28-2 or 19-4?

[4570Tom]

Hi, LGS has both a 28-2 and a 19-4 in the display case. Both are somewhat overpriced given the condition of the finish and the lack of original grips (both wearing pax) but they are within $50 of each other. $600 for the 28-2 and $550 for the 19-4. Both have 4 inch barrels. Both seem mechanically sound. Haven't tried yet to see if they would deal on either price.

I have a 6 inch Highway Patrolman, a 6 inch 19-5, and a 4 inch 586.

Use would primarily be for the range and occasional woods carry.

Given all that, does one strike folks as being a better choice than another?

Thanks.

 

[Golddollar]

Go for the Model 28-2. You're not planning to use either gun for a carry piece so you might was well take the bigger one.

 

[rkittine]

If it was a 27 I would agree, but a prefer the 19.

Bob

 

[EricR]

I would need pics. Assuming both TIGHT, I'd likely take the one in better overall condition. Not an easy choice as both are great pieces.

I have two 4" 28's, one 6" 28, and no 19's.

 

[arjay]

If it's mostly for range use and you plan to shoot lots of 357s,get the 28

 

[Eddietruett]

Buy both! That would get you better bargaining power

 

[OFT II]

If it was a 27 I would agree, but a prefer the 19.

Bob

I agree. It sounds like you have good range guns now. For carrying that 19 will be about five pounds lighter than the 28 at the end of the day.

 

[steelslaver]

The only advantages the 19 has is that it is lighter and easier to conceal. If either is a major concern get the 19, if not the 28. The 28 will survive more heavy rounds and probably be worth more in the future.

 

[robertrwalsh]

I am in agreement on the 28. For the use you intend for it that seems the most reasonable.

 

[squidsix]

19. Even if only because it gives you an option for CCW. You have fantastic choices for woods guns already.

 

[Targets Guy]

I have a

Model 28-2


and a Model 19-2


given your objective I would go with the Model 28.

 

[Breakaway500]

Both! Can't go wrong. As a coincidence,I just bought a 28-2 and a 19-4 from the forum classified,from one seller. I could not make a "which is better" choice..so....in the sake of saving myself the all that anguish and misery of a "wrong" choice..I bought both.

See if they will go for a discount package deal.

Life is too short to regret those tough decisions..

Just cleaning down the new arrivals today..

 

[Jack Flash]

Actually, the price on each is about par for the course with the gun shops in my area. That is, either one would be a decent buy hereabouts.

That would be a tough choice for me. It has often been said by some very smart folks that the M19 is the best choice for an all-around revolver. For extended full power .357 Magnum shooting however, the M28 would be a lot more comfortable for the shooter. Besides, the M28 is just as versatile, just a little bigger and heavier.

Since you already have one of each, albeit with six inch barrels, just buy the one you like the best or the one he is willing to give you the best deal on. Personally, I might lean toward the M28, but a 4" M19 is a mighty fine revolver too.

 

[lebomm]

I would incline toward the N frame, as well. The 19 is handy, but the 28 will handle any ammo you care to feed it (within reason), and do it for your lifetime and those of your next couple generations. Durability is its long suit.

Larry

 

[rgm36]

Go BIG - or go home

 

[Kurusu]

The only advantage of the 19 is it's light weight for everyday carry.
That said. I am a sucker for the N frames.

 

[gfors]

I don't have much of a collection, compared to others, here, but I do have a 4" 19-4 and a 4" 28-2. If forced to pick, I would take the Highway Patrolman. It fits my hand better, and will handle all the full house .357 I can afford.

 

[Babysitr]

I have both and love them both. make this decision on condition! The 28-2 in a 4" is just plain cool.!!!

 

[Abbynormal]

Anything you can do,
I can do better
I can do anything
Better than you.
No, you can't.
Yes, I can. No, you can't.
Yes, I can. No, you can't.
Yes, I can,
Yes, I can!
Anything you can be
I can be greater.
Sooner or later,
I'm greater than you.
No, you're not. Yes, I am.
No, you're not. Yes, I am.
No, you're NOT!. Yes, I am.
Yes, I am!
I can shoot a partridge
With a single cartridge.
I can get a sparrow
With a bow and arrow.
I can live on bread and cheese.
And only on that?
Yes.
So can a rat!
Any note you can reach
I can go higher.
I can sing anything
Higher than you.
No, you can't. (High)
Yes, I can. (Higher) No, you can't. (Higher)
Yes, I can. (Higher) No, you can't. (Higher)
Yes, I can. (Higher) No, you can't. (Higher)
Yes, I can. (Higher) No, you can't. (Higher)
Yes, I CAN! (Highest)
Anything you can buy
I can buy cheaper.
I can buy anything
Cheaper than you.
Fifty cents?
Forty cents! Thirty cents?
Twenty cents! No, you can't!
Yes, I can,
Yes, I can!
Anything you can say
I can say softer.
I can say anything
Softer than you.
No, you can't. (Softly)
Yes, I can. (Softer) No, you can't. (Softer)
Yes, I can. (Softer) No, you can't. (Softer)
Yes, I can. (Softer)
YES, I CAN! (Full volume)
I can drink my liquor
Faster than a flicker.
I can drink it quicker
And get even sicker!
I can open any safe.
Without bein' caught?
Sure.
That's what I thought--
you crook!
Any note you can hold
I can hold longer.
I can hold any note
Longer than you.
No, you can't.
Yes, I can No, you can't.
Yes, I can No, you can't.
Yes, I can
Yes, I-I-I-I-I-I-I-I-I No, you C-A-A-A-A-A-A-A-A-A-A-A-A-N'T--
CA-A-A-A-N! (Cough, cough!)
Yes, you ca-a-a-an!
Anything you can wear
I can wear better.
In what you wear
I'd look better than you.
In my coat?
In your vest! In my shoes?
In your hat! No, you can't!
Yes, I can
Yes, I CAN!
Anything you say
I can say faster.
I can say anything
Faster than you.
No, you can't. (Fast)
Yes, I can. (Faster) No, you can't. (Faster)
Yes, I can. (Faster) Noyoucan't. (Faster)
YesIcan! (Fastest)
I can jump a hurdle.
I can wear a girdle.
I can knit a sweater.
I can fill it better!
I can do most anything!
Can you bake a pie? No.
Neither can I.
Anything you can sing
I can sing sweeter.
I can sing anything
Sweeter than you.
No, you can't. (Sweetly)
Yes, I can. (Sweeter) No, you can't. (Sweeter)
Yes, I can. (Sweeter) No, you can't. (Sweeter)
Yes, I can. (Sweeter) No, you can't, can't, can't (sweeter)
Yes, I can, can, can (Sugary)
Yes, I can! No, you can't!

-Model 28-2 4"-

 

[apollo99]

28-2 4" would be my choice. Heavier duty, none of the K frame issues.

 

[John Fugate]

Hi, LGS has both a 28-2 and a 19-4 in the display case. Both are somewhat overpriced given the condition of the finish and the lack of original grips (both wearing pax) but they are within $50 of each other. $600 for the 28-2 and $550 for the 19-4. Both have 4 inch barrels. Both seem mechanically sound. Haven't tried yet to see if they would deal on either price.

I have a 6 inch Highway Patrolman, a 6 inch 19-5, and a 4 inch 586.

Use would primarily be for the range and occasional woods carry.

Given all that, does one strike folks as being a better choice than another?

Thanks.

Lets be logical. The guns are more less worth the same and in the same condition,, so thats not a factor. How big are your hands, that is what would determine which gun you should buy. Hold each gun in your hand and what fits you best is what I would buy. I buy XXL shirts ,,, even if I don't like the color. I might not be in style but I am going to be comfortable,, I never thought about it but If I were a Smith, I would definitely be an N frame.

 

[Jack Flash]

Lets be logical. ... How big are your hands, that is what would determine which gun you should buy. Hold each gun in your hand and what fits you best is what I would buy. ...

I don't know about that. By all accounts, Bill Jordan had huge hands, yet he favored the M19, for his purposes at least.

While it's true that a K-Frame will not be as sturdy as an N-Frame, I think too much has been made of the "problems" with K-Frames. How many of us have shot one to destruction?

The gentleman already has one of each, just with 6" barrels, so he knows what he is getting into either way. If he does decide to go on a binge and fire tens of thousands of full-power .357 Magnums, he can use the M28 he already has.

 

[CajunBass]

I'd buy one, and put the other on layaway.

 

[Kurusu]

I don't know about that. By all accounts, Bill Jordan had huge hands, yet he favored the M19, for his purposes at least.

While it's true that a K-Frame will not be as sturdy as an N-Frame, I think too much has been made of the "problems" with K-Frames. How many of us have shot one to destruction?

The gentleman already has one of each, just with 6" barrels, so he knows what he is getting into either way. If he does decide to go on a binge and fire tens of thousands of full-power .357 Magnums, he can use the M28 he already has.

His purpose was packing a .357 Mag all day round and no feel the extra weight on his hip. And he didn't really favored it. He kind of invented the concept.

 

[Joed49]

I started out with a 28-2. Sold it and purchased a 19-4 because it was lighter. Kept that 19-4 for 20 years and sold it to buy a 28-2. Think about that one.

My favorite S&W revolvers are the K frames for carry. No other revolver fits my hand as well as a square butt K frame. For hunting it's the N frame, hands down.

Depends more on what you plan to use the gun for. The 28-2 is a tank and will last forever. The 19-4 is light and can be carried all day long.

 

[bananaman]

I only have 1 K Frame .357. 66-2, 2.5". It does not get magnum loads. I have 3, L Frame revolvers in .357. Then my 28, 6" no dash. Have never owned a 19. The right 1 never presented itself. Based on what your stated needs are, I would go with the 28, or take a look at the L's. Bob

 

[gfors]

His purpose was packing a .357 Mag all day round and no feel the extra weight on his hip. And he didn't really favored it. He kind of invented the concept.

He was also a noted hip-shooter. Could be favored the smaller frame, because it was quicker to point. He had enormous hands, and put oversize stocks on his 19.

 

[oddshooter]

The OP has three of my favs: 19, 28, 586

I couldn't agree less with the posts.
Just because he asked a silly question, doesn't mean you have to answer it. Rather than answer, let's try to help.

The OP wrote:
"Both are somewhat overpriced given the condition of the finish and the lack of original grips (both wearing pax)"

This would stop me unless I had buyitis with money burning a hole in my pocket.
He already has a sample of both. This is my second Stop.

He needs something different to play with even it he doesn't know it. Model 13, 14, 15 are all outstanding. I think I would add an SAA for fun and history.



Prescut

 

[BoCash]

I'd buy one, and put the other on layaway.

See Cajun's answer.. LIFE IS SHORT!!

Y'all take care, Bo

 

[stansdds]

Hi, LGS has both a 28-2 and a 19-4 in the display case.

Use would primarily be for the range and occasional woods carry.

Given all that, does one strike folks as being a better choice than another?

Thanks.

Primarily to be used on the range and occasional woods carry? 28-2, hands down. The 28-2 will stand up to more magnum loads than the 19-4.