G F Herold Company Short-Barrel Target Revolvers

Joined
Dec 24, 2005
Messages
5,466
Reaction score
7,362
City & State/Province
Portland Or
( This posting is a bit more about New York City firearms dealers in the 1920's and 1930's, than about the two short-barrel targets in my collection. The gun shop, in this story, was owned and run by a retired NYD PD officer, who primarily handled M&P's for LEO's, and particularly for the NYC PD. The two top-of-the-line revolvers in the story were seldom sold to Police Officers, and so unusual for the store. )

George F Herold was a NYC PD Officer who, on retirement, took over a gun shop across the street (Center Market Place) from the NYC PD early headquarters. The street had several gun shops on it, and his became known as G F Herold Company, The company was a large distributor of guns to Law Enforcement entities, and dealt mostly with the M&P configuration. He also dealt with target revolvers, and this story is about two short-barrel revolvers that went to his store, one in 1934 and one in 1937.

The first two pictures are these two guns; one is a 4" S&W, and the other a 4 1/2" Colt Officers Model .

mikepriwer-albums-mlp21-picture29932-g-f-herold-co-left-sides.jpg


mikepriwer-albums-mlp21-picture29933-g-f-herold-co-right-sides.jpg


The next two pictures are the factory letters for the guns.

mikepriwer-albums-mlp21-picture29934-colt-585141-factory-letter-george-herold.jpg


mikepriwer-albums-mlp21-picture29935-s-w-663727-factory-letter-geoge-herold.jpg


The next picture is of George dealing with customers inside the store. Presumably these men were NYC PD officers from across the street.

mikepriwer-albums-mlp21-picture29931-george-herold-store.jpg


The last 4 images are two stories, of two pages each, about the neighborhood back in the 1930's.

mikepriwer-albums-mlp21-picture29927-centre-market-place-new-york-city-1920s-page-1-a.jpg


mikepriwer-albums-mlp21-picture29928-centre-market-place-new-york-city-1920s-page-2-a.jpg


mikepriwer-albums-mlp21-picture29929-7-centre-market-place-new-york-city-1920s-page-1-a.jpg





mikepriwer-albums-mlp21-picture29930-7-centre-market-place-new-york-city-1920s-page-2-a.jpg



Note: Jovinos was a 5 Centre Place, Frank Lava gunsmith was a 6 Centre Place, Herold was at 7 Center Place, and the NYC PD was at 240 Centre Place.

Regards, Mike Priwer
 
Last edited:
I also have a 4.5" barrel Officers Model that went to Herold. Mine is in a single gun shipment in 1934, I believe. And it's really interesting to see other short barrel target guns ship there. My Officer's Model has a rounded front sight, and I've seen this on other 4 and 4.5" barrel guns of that model from the time period.
 
Richard

I don't know who the special guns were for. It certainly is plausible that they were for members of the shooting team. The Sullivan law exempted some non-LEO's, so it possible that a judge wanted one for protection.

Regards, Mike Priwer
 
While the two revolvers are quite nice, I particularly enjoy the aspects of the post discussing the gun stores.

It is a reminder that when time moves forward, history can erase things if people don’t make the effort to record.
All the archival information is invaluable because, as we can see in this case, every effort has been made to erase the notion that our major metropolis areas were once 1) much safer, more civilized, and culturally active, while at the same time, 2) allowed for ownership of firearms, which could be purchased from respectable establishments in local communities.

I am old enough to remember visiting gun stores in major American and Canadian cities, many of which have not only effectively prohibited (either outright or through bureaucratic means) firearms ownership, but also have “memory-holed” the notion that any such practice ever existed.

It never occurred to me at the time, “I should take pictures of this place because soon nobody will believe that this was a nice, clean, safe place, and, that there was ever a gun store here.”
 
Last edited:
I found this interesting photo taken around 1940. It was found on a Facebook page for historical photos.FB_IMG_1782145171405.webp
 

Attachments

  • FB_IMG_1782149910046.webp
    FB_IMG_1782149910046.webp
    224 KB
  • img_weegee_bio.webp
    img_weegee_bio.webp
    21 KB
  • screen-capture-27.webp
    screen-capture-27.webp
    64.4 KB
  • screen-capture-28.webp
    screen-capture-28.webp
    38.8 KB
  • screen-capture-24.webp
    screen-capture-24.webp
    53 KB
  • screen-capture-25.webp
    screen-capture-25.webp
    91.5 KB
Last edited:
Back
Top