38 Super in a 38 Special

Hey....I'm neutral here guys. I have both semi-autos and revolvers and I will just share something I learned. I lean toward a good functioning semi-auto myself in a fire-fight....(as well as most Police Departments and the military), but I finally got around to getting a moon-clip revolver and it may surprise you to know that you can almost load a moonie revolver as fast as you can a magazine-fed semi-auto. With practice....it's amazing what you can do with a moon-clip revolver. I have seen video's of the "trick-shooters" that can empty a revolver with moon-clips twice in something like under 4 seconds. 12-shots in under 4-seconds from a revolver....amazing.
 
Redhawks oldman got it right,.357 mag 5 different ammos, 38sp38s&w 38 super 38acp &.357 mag.............survival gun
 
If you search the pawn shops, gun buy backs and other places that specialize in collecting antique firearms, you just might run across the 21 caliber, interchangeable ammo Colt Model 17, or perhaps, the Phillips & Rodgers, made until 1996, that also could shoot up to 27 different sizes of ammo and up to 101 different rounds at last count through its magic cylinder.



NOW - I'm looking for a ubiquitous wheel gun to serve as an alternate weapon or tradeable commodity should we shift into the proverbial SHTF/SOL/OMG "there goes the neighborhood" scenario.


Ammo and food will be the#1 priorities (after drinkable water that you can make yourself if you have to).

So, having something on hand, like a revolver that could fire just about anything except suppositories might come in handy.

Since a .357 Mag will already fire six to ten different common rounds and the Phillips & Rodgers has been seen reliably firing up to 101 different rounds (if it's round and not built like Rosie O' Donnell) it will work), I've been calling up as many curio shops, colllectible lawn dwellers, antique dealers, pawn shops, used things that go bang, and lastly, but not least, my local sheriff's gun buyback programs where they get the ill-bergotten gats off the street and sell them to the public for a song (hold the song if you like). Bought a pair of S&W J Frames that one of the local Bonnie & Clydes decided they didn't need anymore after they successfully sat through 6 months of court ordered anger management.


Yes, the .44 Magnum is a lot bigger and makes artificial intestines almost as good as Dr. Carson - but the .357 Mag. is my Mary Poppins that is quite capable of sharing a little Christmas or Chanukah spirit while keeping the nasty green Grinch dressed in all black pajamas from coming down the pipe and stealing it.


Ho. Ho. Holy sh*t!
 
Last edited:
l have some ''Super'' 38 Super ammo. From my ''Super Vel'' ammo collection l shot a few rds from a partial box in my Model SW 28-2. lt put out quite a muzzle flash...Kinda equal to their old 110gr .357 loads..l only did it because l ''COULD''
 
Have a Colt 1911 in the aforementioned round and love it. BTW all of the 38 Super that I have purchased in the last few years have been marked +P.
 
The Medusa. Barrels of fun

medusamixedace.jpg
 
S&W Airweight

Last Saturday, March 11, 2017, I was privy to something I didn't realize was possible.
An older woman neighbor, had purchased a new S&W 637 Airweight from Sportsman's Warehouse. She had previously owned a Taurus .38 snubby, but really didn't know a lot about guns.
The person at SW, also sold her two boxes of Winchester .38 Super Auto +P, telling her this is what was needed for her new gun. She did not have a clue and took him at his word.

She called me up and asked if I would meet her out in the woods where she was trying out her new gun. After firing 5 rounds, she thought the recoil was way too much and called me requesting my assistance out there. Having little to do at that moment, I agreed and drove out to meet with her. Upon my arrival, she had already ejected the spent cases in the gravel and reloaded with another 5 rounds. I said well shoot a few more and I will listen and watch the gun recoil. She shot 3 more and I stopped her because her thumb was bleeding in the web area of her right hand. I told her it did sound very loud for standard .38 loads and the recoil was fierce for her.
She swung the cylinder open and I asked her to hand me the gun. I ejected the 3 spent cases and the two live ones.
That's when I realized that she had the wrong ammo. I also realized that she had an injury to the left thumb as well, because the right hand hurt and she tried shooting left handed. Both were cut open, from her hand sliding up onto the frame from the recoil. I stopped her from going any further, due to the danger I realized was imminent. She fired a total of 8 rounds. All loaded and ejected just fine, and none of the cases were split. I inspected the gun and it appears to be sound.
She took the ammo back to SW, told them what happened and they replaced that ammo with 5 boxes of .38 special and apologized for the screw up.
 
This is the only story I have about this and since it happened to ME, I will tell it. I took a Super 38 Colt {at least that is what it and all others of the Colt variety say on the barrel hood}, on a trade with 1K rounds of ammo. Having no use for it, I traded it. Then over a period of a couple of months I shot all the ammo in several different .38 specials. Steel went "ping" and it poked nice holes in cardboard. No damage, just fun. That's my story on this subject.
 
I just had to respond when I saw this. Be VERY careful. There is a story behind the 38 Super. Once you have read it, make your own decision. I know a lot about this cartridge because I have shot it for over 11 years.

...

Trouble is, (1) it was not very accurate, as the cartridge headspaced on the rim and (2) a bunch of very cheap pistols were imported that were rather weak to handle the cartridge. Because of the first reason, not many people actually used it. Because of the second reason, ammunition manufacturers REALLY watered down the 38 Super cartridges they produced and sold. The round sort of languished.

This is incorrect. .38 Super headspaces on the rim. The problem is that the early barrels made for it headspaced off of the mouth of the case. The cartridge was fine, the guys at the Colt factory were...well, I don't know what they were thinking.

If you had an aftermarket barrel installed that properly headspaced the cartridge, .38 Super was a real tackdriver.

I think Taffin has an article on this in the current issue of Handgunner. But I know he's definitely written about it in the past.
 
...since my last post...

Sold one of the 686-7s and sent several cylinders to TK Custom for rechambering to .38 Super...the guns all had second cylinders fitted...

S&W 60-10 3" adjustable sight .357
S&W 66-2 3" Ashland Special
S&W 649-1(?) .38 Special...

They all shoot great. The original .38s or .357s will fire in the rechambered cylinders but there is some case swelling as the .38 Super is just a hair larger in the body...

Shown is the modified cylinder for moon clips...they will run Super ammo without moon clips but ejection is iffy...
 

Attachments

  • 007_zpshyo3dapx.jpg
    007_zpshyo3dapx.jpg
    116.6 KB · Views: 25
  • 010_zpsw3sqscbl.jpg
    010_zpsw3sqscbl.jpg
    116.2 KB · Views: 24
  • 004_zpsbl7j6jbl.jpg
    004_zpsbl7j6jbl.jpg
    112.6 KB · Views: 25
  • 014_zpslaqxajda.jpg
    014_zpslaqxajda.jpg
    117.8 KB · Views: 26
  • 073_zpsjadcwlot.jpg
    073_zpsjadcwlot.jpg
    117.7 KB · Views: 27
Last edited:
This is incorrect. .38 Super headspaces on the rim. The problem is that the early barrels made for it headspaced off of the mouth of the case. The cartridge was fine, the guys at the Colt factory were...well, I don't know what they were thinking.

If you had an aftermarket barrel installed that properly headspaced the cartridge, .38 Super was a real tackdriver.

I think Taffin has an article on this in the current issue of Handgunner. But I know he's definitely written about it in the past.

...you have it reversed... The original 1903/.38 ACP and the COLT SUPER .38 1911 headspaced off the case rim...it was not till the 1970s when BarSto started making replacement barrels that headspaced off the case mouth like a .45 ACP that the 1911 in .38 Super became a tackdriver...
 
Exactly it's the chamber pressure.

But most argue about a Llama Extra in 9 mm largo. Some shoot any round that fits it. Even the shorter 9 mm x 19 letting the extractor head space the round instead of the barrel. Or they shoot 38super. Just an example food for thought.

Hmmm letting the extractor headspace the round there's an idea?
But think with a knotched cam opposite the extractor. Not just thinking out loud.
 
Last edited:
FWIW this thread got me remembering my experiments reloading .38 Super and trying to get them to fit a S&W chamber. Not with much success I might add.
However I remembered I have a box of Sig 125 FMJ .38/Super, so I pulled one and tried it in my 66-8 and my 19-5. Chambered perfectly in both guns.
Not saying I'll shoot them in these guns, although the 66-8 snubby tempts me.... maybe when ammo is easier to find, if ever.
 
I think this thread will have some renewed interest as it looks like picking will be slim for some time, perhaps several years.

But, as we've seen, manufacturers appear to be adapting and focusing more on the common calibers. .38 Special and .357 Magnum are A LOT more common than .38 Super.

My take on the entire thread: it's possible, but less than ideal. Better than shooting .45 Colt from a .410 shotgun to be sure, but not what it was designed to do.
 
I sent my 442 cylinder to TK custom and had it re-chambered with moon clips for 9mm and it shoots great. I can still shoot 38's they recommend not using 9mm+p ammo because the empty's will stick in the cylinder. 9mm is loaded to higher pressure then +p 38spl.
 

Attachments

  • E42CD5C6-5D69-4C0D-A957-F0DFEBBC53DF.jpg
    E42CD5C6-5D69-4C0D-A957-F0DFEBBC53DF.jpg
    82.1 KB · Views: 7
  • DAE15C0A-DF4B-4B26-929D-9BE929F7B9DD.jpg
    DAE15C0A-DF4B-4B26-929D-9BE929F7B9DD.jpg
    92.6 KB · Views: 7
Last edited:
Some technical notes:

1. .38 Super +P in a .38 Special is *not* listed in the "Unsafe Combinations" Data Sheet at SAMMI. Of course there's a lot of things I could come up with that also aren't on that sheet. They only list .380 and .357 as an unsafe combination in the .38 Special.

2. All .38 Super ammo is +P. SAMMI has no designation for .38 Super without the +P affixed. Some years ago they did this to try and further differentiate it from the parent .38 ACP which of course has an identical case.

There's a bunch of obsolete European 9mm's out there that could theoretically chamber a .38 Super if their chamber/extractor was sloppy enough. I'm talking about 9mm Largo, 9mm Steyr. These are the guns the ammo manufacturers were worried about the .38 Super finding it's way into.
 
This seems to be a pointless thread. Why not use a handgun chambered for the .38 Super if you want to shoot .38 Super ammo and be content with using .38 Special ammo in revolvers so chambered? "Because it will work" in the wrong gun leaves lots of room for anything but sane interpretation.
 
A little knowledge can be bad

First time poster here and hoping I'm not to far off topic. Posting a cautionary tale. In this ammo shortage I stopped into a chain store while on a getaway and thought I hit an ammo goldmine. My son in laws and I have modern revolvers that take 38.
I bought six boxes of 50 "Remmington 38 s&w wheelgun" ammunition not knowing that it would not work in our modern revolvers. Shame on me. I had no clue that 38 s&w was a specific caliber for antique firearms. Now trying to find a buyer.
 
Back
Top