Really Cool WheelGun....586 L-Comp. Anyone Own One?

N

Nalapombu

Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2001
Messages
313
Reaction score
116
Location
Delaware, Ohio
Hey all,

I just remembered a S&W that I ran across that I thought was one of the coolest revolvers I have ever seen or handled.

I had stopped at an out of the way, tiny, po-dunk shop that I thought wouldn't have a box of ammo let alone any decent firearms in stock. I started chatting with the owner and looking over his stuff and something caught my eye. It was one of those PC Briefcases. I had to check it out.

The guy got it out of the case and it was one of the 586 L-Comp revolvers from the Performance Center. Boy was it nice. I would've loved to take that baby home with me, but it was pretty pricey at the time and this was 6 or 8 years ago. I handled it for a while and left. The impression that PC revolver left on me stayed with me for a while. I just remembered it when reading through the thread about the 3 inch Model 66's. I think he also had one of those 3 inchers with the fiber optic sights on it. It was really nice too, but at the time if given the choice I would've taken the 586 L-Comp in a double heartbeat.

Anyone have one of those babies?

Nalajr
 
Register to hide this ad
I've got a second generation 586 L-Comp (w/IL), bought it from a forum member a couple of years ago. I like it a lot, very nice gun, very accurate, terrific action. The port doesn't bother me because it actually works, the recoil pushes back rather than up, makes the gun must faster to shoot. I had the front edge of the cylinder broken just a bit to make it easier to holster and the charge holes chamfered a little more aggressively for faster loading. Also had the hammer and trigger bright polished and the gun parkerized since it had to be refinished anyway. I carry it regularly for field and woods work and occasionally on duty.

SDC11529.JPG
 
I have one from the original issue, that supposedly saw some rough duty as an undercover detective's backup gun. Whoever it was, he sweated a lot, as there is pitting all over the grip frame.

I have thought about selling or trading it several times, but could never "pull the trigger". It's just a really neat, nicely balanced piece.

I'm ambivalent about the porting. I can't convince myself it really helps and the gun would look better with the sight on the end of the barrel, IMO. And I don't know what the deal was on the PC revolver night sights, they lasted about 15 minutes. I had a K-Comp as well, and both were stone dead before I bought the guns.
 
I love mine. I have had it for at least a decade now.

l-comp%20ls2.jpg


The single expansion chamber compensator that S&W some times refers to as a Power Port and others as the Carry Comp is quite effective at reducing muzzle climb. All anyone that is not convinced of this needs to do is shoot a 3" 586 or 686 next to the L-comp utilizing the same ammunition.

The revolvers are VERY accurate plus you have 7 rounds of 357 Magnum ammunition and the ability to use moon clips if you desire.



Whats not to like?

The issue with the sights is not that they go dead (take them into a dark room and look at them they are still glowing), the issue is that a vial of tritium small enough to fit into a standard width S&W front sight does not contain enough of the gas to generate a level of illumination that most folks can easily see. People that have very good night vision can barely make them out.

This is why the Night Guards are wearing the Ashley Big Dot front sight. It allows for a much larger tritium vial.

RufusG,
If your sights were truly dead get them replaced. They have a 10 year warranty.
 
colt_saa said:
I love mine. I have had it for at least a decade now.

l-comp%20ls2.jpg


The single expansion chamber compensator that S&W some times refers to as a Power Port and others as the Carry Comp is quite effective at reducing muzzle climb. All anyone that is not convinced of this needs to do is shoot a 3" 586 or 686 next to the L-comp utilizing the same ammunition.

The revolvers are VERY accurate plus you have 7 rounds of 357 Magnum ammunition and the ability to use moon clips if you desire.



Whats not to like?

The issue with the sights is not that they go dead (take them into a dark room and look at them they are still glowing), the issue is that a vial of tritium small enough to fit into a standard width S&W front sight does not contain enough of the gas to generate a level of illumination that most folks can easily see. People that have very good night vision can barely make them out.

This is why the Night Guards are wearing the Ashley Big Dot front sight. It allows for a much larger tritium vial.

RufusG,
If your sights were truly dead get them replaced. They have a 10 year warranty.
Click to expand...

Nice revolvers! A good friend has one like yours w/o the IL. It too is a very accurate piece. You are correct as that port does work like a champ, especially with magnums. Been bugging him for a couple of years to sell it to me and I have 1st shot if he does break down (doubtful). BTW his sights are dead as we did some night shoots with it. I'll tell him about the warranty as it didn't cross my mind. The muzzle flash from the port with SGD's in .357 mag was not bad as I was shooting my unported 4" 586 and they both lit up rather brightly when the rounds went off.
 
Last edited:
colt_saa said:
I love mine. I have had it for at least a decade now.

l-comp%20ls2.jpg


The single expansion chamber compensator that S&W some times refers to as a Power Port and others as the Carry Comp is quite effective at reducing muzzle climb. All anyone that is not convinced of this needs to do is shoot a 3" 586 or 686 next to the L-comp utilizing the same ammunition.

The revolvers are VERY accurate plus you have 7 rounds of 357 Magnum ammunition and the ability to use moon clips if you desire.



Whats not to like?

The issue with the sights is not that they go dead (take them into a dark room and look at them they are still glowing), the issue is that a vial of tritium small enough to fit into a standard width S&W front sight does not contain enough of the gas to generate a level of illumination that most folks can easily see. People that have very good night vision can barely make them out.

This is why the Night Guards are wearing the Ashley Big Dot front sight. It allows for a much larger tritium vial.

RufusG,
If your sights were truly dead get them replaced. They have a 10 year warranty.
Click to expand...

Thanks for the insight on the tritium sights. My PC Model 19, K Comp tritium sights have "expired" or just too dim for my old eyes to see...time to figure out what the best replacement should be...I am open for ideas.

Thanks,
Kurt
 
colt_saa said:
I love mine. I have had it for at least a decade now.

l-comp%20ls2.jpg


The single expansion chamber compensator that S&W some times refers to as a Power Port and others as the Carry Comp is quite effective at reducing muzzle climb. All anyone that is not convinced of this needs to do is shoot a 3" 586 or 686 next to the L-comp utilizing the same ammunition.

The revolvers are VERY accurate plus you have 7 rounds of 357 Magnum ammunition and the ability to use moon clips if you desire.



Whats not to like?

The issue with the sights is not that they go dead (take them into a dark room and look at them they are still glowing), the issue is that a vial of tritium small enough to fit into a standard width S&W front sight does not contain enough of the gas to generate a level of illumination that most folks can easily see. People that have very good night vision can barely make them out.

This is why the Night Guards are wearing the Ashley Big Dot front sight. It allows for a much larger tritium vial.

RufusG,
If your sights were truly dead get them replaced. They have a 10 year warranty.
Click to expand...

That is not entirely accurate. The XS front sight on the night guard series is the standard dot. The difference between the standard dot and big dot front sight is the size of the white outline around the vial. Trijicon is making the vials for the market and they are all pretty much the same size. For example, Trijicon sells vials to XS.
 
I don't have one. Have been considering buying one. I like the same type port on my 3" PC 629, it works very well in reducing muzzle rise. Thanks for all the great pics, now the fire is lit again for an L-Comp....
 
I don't own a an L-Comp, but I do have a 586-4 with a three inch barrel. It is a great gun and the only three-inch L frame I own right now. It only holds six rounds, but is very accurate - like most L frames. I have been thinking about buying one of the current 7-shot 686 three inch guns. It is my favorite barrel length.
 

Attachments

  • 0008 ps.jpg
    0008 ps.jpg
    51.1 KB · Views: 478
Mattel45 said:
I have been thinking about buying one of the current 7-shot 686 three inch guns. It is my favorite barrel length.
Click to expand...

+1

After discovering the 3" barreled .357's, I can't immagine how I'd like another length better. I've had both 4" and 2" and the 3's are just perfect IMHO. They offer the ideal compromise of shootability, handiness, and concealment.

The 586-L Comp was on my short list last week when I went to buy my first revolver in years (I had no revolvers at the time). After checking out the 586-L and the 60 Pro Series, the J-frame won out. But only by a narrow margin. I think that if I could only ever have one revolver again it would be one of those two.
 
Just Got MIne; 130320

Needed a birthday present for myself, and bought one a couple of days ago. Can't wait to take "her" out. Don't know how it is where "yall" are but ammo hard to come by here in the "Great Northwest", PDX, or Portland. Glad to see all of the positive comments.
 
hmmmmmmm

Mattel45 said:
like most L frames. I have been thinking about buying one of the current 7-shot 686 three inch guns. It is my favorite barrel length.
Click to expand...

Why settle for a M686 of current production when you could trade that standard old 3" M586-4 for this L-Comp.... :)

If you are interested, I'd be up for a trade, the 3" M586-4 is a pretty skookum piece... just sayin!

standard.jpg

standard.jpg
 
I picked up an L-Comp off an add here on the forum. Gun was used but mechanically sound and the price was about half of what I've seen them priced on GunBroker. Anyway, liked it the first time I shot it and it's become one of my favorite L-frames. The comp really does keep the muzzle down but doesn't reduce felt recoil much. That's OK with me as getting back on target is more important than what hits my palm.

Dave
 
The more pics I see of these L-Comps the more I want one. They are such a great looking pistol.

I think it would make a great carry pistol too. Aside from the reloading edge, you'd be right there with any other carry gun these days. 7 rounds of 357mag speaks pretty darn forcefully.

I bet it would make helluva packing gun for woods bumming or as a go along piece when bow hunting wild hogs.

Thanks for the pics and info guys.

Anyone have pics with it in a carry rig?

Nalajr
 
P35fan said:
Here is my 586 L Comp PC version with 7-shots and an unfluted cylinder:

SW586PC1.jpg
Click to expand...

Sorry to dig up an old forum. Where did you find one with an unfluted barrel? I haven't seen that before. I am in the market for one and an unfluted barrel IMHO makes this gun even better. These things must be pretty nice based on the price they are demanding on gunbroker- $1039. That is stout.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

O
Pre lock 586-5 L Comp box question
Replies
4
Views
328
osubucks4702
O
A
6 Shot Model 586-7 L Comp?
Replies
3
Views
417
colt_saa
colt_saa
R
686 Cylinder; Fluted or Unfluted
2
Replies
36
Views
1K
GypsmJim
GypsmJim
T
1st Time S&W Buyer 686 Plus or 586 L Comp
2
Replies
21
Views
2K
71vette
7
S
L- Frame 41 Magnum?
2
Replies
20
Views
1K
ko41
ko41

Latest posts

Back
Top