My EDC (don't laugh) is a new model Llama .32 semi-auto at 8+1 with one reload. The new Llamas are 1911 pattern handguns and work the same. My going to a danger zone, but not Chicago, I carry a Kimber Micro 9 at 7+1. Going into the Chicago area it's a Model 59, no dash, or a Colt Officers Model with 7+1. Only once in all the time I've carried (other than overseas) I have only once been happy I was carrying, and I was damn glad I didn't need to do anything more then let the wind carry my covering shell open, so the potential danger decided there were easier pickings. Me thinks he doesn't like .358 holes in his hyde.
Notice I'm choosing to be armed according to the potential situation not to the insistence of someone else idea of what I'm going to need or have to carry.
Choose your EDC wisely and to the situation, not to someone else idea of what you need.