J-frame .22 magnum. Which model?

otis24 · Dec 17, 2020

I'm considering going from a Ruger LCP II .380 to a J frame .22 magnum for a Sunday go-to-meeting gun. Did they make an all steel hammerless .22 Magnum J frame? If so, what's the model number? This would be model number? This would be my first choice.

Second choice would be the same revolver with aluminum frame (i.e. Airweight). What is that model number?

Thanks in advance for your replys.

HardToHandle · Dec 17, 2020

The 351PD is the airweight.
Generally like mine but do not quite enjoy it. Heavy trigger and a bit slow to reload, but a dream weight wise. No reservations recommending regardless.
Model 351PD | Smith & Wesson

BigBoku · Dec 17, 2020

Off the top of my head the .22 MRF J frames were

650
651
351PD
351C

Love my 650 with the auxiliary.22LR cylinder

Kansasgunner · Dec 17, 2020

The only “Centennial “ enclosed hammer 22 Magnum is the 351C. It is an Airweight. If I remember correctly mine weighs 10.5 oz loaded, 7 rounds.

two-bit cowboy · Dec 17, 2020

I wish S&W made a steel Centennial model in 22 Magnum.

The aluminum framed one is the 351C.

I really like my 43C, 8-shot .22 Long Rifle, and I was going to have my lgs order the 351C for me, but I've read many disparaging remarks on the forum about it so I passed.

I'd recommend an older 2" Model 651 and have the hammer bobbed. Spendy, because they didn't make a lot of them.

ps: Kansasgunner is quicker than me!

noshow · Dec 17, 2020

The Model 650 3" Round Butt with Aux 22LR cylinder would be my only choice

Cal44 · Dec 17, 2020

I have a 650, but I don't have the 22lr extra cylinder.

It's an interesting variant with fixed sights. 3 inch bull barrel.

kraynky · Dec 17, 2020

I wanted the same thing, a light easy to carry 22 mag J frame. I watch every video I could find and tried to read all I could about what's available. It came down to two choices for me, the 351c and the 351pd. I ordered a 351pd, basically because (while both have pretty stiff trigger pulls), the pd can be cocked and fired single action style, with a not so bad trigger.

I wasn't concerned with pocket carry and hammer snag because I knew it would be holstered. If you plan on pocket carry, of course the 351c would be a smarter choice. My trigger is slowly getting better over the last 9 or 10 months, but I've worn out several 22 WMR snap caps getting it there.

It's been a good gun so far, and suits my needs just fine. I would recommend it to anyone. If you want a super light 22 mag (and don't need a pocket gun), and don't mind the cost, it's the ticket. I have no idea about current cost or availability tho.

foxy320 · Dec 17, 2020

Don't forget the blue steel model 51. I've got one of those & it's a good shooter. Very pricey now compared to when I bought mine.

Marshal Tom · Dec 17, 2020

I know you specified a S&W J frame but you could also consider a Ruger LCR in .22 Mag.

Dave.357 · Dec 18, 2020

Is 4” to large

2 model 63’s the one with after market grips has been
Fitted with .22 magnum cylinder, twice the fun.

MJK-MOD-547 · Dec 18, 2020

I have the 650 and 651. They are accurate. The cost for these today are too high.

I would be looking at a newer version of the .22 mag.

noshow · Dec 18, 2020

Cal44 said:
I have a 650, but I don't have the 22lr extra cylinder.

It's an interesting variant with fixed sights. 3 inch bull barrel.

Cal, should you want a LR cylinder, they are the exact same part# as the Mod 63. Mine was added by the Mothership just after buying the 650 new in "74.

jcelect · Dec 18, 2020

Mod 51 = 3 1/2" blue steel - discontinued
Mod 351PD = 2" w/hammer "Airlite" 2004-date
Mod 351C = 2" Centennial "Airlite" 2010-date
Mod 650 = 3" Heavy barrel SS no adj sight w/hammer discontinued
Mod 651 = 3" Heavy barrel 2" rare SS adj sight w/hammer discontinued
jcelect

Bob512 · Dec 18, 2020

I have the 351c and the 43c. I have enjoyed the 351c and it always goes with me on range days. The trigger was stiff at first and lightened up considerably with use.

I chose the 351c specifically for the hammerless option and concealed carry, it also very light weight

SAFireman · Dec 18, 2020

The 351C was my choice. I have a lot of SS Centennials, so this was a natural choice (plus they were having a blow-out sale...probably should have grabbed two).

J-frame .22 magnum. Which model?

otis24

Member

HardToHandle

Member

BigBoku

Member

Kansasgunner

Member

two-bit cowboy

US Veteran

noshow

Member

Attachments

Cal44

Member

Attachments

kraynky

Member

foxy320

Member

Marshal Tom

Member

Dave.357

Member

Attachments

MJK-MOD-547

Member

Attachments

noshow

Member

jcelect

US Veteran

Bob512

Member

SAFireman

Member

Attachments

Similar threads

Latest posts