Thoughts on out of state moving & local resentment

brendonjames65

US Veteran
Joined
Jul 29, 2021
Messages
306
Reaction score
1,363
Location
Oklahoma
There is an interesting phenomenon when one moves. Some locals develop the attitude as if they own the state how and how dare an outsider move to their area. The last time I checked, a citizen can move wherever they damn well please. Many veterans have earned that right as well by risking their lives to protect our country or having bled for our country but any citizen has the right to move to the state of their choice, this is America the last time I checked! Yes, we’ve always assimilated but that’s beside the point, I don’t need to ask a locals permission to move now or ever.

When we relocated from California to Montana, I only encountered this attitude online on various social media platforms but never in person. Some local people will spout this rhetoric online but never to your face and even some of them relocated from somewhere. A big complaint many locals had was outsiders were buying up all the properties and dramatically increasing the prices so no local could afford to buy yet it was locals who were selling the properties to outsiders for a tidy profit! Of course perhaps bringing the same voting habits that ruined their previous state is a legitimate concern. Full disclosure: I never wanted to leave California but it became unrecognizable to me and we chose to leave after retirement. If the political climate was like it was say 20 years ago, I would have tolerated it and stayed.

A couple of Montana locals I became good friends with were a couple of guys in their 80’s. Perhaps I had more in common with them. My friend and old time master gunsmith Dennis Olson knew both Jack O’Connor and Elmer Keith. Dennis is tough as nails and doesn’t suffer fools. I remember when Dennis and I went on a very rugged 12 mile off trail hike, fording the creek over a felled log and climbing the steep terrain to checkout the damage from the Graves Creek fire. Pretty good for an 80 yr old guy recovering from cancer! The man’s fitness level could put many 20 year olds to shame even in his 80’s! Dennis had moved to Montana from South Dakota back in the late 50’s. I asked him how long did it take for the locals to accept you? Dennis replied, “25 years!”

Since relocating to Oklahoma for family reasons, we haven’t encountered this online or otherwise. Really nice folks here although probably not a destination area although I think it should be. Very beautiful and as long as I have land to hunt and shoot I’m quite content. I think people generally get along well in person but not always online for obvious reasons. I certainly get that nobody wants their community changed for the worse but we’re still a free country where folks can move wherever they want!

Update 11/8: Just to update since I didn’t explain it very well:

We got along very well with the locals we interacted with in person in our community in north western Montana during our 4 years there. I was invited to join a militia after all! Certainly that’s a sign of acceptance! I politely declined. My great grand parents immigrated from Ireland to Butte MT in the 1890’s as well. It’s the locals who complain online and pass judgement about newcomers without even knowing them that irritates me! Passing judgement on people you’ve never met is something I will never accept or agree with pure & simple! Yes it’s just the internet, ignorance abounds at times, usually I ignore it.
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
I agree it is a silly phenomenon. I have read about it but don't think I have experienced it. But that may just be me. I am likely simply impervious to noticing if people think I am an outsider.

Since childhood, I have moved many times, and I spent most of my adult life in Japan, where there was no question whatsoever about being accepted as a local. (Meaning no one, including me, had any expectations that I would be.)

My approach to this is I try to behave properly and treat others with courtesy and respect. I don't spend any time at all thinking about whether others accept me or not.

Not my problem.
 
Last edited:
I agree it is a silly phenomenon. I have read about it but don't think I have experienced it. But that may just be me. I am likely simply impervious to noticing if people think I am an outsider.

Since childhood, I have moved many times, and I spent most of my adult life in Japan, where there was no question whatsoever about being accepted as a local. (Meaning no one, including me, had any expectations that I would be.)

My approach to this is I try to behave properly and treat others with courtesy and respect. I don't spend any time at all thinking about whether others accept me or not.

Not my problem.

Great attitude to have. I think certain states it’s really, really exacerbated like Montana, which has seen a huge influx of newcomers. Oklahoma, not so much.
 
Going from liberal California to the last frontier of Montana you got the stink eye because narrow minded people thought you were a from California. Going from Montana to Oklahoma is like walking across the street. They are basically the same. Now that you’re twice removed from California the stigma should be gone. Being from NY I’ve experienced as well. But as you say, never in person.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You should come to Vegas. It's the overspill destination for the whole planet. If it ever had a "basic community" I suspect it was overwhelmed by imports before I got here in '97. Of course, the population growth here has been insane, fueled by low taxes and cheap (and often nasty) housing.

By 2000, newcomers were treating me as a local because "You've been here a while".:confused::confused::confused: Since then the city has outgrown its utility as a place to live (too many people) and the hard commercial attitude in the entertainment industries have squashed a lot of the fun. Still, the sun shines a lot and the airport has flights to almost everywhere, so it's a great base of operations.

We would move closer to family in Texas, except neither of us wants to live in tornado or hurricane country. We also have concerns about water, power, and certain politics in the state. Pile on the property taxes that Texas seems to have, and we'll likely stay put.

With regard to other countries for retirement, my wife and I have sufficient ethnicity between us to allow us to live in multiple places, including the UK and Spain. However, I don't see any of them as permanent homes for a laundry list of reasons.
 
Well said…

People are moving from there because they do no like it there. When they get here they want to change it to what it was like there. People here wish they had stayed there because they do not want here to be changed to there.

This relates well to another post, “Elections have consequences”

I originated in CA. Spent 10 years in TX. Now in OK. When folks ask me where I’m from I say Texas.
 
People are people and many should have been drowned at birth. This world is always gonna have strife and hate and hard feelings because you just can't 'pass a law' and cure those kinds of things. Feeling superior to others because of money, education, ethnicity or political philosophies is a false pedestal to stand on. As far as "interlopers" moving in from out of state, I've seen both sides of it - those who unfairly get less than a warm welcome because they fled a state that has "that reputation" and those like a guy I had to work with for about a year that came from "Bahston". Didn't mind taking the money he made here but never failed to tell anyone and everyone how he hated this back-wood bastion of hillbillies.
 
I have a rural Montana background.
What really bothers folks is outsiders moving there and bringing their failed politics with them.

I think it’s more an online social media phenomenon which I encountered but never in person in rural western Montana. If they had an opinion at a BBQ or social function they kept it to themselves. What I found was some locals (online social media) formulated a negative opinion to all outsiders knowing nothing about them or their background and liked to blame all their problems in their life on outsiders. Kind of like you’re guilty until you prove you’re innocent.

The most accepting and good friends I made were some of the older fellas in their 80’s who were from a different era and some younger folks and the Mennonites. I’ve always been of the notion I’ll judge you when I meet you and get to know you. That’s what stand up men do in my opinion. It’s good to become friends and help one’s neighbors. We’ve always been that way and have been blessed to have great neighbors everywhere we’ve moved.
 
Last edited:
Born and raised and still in Central Ohio! So were Mom & Dad! Both families were Pioneer Families in Ohio (pre 1820). When we bought our first farm, we moved 20 miles from Columbus' north side to outside Westerville. Mom's stepfamily are everywhere around us! We were treated like illegal aliens at school the first few years. By the time I graduated in 1974, I was an old-timer. My brother had married a local and that cemented us in the community.

One of the problems we had when we first encountered the locals was, they couldn't/didn't read or couldn't/didn't care about the no trespassing signs we had around the farm. When dad released a barrage into the floor of the woods at 0230 to notify some trespassers of our intentions, they did learn were not to be in a hurry. About a week later, the old farmer across the road from us was talking to dad and said that all the old time farmers were glad dad had come up with a language the local thieves could understand! Most everyone got on well after that, except for one family!

Ivan
 
["Bahston". Didn't mind taking the money he made here but never failed to tell anyone and everyone how he hated this back-wood bastion of hillbillies.[/QUOTE]

I had a co-worker that was from Chicago. All we heard from her for year after year was how great Chicago was, in every way, and how awful Texas was, in every way. Many times she was told to her face " If you are so unhappy here go back to Chicago, but stop bad mouthing Texas". Her answer was I can't my daughter and son in law are here and they won't leave.
 
"It's sooo beautiful here... it just needs a Starbucks, and a mall, and...."

When folks move to a place with a great quality of life, but immediately begin to try to change it into what they're fleeing, it's only natural that the longtime residents are going to be resentful.

We just moved from one part of rural AZ to another part of rural AZ because the former has been so overrun by transplants over the last 10-15 years it became unrecognizable. Part of that is the fault of the developers and community leaders who refused to put any kind of control on the growth, but a lot is the attitude of the folks moving in. At first, we got a lot of refugees (from CA, mostly) who wanted to assimilate, but now it's just locusts. Big city attitudes, and no respect for the cultural history of the region. It's sad, because it used to be a nice place to live.

It's inevitable really... every place with good quality of life has it for a reason. But those reasons will eventually be overwhelmed by the effluent coming out of the big cities. And in fleeing their own mess, they always bring some of it with them.
 
Part of that is the fault of the developers and community leaders who refused to put any kind of control on the growth,

BINGO! I am of the opinion that this is typical in every state that is experiencing explosive growth. This is what I refer to in an earlier post when I say if you build it they will come. While I might struggle with the politics of my state government, they do keep a lid on growth...and I like living in my sparsely populated state of 600k population. The scenery is the same decade after decade after decade.
 
The common theme through out this thread is the new people who want to turn their new place into their old place. That's where the trouble and resentment comes from.
If you wanna move here, I'm fine with it as long as you leave the old place behind. But if you ever make a comment along the lines of "that's not how we did back in ______" You just became a problem and nobody is gonna like you. :mad:
If you move to a new place tell folks how much you like it here and how its so much better than the old place. Then you can make friends and assimilate into the community.

Except yankees. We don't want nothing to do with yankees. :D
 
Back
Top