's whole life.

Can anyone reccomend a biography that covers MORE than just the Little Bighorn?
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Two I can think of to start with:

"Son of the Morning Star" by Evan S. Connell

"Crazy Horse and Custer" by Stephen Ambrose

Also a recent book I read about the battle and recommend is "A Terrible Glory" by James Donovan.
 
Reading A Terrible Glory by Donovan right now. Covers events before the battle and is a great read so far. Available in paperback.
 
In addition to the recommendations above, I highly recommend "The Last Stand: Custer, Sitting Bull, and the Battle of the Little Bighorn"
by Nathaniel Philbrick

Philbrick is an excellent historian and his books are very engaging. In fact I'd recommend most all of his histories. (Check the reviews on amazon.)
 
Last edited:
I second the above recommendations for the Custer-specific books. If you are interested in a broader perspective, Centennial Campaign: The Sioux War of 1876 by John S. Gray is very good. It covers all the major engagements of that year.

Archaeological Perspectives on the Battle of the Little Bighorn by Scott, et. al. is excellent. The authors used modern forensic analysis of battlefield artifacts to examine how the fight progressed. One factoid, they determined that over 200 individual firearms using the .44 Henry rimfire cartridge were used in the battle. They traced one specific rifle from the Last Stand site to Reno Hill. Obviously the repeating firearms, either Henry or Winchester Model 1866 rifles, were in the hands of the Sioux and Cheyenne warriors.
 
I already own

A Terrible Glory

Son of the Morning Star

The Custer Reader

And Marie Sandoz'

The Battle of The Little Bighorn which is really more about Reno and Benteen than Custer.

I'm looking for something that covers his early life to the end of the Civil War. I want to know why they promoted him to Brigadier General after promoting him from Second Lieutenant to Captain then busting him back down to First Lieutenant.

I want to know how he managed to fight J.E.B Stuart to a standstill.

I want to know if he really went through an article 32 at West Point that almost ended his career before it started or was that just a myth
 
Last edited:
I'm looking for something that covers his early life to the end of the Civil War. I want to know why they promoted him to Brigadier General after promoting him from Second Lieutenant to Captain then busting him back down to First Lieutenant.

I want to know how he managed to fight J.E.B Stuart to a standstill.

I want to know if he really went through an article 32 at West Point that almost ended his career before it started or was that just a myth

"Crazy Horse and Custer" by Stephen Ambrose covers the promotion to brigadier general pretty well. As a lieutenant, Custer had served on General George McClellan's staff, and fought during the Peninsula Campaign that began in the spring of 1862. Custer persuaded a colonel into allowing him to lead an attack with four companies of Michigan infantry across the Chickahominy River above New Bridge. The attack was successful, capturing 50 Confederates. Major General George B. McClellan, commander of the Army of the Potomac, termed it a "very gallant affair," congratulated Custer personally, and brought him onto his staff as an aide-de-camp with the temporary rank of captain.

Custer earned a reputation for both bravery and brashness. He also became known as a publicity hound, taking every opportunity to get himself in front of the newspapermen documenting the war.

His primary benefactor, though, was Major General Alfred Pleasonton, commanding a cavalry division. After Chancellorsville, Pleasonton became the commander of the Cavalry Corps of the Army of the Potomac and his first assignment was to locate the army of Robert E. Lee, moving north through the Shenandoah Valley in the beginning of the Gettysburg Campaign. Custer distinguished himself by fearless, aggressive actions in some of the numerous cavalry engagements that started off the campaign, including Brandy Station and Aldie.

Three days prior to the Battle of Gettysburg, at General Pleasonton's urging, General Meade promoted Custer from first lieutenant to brevet brigadier general (temporary rank) of volunteers. Pleasonton desperately needed to shake up the Cavalry Corps, which had not been doing well in its battles with Stuart, and he wanted fresh young men at the top. Pleasonton simply wanted the hardest driving, most ambitious young officers to give his cavalry some spirit and he saw this in Custer.

Custer played a key role at the Battle of Gettysburg, preventing General J.E.B. Stuart from attacking Union troops, and later capturing Confederates fleeing south after the Union victory. But his brigade lost more than 250 men, the highest of any Union cavalry unit. Custer's units would continue to rack up a disproportionate number of casualties throughout the war. According to Ambrose's book, Custer's style of battle sometimes bordered on reckless or foolhardy. He often impulsively gathered up whatever cavalrymen he could find in his vicinity and led them personally in bold assaults directly into enemy positions. One of his greatest attributes during the Civil War was luck, and he needed it to survive some of these charges.

His aggressive battle tactics seemed to be just what the Union Army needed at the time he was promoted, and although his tactics lacked imagination his recklessness carried him through. Unfortunately, that same lack of imagination and his recklessness is what got he and his final command wiped out.
 
Last edited:
Custer in The Civil War

Hi from Michigan;
I had a number of relatives in Co K, 6th Michigan Volunteer Cavalry, Michigan Cavalry Brigade, so have collected too many books on the Civil War.
I suggest modern books "Custer and His Wolverines" by Edward G Longacre, and anything by Eric J Wittenberg.
Lt (later General) J H Kidd's earlier book "Personal Recollections of a Cavalryman" (later published as "Riding With Custer" is a
useful older work.
Short answer to promotion question: Union Cavalry early in the war was in short supply and poorly used, and not consolidated for action against the Southern Cavalry. Some heads rolled, and aggressive young officers promoted, including Custer and Merrit. Similar story to Guderian's tanks against the French and English armor in early WWII.
Looks up East Cavalry Field at Gettysburg!
PM me if you want more.
 
The Army I was in had a solution for officers who didn't care how many casualties their outfit took. Does the word 'frag' ring a bell?

Patton said something along the lines of: I don't want you men to die for your country; I want to make the other guys die for their country.
 
Custer was present at Appomattox Court House when Lee surrendered. He may or may NOT have bought the table that Lee used. Anyway, after the ceremony, Custer went whooping and hollering, waving the table over his head. General Chamberlain had his men drawn up and presented arms.

One was respectful and the other was not.
 
Custer was present at Appomattox Court House when Lee surrendered. He may or may NOT have bought the table that Lee used. Anyway, after the ceremony, Custer went whooping and hollering, waving the table over his head. General Chamberlain had his men drawn up and presented arms.

One was respectful and the other was not.

I think you got some snippets of stories a bit mixed up. ;)

The story that at Appomattox Custer rode into the camp of the Army of Northern Virginia and somewhat flamboyantly demanded its surrender to him, but was sent packing by Longstreet, seems well-documented. However, he wasn't present at the actual ceremony, and the fact that several famous later paintings show him incorrectly in attendance has been much discussed.

The famous table, however, was purchased by General Sheridan and presented as a gift to Libby Custer, with a note that said "My Dear Madam, I respectfully present to you the small writing table on which the conditions for the surrender of the Confederate Army of Northern Virginia were written by Lt. Gen. Grant —and permit me to say, Madam, that there is scarcely an individual in our service who has contributed more to bring about this desirable result than your very gallant husband."
 
I read this one, "The Real Custer From Boy General to Tragic Hero" by James S. Robbins a while back for the reasons you listed. I love to read about the Little Big Horn, but I wanted to read a bit about the man prior to his demise. It was an interesting read and covered his Civil War career and life at West Point. I enjoyed it.
 
Looking at different sources, half say Custer was present at the surrender and half say he wasn't.

I wonder if the Official Records say anything about who was present.

Depends on how you define the "surrender". Custer was definitely at Appomattox. He just didn't attend the actual festivities.

The two snips attached come from the National Park Service, which has custody of ACH. Having worked for and with NPS historians, albeit just in a volunteer capacity, I trust them to have their facts straight, not the least because they are besieged daily by know-it-all visitors who consider themselves amateur historians :)
 

Attachments

  • Custer Appo 1.JPG
    Custer Appo 1.JPG
    127.4 KB · Views: 26
  • Custer Appo 2.JPG
    Custer Appo 2.JPG
    98.9 KB · Views: 28
While the North Carolina colonel disobeyed General Lee, I don't recall that any Union army personnel would be subject to Lee's orders.

Yes, there has been quibbling about the wording. Lee expressed his request to Babcock, who as you may note was a Union brigadier general accompanying him. Since Custer was only a brigadier of volunteers, Babcock may have outranked him, but I don't know the details. So technically Lee's wish was a direct order only for the Confederate officer, but Babcock could possibly order Custer and his sidekick to cease and desist.

19th century military courtesies being what they were, everything was likely couched in the most polite terms along the lines of "General Lee sends his regards, but would like me to convey his wish that you might not ...." :)
 
Back
Top