Anyone ever had any?
If so, how was it and where did you get it from?

__________________
Only difference Fool/Mule-ears

1: Yes.

2: Meh.

3: An alligator.

__________________
Music/Sports/Beer fan

1 yes

2 tasted like boiled chicken (it was canned).

3 I picked it up at a convenience store in Texas.

1 yes
2 nothing special, bland.. boiled pork?
3 street food in New Orleans, so it may or may not have been real gator...

I had some deep fried gator at one of my clubs annual wild game dinners. Most of the meat was donated by members back then, so there was no telling if it was processed properly or how long it was stored in a freezer.

It looked great, but had a fishy taste and was chewy. I can see why the member gave it away. I'm sure it's like other game and is best fresh.

__________________
"I also cook."

Yep.

It’s a novelty meat only. Not great, not terrible.

Yes I have had it. At a New Orleans restaurant. It was fried somehow and in small bite size pieces. I recall it was somewhat fishy and chewy. Not bad but nothing special. I tried it for the novelty but feel no need to have anymore.

When I was in New Orleans in 1979 I had Alligator, Frogs Legs, Crawfish and Snake. In New Orleans they really know how to make sauces and so pretty much any food can be made to taste good. I believe the restaurant was Brennan's or O'Brians, or both as I was there for a week and ate all over.

In Florida…deep fried…kinda chewy.

Not impressed.

Here in Florida its on just about every menu. Ok but nothing great other than you can say, “ I ate some gator”. BTW, there are So Many gators now they need to be removed from the protected species list. Need more gator belts, wallets and handbags…..and maybe shoes.

Yes. many times.
If it's fishy or nasty, they didn't know how to prepare it.
Taste like a cross between chicken and turtle to me if done correct.
You only eat the tail, sans fat.

__________________
Dave Ramsey Cultist

Living near the Swamp, I try to avoid being
an Alligator's meat.
Trap with slugs practice is prudent.
Just kidding.
A good sauce makes the tail taste okay,
when served by our Swamp buddies.
First time we met them at a Christmas party long ago,
I was the only one without a Rattler or Mocc head on the
front of my Stetson.
Ruger Sec6 Snub is our Swamp gun since '80.

Gator, Gator,
I know what's on your mind.
On your dinner menu,
My name you will not find.

Attached Images

IMG_1243.jpg (73.3 KB, 65 views)

__________________
Have Fun/Stay Safe

Had some at a gator show — guy with a Michael Jackson glove feeding jumping gators chickens (dead and defeathered*) from a platform — in Kissame, Florida, in the early 80s. Meh.

Kinda bland.

(* In retrospect, live & squawking chickens would have made for a more entertaining show... Maybe a good looking gal in a bikini rather than a Michael Jackson wanna be. And a better, more piquant sauce. Hey, I missed my calling as a gator show impresario!)

Had gator nuggets on the Seminole Reservation for breakfast. Not bad, but the reservation made cocktail sauce made it better.

1 lb. tail chunks heavily seasoned like chicken or pork then smoked was not bad at all.

Have had it down in Dear Old Louisiana.
Pretty much like several folks have already described it.
Made me want to sing some local songs.
Or was that the Beer?
Thibodaux, Louisiana - YouTube

__________________
NRA LIFE MEMBER

Tastes like greasy seasoned chicken. Good. No bad after effects. Cajun restaurant.

I had it in a stew, in a restaurant, but it was so heavily Cajun spiced I couldn't eat it. One bite, all I got was a tongue burn. Sent it back.

__________________
H Richard
SWCA1967 SWHF244

Just once, got it from a good fish market, they have all kinds of meats. Made Gator & chips. Taste, as noted above, but a bit of a muddy after taste.

__________________
No baby we aint

Never had gator. I have had dog, monkey, rattlesnake and whale.
I was so drunk for the dog and monkey I don't remember what they tasted like. The rattlesnake was quite good and the whale tasted like a fatty beef roast that had a mackrel strapped to it while cooking.
(Never was drunk enough to try a baloot....)

__________________
Dean
SWCA #680 SWHF #446

Once, at Ralph & Kacoo's seafood restaurant in Baton Rouge around 40 years ago. Sort of in fried chunks, like chicken McNuggets. I don't remember whether it was good or bad, but at least I ate it all so it couldn't have been too bad. I wouldn't repeat the experience today.

I’ve had it many times. Gator bites are served as an appetizer at a lot of the restaurants in my area. We have a locally famous restaurant called “Gatorz”, with chicken wings being their specialty. Whenever we order out from them, the wife and I always get an order of their gator bites to split. Not bad, I guess “greasy spiced chicken” would be an apt description of the taste.

__________________
USS Brewton FF1086
SWCA#3597

Alligator sausage.
Was very dry and coarse. Tasted like wild pork.
Bought from a local meat market that specializes in game.

It wasn't that spectacular. Now, the bison burgers...that was memorable in a good way!

__________________
The Last Standing Knight

I've eaten just about every kind of wild and domestic animal and while down in New Orleans had to try alligator. Now I will give praise to New Orleans for their cooking skills and one of the things they know how to do better than anyone is make a sauce...for EVERYTHING. The gator I ate was from a well known local favorite restaurant. It was nuggets that were pan sautéed and had at least six sauces to choose from. On its own it is as good as any of the other reptiles I have eaten, being a large animal the chunks can be larger and tater tot sized nuggets were what I got, it was supposed to be tail meat. It is unique in flavor and texture, much the same way as shark and sturgeon are different from flaky fish, its dense and in larger chunks probably a bit grainy. I liked it enough to want to serve it up for my family and found it could be ordered from "The Cajun Grocer", its a little on the spendy side but for something the kids will go wild over its worth it. Everyone should get a chance at eating Gator. I grilled it over charcoal along with a mess of chicken lightly seasoned and it went fast, everyone like it and there is always the fact that it is different.

Be a good idea to stay away from mudbugs then.

__________________
Dave Ramsey Cultist

I will agree that Gators should be removed from the protect status, but NOT hunted indiscriminately either. They serve a valuable purpose in the ecological food chain.

Funny how all the northern "transits" freak out over the sight of an alligator. Take all your kids and pets inside, alligator on the loose!

The Bulldogs took care of the Gator problem.

__________________
Music/Sports/Beer fan

Interesting you should ask this. Last nigt after 4::00 mass me and the wife drove over to St. Johns resturant in St. Martinville and has crab bouillettes and egg plant fries and gor te main course I had the Swamp Platter which was frog legs, alligator bites and catfish fillets all in their deep fried glory. Aligator tastes...well like alligator. Nice firm white meat delicate taste. The frogs legs were absolutely divine! Perfectly fried, you could suck them off the bone. Washed down with a couple od Abita Ambers went home and watched Coach prime get his "Prime" handed to him, and watched the D'backs put a 9th inning pasting on da Rangers.
All in all not a bad night.....
Back to the question at hand. Problem with alligator is sometimes you get the tough cuts which is all chewy. This in the most common complaint I hear. The alligator I had lst night was Not chewy but really quite good. They definately did not use the cheap cuts.

__________________
Forum consigliere

Figured the Caj would know.
I’ve had a bunch of things in Louisiana Restaurants including Gator but never Frog Legs.
The only time I can remember having Frog Legs in a Restaurant was in Mexico!

__________________
NRA LIFE MEMBER

I've eaten a lot of gator over the years. If fresh, seasoned, dusted in flour and deep fat fried, it's very tasty. Many of the guys I know run it through a cuber to cut down on the chewiness.

I used to be part of the crew that cooked the gatortail for the local Education Foundation's "Wild Beast Feast" fundraiser. We would fry over 300 lbs of de-boned, ready to cook gator meat , along with 900 quail, 30-40 deer, 300 swamp cabbage and sundry other species that various people had donated.

This was an "all you can eat" affair and we found that if we did not not spread the serving of the gator out over a couple of hours, it would all be gone in the first 30 minutes, and late arrivals would not get any!

"A cross between chicken and turtle" is a very good description of what good gator should taste like.

Gator McNuggets. It was fine and would do it again. Kind of a novelty. FWIW, mountain lion McNuggets are great, especially if have a snoot full of Canadian Mist onboard.

__________________
213th FBINA

Alligator meet takes like whatever season it with..........By itself it would taste like a cold baked potato.

__________________
S&W Accumulator

It was real gator tail meat, mixed with pork.

__________________
Find a way or make one.

We eat a good bit of gator down here (Southeast Louisiana) regularly. But you really only want to eat the tail meat. That's the best part of the gator and easiest to cook and season to your liking. I personally love fried gator, gator sausage, and tossing some gator into a big pot of gumbo.

__________________
Find a way or make one.

Gumbo Slice!

Certain parts of SW Florida are over run with them. They sun themselves on my dock in Naples. The water is brackish so they thrive. Yes they should be removed from endangered list.

Phil's Marina Cafe in Slidell, La, last exit going South on I 10 before you cross Lake Ponchartrain, has the best gator bites I've tried, including some of my own. They fry them and then soak them in what looks like some kind of Thai sauce. They are sold as an entree for $11.00. I usually get two of them and a large bowl of gumbo and a salad and don't order a main dish. Rouse's supermarkets are found in many parts of Louisiana, Mississippi, and Alabama. You can get a pound of gator tail for around 10-12 bucks and come up with your own concoction. I often fry them with local fish that we caught. Another good dish is an alligator kubiyan (sp?) which is done with a good sauce piquant. A layer of sauce, a layer of alligator tail. Continue until you fill up a large pot, depending on how many people you are feeding, and cook on low heat, usually for hours, while sipping your favorite libation. When done the meat should be almost falling apart. Serve over popcorn rice with veggies ( I like fresh sweet corn on the cob and spicy purple hull peas).

Had it many times. A little dive bar and grill near Beloit, Kansas served them in bite sized, deep fried chunks. We'd always get a couple of orders during the annual pheasant hunt. A buddy I hog and turkey hunt with is a retired firefighter from Shreveport. He always brings along a mess, along with other foods native to his locale.

Big issue with gators is that the market for wild hides is pretty much gone. The buyers want the farm raised hides as they are more uniform. Not as much incentive to hunt the wild ones any more. The big business now is harvesting the eggs and then transporting them to the farms for hatching and raising. Law says they have to return 30% of the hatchlings to the wild. The problem with that is that although the farmers are supposed to scatter the hatchlings over the marsh, a lot just dump them in one spot and let them figure it out on their own. And yea..we are overrun with the critters. But they were here first.

Here's a receipe for the adventurous to try
Attention Required! | Cloudflare
Pay no attention-just click on the damn link!

__________________
Forum consigliere

The area we hunt (The Suwannee River delta) is like a mini Okefenokee Swamp, full of small lakes and marshy wooded sloughs. Mix in a few thousand deer and dogs during hunting season and it's easy pickings for the gators.

Throughout the course of hunting season, I usually find several deer and dogs floating around while the gators are waiting for them to get tender enough to eat.

Fun Fact:
Louisiana has a larger population of gators than Florida does. But the Florida Everglades are (is?) the only place in the world where alligators and crocodiles coexist.

__________________
Find a way or make one.

Undocumented alien snakes are a real problem in South Florida.
First time I ran into a 15' one, was in '79.
Advised my Northern buddies to never just reach for a golfball in the ruff, and be watchful near ponds, more so where Rattlers live.
When Heron Bay got started, folks wondered what happened to their cats/dogs and Moccs were around.
The Sunrise Police range had nice sized Rattler skins in the trailer/club house, back in the late '70s.

Pic of friends back yard near Clermont. A little red plane lands there. Too old and poor to start flying again so we drive up.

Attached Images

	IMG_1385.jpeg (72.4 KB, 19 views)
	IMG_0521.jpg (58.6 KB, 19 views)

__________________
Have Fun/Stay Safe

Have never had alligator meat, and from the sound of the comments, won’t be trying it

Back in the 90's several restaurants in south florida severed "gator tail", we had that several times as an appetizer and it was good. I'm not sure I'd buy it as a meal, or go out of my way to get large quantities and freeze it, but as an occasional appetizer it was good.

Inquiring minds want to know...

If you grew up eating alligator and someone fed you your first chicken would you say it tastes like alligator?

__________________
Music/Sports/Beer fan

Yes

Just ok. Kinda like chicken but not as good. Rattlesnake is better.

I'd rather not say.

That’s what I was thinking gator bites,,, that’s so 90’s! There’s a new reptile on the menu

“We Cook Your Catch”

Attached Images

IMG_1786.jpeg (91.0 KB, 15 views)

Had some almost 60 years ago. My Uncle and his friends would get them from the swamps here (yes, it was illegal). He battered it and deep fried it. As I remember it did not taste much different than sea turtles (yes, those were illegal too). My Father and his friend would get them and they were battered and deep fried too.

__________________
USMC 69-93 Combat Pistol Inst.