....Comparing an English double to a European gun is like comparing a Ferrari to a Hyundai.
You have to judge the individual gun. Have it in hand and better yet have had it apart,,all apart for service or inspection.
That's only way you can really appreciate the workmanship and quality,,or lack of it.
Every gun is judged against a high standard of the trade. Never against XYZ Gun Co Brand, or ABC Makers gun.
There's 'Best' and there're guns that don't met the standard. They can come from any maker.
There are several small makers around Europe that specialize in DR's and S/S shotguns. They build only to order and yes you can get a hidden fastener action if you wish.
Some build only a half dozen + complete guns in a calendar year.
There are lots of 'English' SxS shotguns and DR's around that are less than the sparkling quality, fit and finish of a H&H of the best of their days.
Most will show they have come from the Birmingham Gun Trade . They are still good firearms when in good repair.
But just being an 'English' double does not automaticly elevate them above anyone else in line.
You can pay a lot more for it because of the Brit connection if you want to.
But there's no assurance that the gun is any better than the German or ? mfg one sitting next to it.
I still have a few DR's.
_ John Rigby Hammer, Jones Underlever action in 500x3"
Damascus bbls, made in 1867 according to Rigby;s info. Certainly a fine quality rifle, has seen some use and some hard use but has held up well.
Still shoots well dispite bores getting worn. Orig leather/oak case some accessories.
The seller also had a same rifle in 577. I went back to buy that one after getting together the cash and of course it was gone. ($2500 !)
-Chas Osborne Hammerless 470N/E
Hard use, needs a restoration which I will attend to at some time. Simple BoxLock w/some engraving, exc bores. Shoots well and plants Kynoch 500gr solids and SP on target at 50m.
German hammerless. Forget the name on the bbl's right now. 9.3x74R
My favorite to shoot and reload for. Bbl's proofed in 9/29
Has it's orig German scope in claw mounts still with it. Very accurate with full loads at 50M. Simple 2 leaf rear sight used on 2nd leaf, will place light loads on bull at 50m also (95gr 9mmMak bullets over RedDot powder.)
Full side lock. I refinished the wood and recheckered. New horn buttplate I made for it from an FN A5 horn BP as the orig H/R w/ soft rubber center was in bad shape. Reblued the bbls. Bores excl.
Last one in was a German mfg also. 9.3x72R w/ claw mounts and scope(Leopold Alaskan 2.5). Simple BoxLock extractor. IIRC proofed in the 30's
Very badly soft wheel buffed and then hot blued over near full engraving on the frame. Engraving mid quality anyway, so that will disappear during polishing.
Exc bores, Came w/die sets, Norma brass (new) and bullets.
That's getting a do=over now, at least I've started . I've annealed the frame and parts, started striking the bbls, ect. Other things get in the way.
A mid range quality rifle when made but it'll be a nice rifle when finished and make a decent deer gun. 9.3x72R is about like a 38-55
I'll likely clear the claw mounts from the rifle. Put them on something else.
-I sold a Johann Springer (Vienna) DR. in 9mm x? cal. very small, light weight hammer rifle. Ex'clt high quality by a well known maker. Made before WW1 IIRC. Highly engraved, high qual wood, checkering.
Beautifully made,,inside and out. House sale item.
Got talked out of it for ?
They are out there, You just have to look a little harder. They don't generally show up on the used gun rack at the Local GS, but you never know!
Do some homework and examine lots of pieces before buying. Educate yourself.
Many of the guns on the market have had some ;work' done to them at some point. Some of it was done to fluff up the gun for sale. Simply doll-up
work. Be able to spot that for what it is. It may be hiding a flaw, it may simply be shine-ola to attract a buyer.
True repair is fine if done correctly just like on any other firearm.
These things do wear out and do break once in a while no matter who made them.
Don't accept workmanship that's slipshod. Finding someone to fix someone else's bad repair can be a very expensive trip down Money Pit Lane.