Grips are really a subjective thing. Some folks like a particular model .. just because it looks pretty and they can show it off to their buddies. Thats fine, and i commend them for their abilities & perfection of their collections. . I went through several grips including Hogue Rubbers - which i wasn't overly fond of, to one of their plain wood grips. The Hogue wood grip slid around in my hand & just didn't feel right. I have a large hand & needed a grip that was "bulky" to my feel. Some grips are really "thin". I got my first pair of S&W Combat finger grips from "Twomoons" here on the forum. Put them on my 686 & they were like night & day. They fit perfect to my hands. I've since gotten the same grips for my other guns. The S&W J-Frame Combat would not let me use a speedloader. So, had to modify that grip, but i kept it. For the ones of us that shoot a lot & carry the weapon for self defense and life saving purposes "the feel-is-the-deal". Grips can be expensive, & if you don't like a particular one, you may not be able to resell it for a while. Check what feels best to you, not what just looks pretty. Best of luck.
Carl