5 Shot K-Frame in 400 S&W Magnum.

Tony Rumore

Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2016
Messages
33
Reaction score
258
There's a big gap between the five shot J-Frame .357 and the five shot L-Frame 44 mag.

Where's the 5 shot K-frame? I think it's time to bring back the Herter's .401 PowerMag.

Tony Rumore
Tromix
 
Register to hide this ad
I imagine the 41 is too big for the K-frame cylinder or they would have already done it. With the 10mm getting new legs in the industry lately, it would be a great time to trot out a 10mm Magnum...with a rim on it.

Of course they wouldn't be able to give Herters any credit for doing it 56 years ago, so they will need to re-name it, and act like the .401 never existed. You know....like the 451 Detonics Mag/460 Rowland.

Tony
 
Smith is done with innovative new revolver designs. The closest thing I can think of is a 10mm GP100.

I wouldn't be so quick to count them out, it has only been just over a decade since they came out with the Model 327, less if you count upgraded models like the TRR8.

Besides, has anyone really been innovating much lately when it comes to Revolvers? I mean, there's really only so much ground left to break in that department, and finding new ways to fit as many rounds into a cylinder as possible isn't exactly the most profitable of ventures, so who's to say they haven't already thought of it but simply chose not to.
 
I wouldn't be so quick to count them out, it has only been just over a decade since they came out with the Model 327, less if you count upgraded models like the TRR8.

Besides, has anyone really been innovating much lately when it comes to Revolvers? I mean, there's really only so much ground left to break in that department, and finding new ways to fit as many rounds into a cylinder as possible isn't exactly the most profitable of ventures, so who's to say they haven't already thought of it but simply chose not to.

You may be right, but my perception is that S&W view the semi-auto plastic guns as far more profitable and are keeping just enough revolvers around to maintain their legacy. The few attempts at innovation are geared toward the competition market like the TRR8 and the JM 929, the latter of which I guarantee they wouldn't have made without Miculek selling them on it.

Stuff they should be making that would sell well:
- Every revolver they sell should have a non-ported 3" barrel option
- J/K/N frames in 327 Mag
- Taurus offers a line with an L frame cylinder in a K frame and a J frame grip, and they have offered them with steel, aluminum, and titanium frames. With one of the lighter metals, it's a pocketable 5 shot 44 SPL or 7 shot 357 Mag.
- Reintroduce the I frame chambered in 32 H&R Mag and 22 LR and maybe even a 5-shot 9mm or 380 ACP for the ultimate pocket pistol/BUG.
- Offer a J frame with a DAO factory trigger comparable in weight to the LCR for folks with weak hands

Those are just off the top of my head.

Instead of catering to the expanding CCW market (many of whom are older and like revolvers) and introducing some innovative designs or using new calibers, they reintroduce the M36, M10, and M19 - guns that are likely the most common guns S&W ever made.
 
"has anyone really been innovating much lately when it comes to Revolvers?"

I believe Kimber could be considered a modern innovator with the K6S. S&W as well. My TR8 has become one of my favorite shooters. Even the Ruger LCR is innovative..so yes..there have been advances in the field.
 
I think youre onto something Tony.
A necked down 460SW to .40cal perhaps?
X frames, bolt actions, and masochists only.
 
Wouldn't ever get a K-Frame wrapped around the .38 WCF (.38-40).

I could sure do with an factory-made N-Frame .38-40 chambered Outdoorsman if Smith & Wesson would just make one to the standards of at least the "pinned and recessed" days if not pre-war.
 
Groo here
Got an M-69 2 3/4 in and a GP100 wc 3in 10mm.
The m-69 is a five shot,the Gp100 a 6 shot.[ with moon clips]
Full up 44 mags are ruff in the m-69 , full up 10mm in the gp100
not as bad.
What ever you like , but I went with the 10mm for CCW.
 
"has anyone really been innovating much lately when it comes to Revolvers?"

I believe Kimber could be considered a modern innovator with the K6S. S&W as well. My TR8 has become one of my favorite shooters. Even the Ruger LCR is innovative..so yes..there have been advances in the field.

Besides the innovative guns I listed above and the Kimber, there's also the Chiappa Rhino!
 
Back
Top