M41 barrel finish question.

andyo5

Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2007
Messages
2,369
Reaction score
948
Location
Oro Valley, Arizona
Hi, all. I need some help from the Model 41 experts.
I recently purchased a used 7" M41 barrel on ebay. It was described as in excellent condition with a few tiny surface flaws, original finish, excellent bore, etc.etc.
Anyhow, I cleaned and shot the barrel today and it does seem to be in excellent mechanical condition with great groups (for me) and a bright bore with good crown and rifling.
My only concern is this:
When I first took it out of the shipping box, I noticed a bluish cast to to the left and right slab sides of the barrel. Everything else looks black, and the few tiny marks that are there could easily be touched up. But as I turned the barrel under a light, I could see the color appear to change from black to a milky blue appearance. On the left side, the cut off point seems to be the 'E' in the word 'Wesson'. If I rock the barrel backwards so the back is lower than the front, the rear half looks blue and the front half looks black. Rock it the other way, and you get the opposite results (see photos). There is a similar effect on the right side, in almost exactly the same pattern. I tried to see if it would rub off. I put some Birchwood Casey Sheath on a piece of towel and gently rubbed back and forth. Some light tan colored material came off onto the towel.
I believe that this barrel is from another production era than my gun (probably older), so I did not expect a perfect match. But I did expect it to be black.

So here's my question: Do you think this barrel has been refinished?
The seller seems quite reputable and offered a 30 day return. He seems to re-sell a variety of items and I don't think he has firearms expertise so he may actually think this is the original finish even if it isn't. I'm not sure I would return it for this, but for my peace of mind I'd like to understand this better. I paid $263 shipped.
Thanks!
 

Attachments

  • D7K_3011.jpg
    D7K_3011.jpg
    76 KB · Views: 68
  • D7K_3013.jpg
    D7K_3013.jpg
    79.2 KB · Views: 58
  • D7K_3014.jpg
    D7K_3014.jpg
    123.3 KB · Views: 51
  • D7K_3017.jpg
    D7K_3017.jpg
    92.2 KB · Views: 54
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Based on the integrity of the stampings on the barrel, (SMITH & WESSON) I would say no, in terms of a re-finish that would normally require removal of the old finish, buffing, and re-bluing. The stamping looks crisp/sharp at the edges. I can't see the "non-reflective" area on top of the barrel, but that would be another good place to look, as that "matte" finish applied at the factory would be very hard to duplicate when compared to another 41 barrel. (if you have one)

As far as the possible application of something that negatively changed the original finish, I cannot tell for sure.
 
Last edited:
I can't see the "non-reflective" area on top of the barrel, but that would be another good place to look, as that "matte" finish applied at the factory would be very hard to duplicate when compared to another 41 barrel. (if you have one)

Yes, the rougher matte finish on top and bottom of the barrel do not seem to have been disturbed.
 
Definitely reblued, probably as a touch up, using the wrong color.
This photo shows that someone had scratched up the bottom bearing surface of the barrel with something, and applied the same blue coloring as on the sides. Had they used the correct color bluing, I probably would not have noticed.
 

Attachments

  • D7K_3022.jpg
    D7K_3022.jpg
    77.4 KB · Views: 42
Last edited:
Decided to return it after all. Ebay will cover the shipping.
After the last two online purchases of used guns, I am getting tired of the lying and misrepresentation. No reason to tolerate it.
 
Back
Top