M57 surgery was successful

Hair Trigger

US Veteran
Joined
Feb 8, 2016
Messages
3,633
Reaction score
8,202
Location
western NC
After seeing the resurrected thread on M57's elsewhere today, I decided I was going to see if I could remove the accessory vented rib that was on the M57 I bought a couple of years ago. I found it at a gun show, had Altamont stocks that didn't really look good on it, plus a vented rib, a la Dan Wesson or Colt Python. I didn't want to pass on the gun, it was an "S" prefix and the finish was 90%. The stocks got replaced with nicer Altamonts and I figured I could live with the rib.

Unique as it looked, I've never been able to get my head around the rib, it was not original and made the gun look too different. However, it was nicely installed, not screwed on but bonded somehow. I finally decided today, it was coming off, one way or the other. I had examined it through a strong 15X magnifier, and determined the bonding agent was some sort of silicone gasket cement. My fear was damaging the gun's rib trying to get the vented rib off, mainly scratching it or removing the bluing somehow. Using a metal tool to dig the adhesive or pry the rib was not an option, so what I came up with was a plastic tool used to remove door panels from cars. You know the kind, they have a thin end and you pry between the panel and metal door with them. Well I wedged the thin end next to the front sight and the accessory rib, lifting it ever so slightly. I took a surgical scalpel and cut the adhesive, keeping the blade against the accessory rib. Then I moved the plastic tool further up and wedged it again, repeated with the scalpel, and once I got to where the barrel joined the frame, the accessory rib popped off.

I hadn't scratched the revolver, the rib was off, but the grooves in the barrel rib were full of the adhesive. Using the plastic tool, I started rubbing the adhesive and then using a stiff toothbrush to remove the loosened adhesive. A final cleaning with a fine brass brush, then some solvent and a plastic bristle brush, and the rib was clean.

I love having a nice, stock appearing M57 now. I have a letter request out to SWHF, I want to see what the ship date is so I can find a set of period correct target stocks. The SN dates it to 1968, possibly 1969; I want to see if diamonds are correct (hope so).

I'm a long-winded old fart, but here are a few pics, before and after:
 

Attachments

  • DSC01656.jpg
    DSC01656.jpg
    175 KB · Views: 524
  • IMG_2648.jpg
    IMG_2648.jpg
    149.5 KB · Views: 482
  • IMG_2647.jpg
    IMG_2647.jpg
    158 KB · Views: 443
  • IMG_2649.jpg
    IMG_2649.jpg
    61.3 KB · Views: 351
Register to hide this ad
I remember seeing those ribs advertised in the back pages of the 70's gun magazines of the time...I think this is the first time I've ever seen one actually installed on a gun...It looks much better now...I'm reminded of all the current picatinny mounted gimcrackery available on modern plastic guns...:rolleyes:...Ben
 
I think you might be right on the edge between diamond and non diamond targets. My 29-2 S2823xx came with diamond targets in 1968, and my understanding is they were being phased out about that time.
 
I can totally relate to your anxiousness of removing the rib. I have a couple of really nice Kimber model 82's that had glued on butt pads that were totally destroyed from sitting on their butts in the safe. The first thought of trying to remove a glued on pad from such nice wood had me losing sleep. But like you, after some careful thought I came up with a plan that worked.
Nice looking 57 BTW..
 
I have bought several handguns over the years with those vented ribs and found that a careful application of heat helps loosen the adhesive up and suds in the clean up process.
 
quote "Unique as it looked, I've never been able to get my head around the rib, it was not original and made the gun look too different." unquote

Great assessment. Glad you changed it. Looks more acceptable to me, too.
 
Great job! Your 57 now looks like it was meant to. BTW I requested a Letter of Authenticity from the Historical Foundation recently and it arrived in less than three weeks. (Thank you Historical Foundation) My revolver was shipped from Smith & Wesson on April 2, 1964. I knew it was an early example but not quite that early.

Good luck completing your project with a set of period correct stocks and thanks for sharing, I enjoyed your post.
 
I think you might be right on the edge between diamond and non diamond targets. My 29-2 S2823xx came with diamond targets in 1968, and my understanding is they were being phased out about that time.
Thanks, Everybody. I think you're right on being borderline. I got my Letters in the mail today, hurrah! The M57 letter does not mention diamond target stocks, it just says shipped with GA target stocks. The ship date was June 23, 1970, but the letter also mentions the S prefix changed in 1969 at S333454 (doesn't say how late in the year); my SN is 13,923 earlier than that, So I feel safe saying mine is a 1969 manufacture. Still puts it in the cusp of Diamonds? no Diamonds?, but maybe one of the Head Gurus can get it closer.

I'd love to put a set of Diamond Targets on it; my M58 Letter says a ship date of August 22, 1968, and it had diamond PC's on it when I got it, numbered to the gun. (letter did not mention a diamond, just PC magnas) Would be nice for my two oldest S&W's to both have the diamond stocks. I already knew most of the stuff on my M58, because I have a note from the original purchaser to his former partner (LE partners) with the information on it. I purchased the revolver from the partner who inherited it.

All in all, I feel like I have a "new to me" gun now, although I've owned the M57 for a couple of years now, and it's been to the range with me quite a bit.

That is a huge improvement. I never understood the thinking behind a ventilated rib on a handgun. Going for a look I guess as they are not functional like on a shotgun.
Just curious, how are vented ribs functional on a shotgun? I have four SxS doubles, two have vented ribs, two don't, and I have a pump shotgun with a vented rib.
 
Back
Top