686 Cylinder; Fluted or Unfluted

To me the Classic Hunter is the best looking of all the modern Smiths …

I agree.

IMG-0816.jpg


The model 610 is sharp with the unfluted cylinder.

I agree again.

IMG_0792.jpg
 
Last edited:
The classic hunter is my favorite pistol, but S&W has put out so many unfluted versions it has kinda lost its distinction. Nobody remembers it as a 1 in 5000.

Mine was tuned at the Bill Davis service center way back when.
 
I have a 25-7 5", which IIRC is my only unfluted revolver. I like it for other reasons. I doubt the flutes make much difference. I dislike the full lug barrels, which started on the 581/586/681/686 models as a purely cosmetic effort to compete with the Python. To me, a solution in search of a problem.
 
The classic hunter is my favorite pistol, but S&W has put out so many unfluted versions it has kinda lost its distinction. Nobody remembers it as a 1 in 5000.

Mine was tuned at the Bill Davis service center way back when.

I most certainly do. I have a lot of research tied up in them.
Those 5000 are the original Classic Hunter that Smith & Wesson introduced in the fall of 1987 it was called the Mystery Magnum and let readers compete for a chance to win one by sending in names suggestions and the name that was wound up chosen was the Classic Hunter and Lew Horton ordered 5000 of them
 
Much like a full underlug they only serve to make it heavier and uglier.
 
This thread reminds me about the guy that said the only Pickup truck worth having was the Ford F-150, because his dad drove one and his grandpa drove one and there was no reason to have a 4 wheel drive.......:eek:
 
Some of the Ruger Convertibles have one cylinder fluted and the other caliber unfluted. That's really neat because at a glance I can see what caliber I have.

An engraved unfluted cylinder looks really cool.

Fluted single action revolvers are cool because they look like cowboy guns.

Brass framed black powder revolvers with unfluted cylinders look really cool.

I have to say I like em both.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top