Cowboy/ribeye steak

Joined
Apr 20, 2006
Messages
925
Reaction score
2,038
Location
Southern Maine
Picked up a nice thick bone in ribeye. Have heard of cooking it by first searing both sides in a hot cast-iron pan then throwing the pan and steak in the oven to complete the cooking.
Poking around the Internet I came across info referring to this process as cowboy steak and a trimmed version as a tomahawk steak.
I welcome any tips or suggestions.

Merry Christmas to all, Kevin
 
Register to hide this ad
I cook mine the same , spice it up with a pepper and little Dale Sauce , butter and sit to room temperature before cooking. No outside grills allowed on the apartment patios.
 
I cook my steaks either in my Sous Vide or do it the reverse sear method. Both methods you bring the steak to your desired temperature (i like mine on the rare side of medium rare about 117-120 degrees). Then I sear them in my old cast iron fry pan using high temperature and lots of butter.

These methods will give you the perfect doneness from side to side with a good crust and no gray area between the crust and your preferred doneness.

171298839.bthG429l.xmasdinner2020a.jpg
 
Google the 3-3-2-2 method. Hot skillet, not screaming hot so it burns the meat, but you want a good sizzle. Check temperature by flinging some tiny water droplets off your fingertips. They should dance and sizzle like you want your steak to do. When the skillet is up to temp, put a little oil in it and wait for it to shimmer. Then 3 minutes on one side, flip it, 3 minutes on the other, then flip it and 2 minutes on the first side, then flip and 2 more minutes. Hence 3-3-2-2. Let it rest for about as long as you cooked it. Then chow down! Make sure the steak is up to room temperature before cooking. I use a cast iron pan.

This method works great if you have a fairly thick steak. If it's thinner, then try 2-2-1-1. If it's not done to your likeing then flip and cook for a minute and flip back for a minute until you're happy.

Best way to check for doneness is to just push on the steak with the turner. Don't cut it! If it just starts to firm up, it's rare, slightly firm it's medium rare. If it gets firm or hard, you're medium or well which IMNHO is too far gone.

One more thing. I just salt both sides right before cooking. Salt too early as some folks suggest and you get juices on the surface. If it's not dry, it doesn't brown very good. Some folks say salt AND pepper. Pan frying burns the pepper in my experience. I grind the pepper on the steak after cooking when it's resting.

OK. Now I'm hungry.
 
Last edited:
Cook That Steak

Picked up a nice thick bone in ribeye. Have heard of cooking it by first searing both sides in a hot cast-iron pan then throwing the pan and steak in the oven to complete the cooking.
Poking around the Internet I came across info referring to this process as cowboy steak and a trimmed version as a tomahawk steak.
I welcome any tips or suggestions.

Merry Christmas to all, Kevin

Season that steak and let it set at room temp for 2 hours.
Get that skillet as hot as you can. Give that steak to the skillet for about 1 1/2 minitues per side. Have the oven pre heated to 400f.
Finish it in the oven the way you like it.
BTW, massage the steak with a little olive or avocado oil when you season it.
Yummmmmm,…
Best,
Gary
 
Cover both sides with coarse kosher salt and let it get to room temperature. Sear both sides and grill it to your liking. Enjoy
 
Reverse sear for me. Oven 250, bring steak to 120 degrees - I use a digital thermometer with a probe and an alarm. Sear over hot grill or hot burner about 1 1/2 or 2 minutes a side. 135 degree internal suits me. :)
 
Back
Top