A burgeoning interest in pre-war N-frames (HD,OD & M1926)

RM Vivas

US Veteran
Joined
Nov 11, 2002
Messages
608
Reaction score
4,233
Location
ROCK/me/HARD-PLACE
A burgeoning interest in pre-war N-frames (HD,OD & M1926)

I’ve been nurturing a nascent interest in pre-war N-frames. Aside from enjoying the aesthetic of the shrouded ejector rod, I feel that the HD/OD market is under-valued (relatively speaking to say the RM/NRM market) and will be the next Big Thing.

Initially it was confined to Heavy Duty models, but then I started looking at Outdoorsmans’ and then it metastasized into Model 1926s’ as well.

I see HD, OD and M1926’s in my future (similarly, I also see more overtime and less disposable income; go figure). The question I have now, in a similar vein to the discussion about specialization at this years Symposium, is -how- should I collect these models.

A technical purist would shoot for one of every variation, experimentals, custom ordered, etc. There is merit in this approach and it has a delightfully academic and clinical aspect that appeals to me. It does, however, lack a certain element of soul.

The other option, and one I am leaning towards, is guns that may not be mechanically or developmentally unique, but that tell a story. I’m looking at a trio of 5 inch factory nickel guns up for sale and they are all mechanically unremarkable, serial numbers are spread across production and are, for the most part, just plain Jane nickel 5-inch HD’s. However, 2 letter to little gun shops and one letters to the Alabama Highway Patrol.

I’m thinking that as much as a collection of evolutionary guns appeals to my OCD/compulsive side, I’m thinking a collection that focuses on law enforcement, military used, known competitive shooters, etc. sort of guns might be the way to go. It’s a rather broad category and I suppose I could break it down further and do -just- law enforcement guns, or -just- competitive shooter guns or the like. I like the ideas though of a collection that has a little bit of everything that will appeal a little bit to everybody. Obviously, the only person it has to appeal to is me, but I like the idea of being able to share it with a wide range of people.

I could also very easily see, as time goes by and the collection grows, either I develop a taste for one specific them and go that way (LE guns, competition guns, etc.) or I stay with the broad theme but fold in some of the technical purist stuff.

Thoughts?

Best,
RM Vivas
 
Register to hide this ad
I went down that same rabit hole: 1st & 3rd model 44s, and finally the pre war magnums. I have a couple of LEO agency pre war heavy duties stashed but somehow missed out on the OD itch.
 
I'm noticing quite a number of ODs as having gone out on police contracts, which of curse leads us to the RM.

Best,
RM Vivas
 
My N frame obsession started with a used 29-6 Classic purchased in 1998. In 2008, however, my interest turned to Pre-War, Transitional, and Pre-Model N frames -- HD, OD, and .44 HE (1st, 2nd, 1926, and 1950 Model, both Military and Target). Most of my accumulation are well-worn shooters, mechanically sound but not all are especially pretty. I have managed to find a few collector-quality examples in original or correct boxes, along with three Hamilton Bowen resto-mod/caliber conversions. My Pre-War N frame collection stands at 14 examples at the moment, two are 5" HD's with humpback hammer, two are OD's converted to .44 Special by Hamilton Bowen, and OD 53195 is a nice example, unaltered, in a period-correct box. I think the OD is one of the most elegant large-frame revolvers (along with the New Model 3 and .357 Magnum) manufactured by Smith & Wesson - be it Pre-War, Transitional, or Pre-Model. I'm on the hunt for Pre-War and Transitional .357's but, wow, they are spendy!
 

Attachments

  • 38-44 OD_ 53195_Aug 1937.jpg
    38-44 OD_ 53195_Aug 1937.jpg
    58.2 KB · Views: 0
  • Gila's Bowen 44OD_a.jpg
    Gila's Bowen 44OD_a.jpg
    248.8 KB · Views: 0
  • Prewar .38-44 OD .44 conversion.jpg
    Prewar .38-44 OD .44 conversion.jpg
    78.3 KB · Views: 0
  • 57933 Prewar 38-44 HD 5” Humpback.jpg
    57933 Prewar 38-44 HD 5” Humpback.jpg
    60.8 KB · Views: 0
  • S66936_1946 Transition .44 Military Model of 1926.jpg
    S66936_1946 Transition .44 Military Model of 1926.jpg
    137.9 KB · Views: 0
My interest in pre-war N frames started around 2000. Since, I've managed to gather up 11, all of but a couple of them target sighted models. A couple of 1st model targets, a couple of 2nd model targets, a couple of RM's, a couple of1917's, one commercial target (yep, it letters), a OD, a HD and a 5 inch standard 2nd model. I'm looking for a 3rd model, but haven't found one that's reasonable, at least within my budget.
I think pre-war N frames are a pinnacle achievement of Smith & Wesson.
In regards to collecting, I always keep my eyes open and really don't have a niche I'm looking for in particular beyond being a pre-war N frame. A couple of mine are law enforcement guns, which is cool. But I bought them for the gun, not the law enforcement connection. I do prefer target guns and will pay the premium for such.
Anyway, the reason I share all this is to say that where I live, you kinda take what you get because the choices are limited. If I find something, I usually buy it, if I can afford it. Not having a niche need to satisfy gives me a lot of flexibility in what I bring home. That said, some of the best guns were ones I wasn't looking for.
Whatever you decide to do, just make yourself happy and maybe not try to meet others expectations.
 
Back
Top