Leaving gun in holster

brundlseth

Member
Joined
Sep 28, 2015
Messages
14
Reaction score
12
Location
East Central Florida
I carry a 640 New Centennial in a 'pouch' type holster on my belt. The holster is all natural leather and has a flap which folds over from the top enclosing and effectively concealing the revolver within. When relaxing at home with other weapons at hand, I remove the holster from my belt.

Is it harmful to the revolver to leave it in the holster or should I remove it when it is not being worn?
 
Register to hide this ad
It's not a good idea because leather may retain moisture and sometimes the tanning process actually leaves corrosive products in the leather itself. However, your 640 is stainless steel with a synthetic grip if it's stock. At the worst, you may get some discoloration of the steel from contact with the leather.
 
When I come home and don't plan to go out again I remove my gun from the holster. I figure if there is any moisture in the holster I will give it a chance to dry out overnight.
 
Thanks for your help. And my 640 is stainless with synthetic grips. Your remark about the tanning process reminded me of a stainless thermos that started to corrode after I began removing coffee stains with chlorine bleach. I think I will leave my snubbie out at night and, besides, that will help me remember to wipe it down every few days.
 
+29 in a holster, and I am still waiting to see what you folks are talking about. Proceed, and please exhibit with what you profess. My 686 has lived holstered for nearly 3 decades, so please color me confused. The 686 is on the left.

SW686%20627PC%20Holsters%201.jpg

SW686%20627PC%20Holsters%20Back.jpg
 
I have always read that guns should not be stored in holsters or "gun rugs," yet, I know police officers and state troopers that only removed their weapons from their holsters at qualification or perhaps briefly during a traffic stop. Never when off duty.

And for the most part, all of the instances of which I am aware involved ordinary blue steel S&W revolvers. Yes, there was bluing wear, but I never observed one with rust.

So, does the rust know to only happen off duty if the weapon is left holstered when the officer is not on duty? Or, is the weapon being eaten away by a form of the bacterium "Halomonas titanicae," like the Titanic hull, while the officer rides around on patrol? Will the officer one day pull a "rusticle" from his holster instead of a revolver?

Is it bad to keep the weapon holstered on duty? It is mostly academic these days, as most duty weapons have a gee-whiz finish or are stainless steel. That said, I have never read of an officer pulling a rusticle from a holster instead of a blued revolver.

So, while caution may dictate not leaving it holstered constantly, I have yet to see evidence that, given proper lubrication, the weapon suffers much harm. I am sure there are exceptional cases in seaports or very hot, humid, or salty environments, but I suspect those are rare.
 
The ammunition will turn green and crusty long before the pistol does. Keep the ammo fresh, and I doubt there's much to worry about. I haven't seen it . . .

BINGO!

Years back, while not actively engaged and "storing" my holstered 686, I did find that I had to clean the lead tipped bullets of their lead fuzz.

NOW, I make a point of shooting it much more often and THAT seems to keep the green fuzzies in check...:D:D:D

Oh yeah, here is some old .222 ammo from ~1959 I have from my Dad's reloading days, if you want to see some fuzz...
Old-Reloads-circa-1959.jpg
 
Last edited:
Part of it depends on your gun, where you live and what you do. Type and material of holster. If you live in a relatively dry area, carry a stainless gun or a blued one that you wipe down with a light oil or wax and keep you holster treated with a good leather treatment your not going to have problems.

If you live in a damp climate or don't dry and oil your gun AND holster when it gets wet you will have problems, maybe even with stainless guns. Some leathers are worse than others.

Another thing is grips. I got a good deal on a really nice model 14 a while ago. Hardly fired, great blue with little wear,but, itt was sporting Goodyears and under them was some minor rust spots starting to form.

Even if you live in a dry area and keep your holster treated, you should be practicing, giving the gun a cleaning, inspection and wipe down.
 
If for no other reason, I remove my EDC from the holster when returning home so I can access it easier and faster form it's hiding place if I ever need it. The last thing I need is to worry and possibly fumble removing a gun from it's holster in a hurry. Weather it will rust faster, mold ammo faster or what ever, I still thing it's a faster access if not in one when it's needed in an emergency in the home.

I also like to let a gun dry out after being carried in a holster all day long. I have seen (many times) where a gun will look fine on the outside yet have rust inside. I have even experienced this (light rust) inside my EDC gun and I am a fanatic regarding gun care and maintenance. That's one good reason to completely disassemble, clean and lube every year or so - even if it gets shot infrequently. Carrying in all kinds of weather and humidity can do funny things to even a stainless steel gun!
 
Back
Top